Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[Saints_Man]

Oliver v Walsh v Boak? I've got Macrae, Titch, Merrett and Brayshaw as my other mid premos already

 

[Northernsoul74]

Oliver v Walsh v Boak? I've got Macrae, Titch, Merrett and Brayshaw as my other mid premos already

Oliver.

 

[Hack_Watts]

Lyons vs Boak vs Duncan

Lyons Easily. Huge CBA numbers and super consistency. Boak and Duncan will drop off at the pointy end you'd think?

 

[Choppers]

Salem v Mills........have Ridley Short Stewart Daniel

 

[Hack_Watts]

Petracca (110) and Hind (90)

(A Scott On Field - Gulden Traded)

Vs

Hawkins (90) and Brayshaw (105)

(Gulden on Field - Rowe Traded)

Vs

Brayshaw (105) and Laird (105)

(A Scott on Field - Gulden Traded)

 

[Hack_Watts]

Salem v Mills........have Ridley Short Stewart Daniel

Mills for sure.

 

[Choppers]

Mills for sure.

Thanks, just the push I needed....

 

[Significant]

Petracca (110) and Hind (90)

(A Scott On Field - Gulden Traded)

Vs

Hawkins (90) and Brayshaw (105)

(Gulden on Field - Rowe Traded)

Vs

Brayshaw (105) and Laird (105)

(A Scott on Field - Gulden Traded)

The whole Gulden discussion has been worthwhile and made me think of keeping him now.
Has tough games against Geelong and Demons coming up, but then goes on a run of Pies, Freo, Blues, Saints, Hawks before his bye where he and Warner may be perfectly upgraded to a Macrae.

Can you do someone more consistent than Hawkins? Sidey? Zorko?

 

[Hack_Watts]

The whole Gulden discussion has been worthwhile and made me think of keeping him now.
Has tough games against Geelong and Demons coming up, but then goes on a run of Pies, Freo, Blues, Saints, Hawks before his bye where he and Warner may be perfectly upgraded to a Macrae.

Can you do someone more consistent than Hawkins? Sidey? Zorko?

Brain says Sidey. Zork throws up stinkers and is surprisingly undisciplined for a leader of the club.

Having said that Sidey and Zorko are more expensive and would mean I have to take a Brayshaw type over an SP like Oliver or Trac. Trac could average 120.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Salem v Mills........have Ridley Short Stewart Daniel

Mills

 

[rocker_oz33]

Brain says Sidey. Zork throws up stinkers and is surprisingly undisciplined for a leader of the club.

Having said that Sidey and Zorko are more expensive and would mean I have to take a Brayshaw type over an SP like Oliver or Trac. Trac could average 120.

I want tracc .

But I'll have to wait till Flynn gets fat.

 

[Choppers]

Mills

Cheers.....I agree.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Cheers.....I agree.

He looks to be a top 5 Def.

Lloyd..Rids.
Larid..mills.
Stewart..Houston.

 

[No eye deer]

He looks to be a top 5 Def.

Lloyd..Rids.
Larid..mills.
Stewart..Houston.

He looks to be a top 5 Def.

Lloyd..Rids.
Larid..mills.
Stewart..Houston.

Ryan not in the mix?

 

[Max the great]

Duncan vs Walsh

Walsh easily. Love that people are getting sucked into Duncan.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Ryan not in the mix?

I always forget someone.

Ryan.
Whitfield on avg not total points

 

[zoomba23]

Walsh easily. Love that people are getting sucked into Duncan.

Duncan’s been a very handy POD premo for years. Hasn’t had a season below 103 since 2016. ‘Getting sucked in’ is not the phrase

 

[MagicGnome97]

bont vs walsh

 

[Max the great]

Duncan’s been a very handy POD premo for years. Hasn’t had a season below 103 since 2016. ‘Getting sucked in’ is not the phrase

He started last year like a house on fire and scored 760 points in his last 8 games last year. Going to spend 580k on a player who isn't an uber premo mid that can do that? Good luck.

 

[toxic]

bont vs walsh

Bont

 

[Me Myself and I]

bont vs walsh

Bont

 

[Me Myself and I]

Boak & Robertson v Walsh & Farrar. Can't do W & R 2k short.

 

[ILY Leonard]

Maynard vs Ash?
Phillips vs Membrey?

ROS in a draft league

 

[Northernsoul74]

Duncan’s been a very handy POD premo for years. Hasn’t had a season below 103 since 2016. ‘Getting sucked in’ is not the phrase

I brought him last year and was very average after his hot start.

 

[Barnzy]

Bont vs Tracc?