Showing your age.... as John Hughes would say with a bent digit - ‘Absolutely’
....Although only 1 game
List Mgmt. 2021 List Management: Draft, Trade, Free Agency and Academy
- Thread starter Lach72
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
....Although only 1 game
Count me delusional.
Weideman is ok and will get another shot elsewhere in Vic if he doesn’t find himself breaking into the Demons team.
As for Schache absolute spud. Will be dropped back to VFL and as mentioned if he wasn’t no. 2 pick would be playing Vic Amateurs.
No point trading in someone just because they are 194cm plus. I’m not necessarily advocating second tier KPF but we can do a lot better than Schache.
That’s because he himself is shocking. He gets a fresh start why? Most of the time he gets caught out defensively. His attitude on the field is poor. We’re not going to go down that route of offering fresh starts. We have better players around.
Schache definitely. However bulldogs probably would ask for Cerra in return. Forwards don’t need smarts these days.
Be tall, Mark the ball, kick goals. That’s it. Oscar Allen has demonstrated that perfectly this season. Be nice if Lobb does too.
Weideman would be a great get.
- Jun 6, 2010
- 4,030
- 12,851
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Dillon Panthers
I would’ve been 9 years old when Darren Bolton played his 2 games for Freo in 1999.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
One of those things is arguably the most difficult skill in AFL.
It’s a bit like saying in golf, all you have to do is hit the ball straight and sink putts. Easy.
Jesus Christ. Schache for Cerra? If there’s even a chance that happens fold the club and be done with it. Schache was just about the worst player on the ground last night. Even Beveridge (politely) admitted he was s**t in the presser afterwards. I don’t think he’ll ever play again for the Dogs unless there’s a serious injury crisis.
I can’t understand how anyone could watch that game and say “I want that guy on our list”
Josh Treacy is already 10 times more effective than Schache after 3 games of his career.
Schache vs Treacy is the prime example how to draft.
Forget the heights and skills, first question should be, are they competitive ?
Jack Watts vs Nick Nat.
Treacy is a competitive beast and Schache is a loopy leaf.
Last edited:
Recommitted - Josh Schache [contracted and staying at Western Bulldogs]
Highly doubt he will get another game with us He has another year on his contract so you would think he does Doggies are desperate for a KPD and with Josh now clear not going to make it as a foward they should just play him in defence in the vfl just to see if he has that ability or can...
www.bigfooty.com
Look at the comments on page 3 of this thread and they sum up pretty well why this guy will never make it.
Assessing this criteria.
Schache is good at being tall...
That is it.One out of three ain’t bad - give them our first pick.
Worth the Bulldogs giving him a crack in the backline because AFL level he is no where near it as a forward. Sure kicked a few goals in VFL. Anyone remember Ryan Murphy and Brendan Fewster.
Recommitted - Josh Schache [contracted and staying at Western Bulldogs]
Highly doubt he will get another game with us He has another year on his contract so you would think he does Doggies are desperate for a KPD and with Josh now clear not going to make it as a foward they should just play him in defence in the vfl just to see if he has that ability or can...
Look at the comments on page 3 of this thread and they sum up pretty well why this guy will never make it.
He’s a clean cut Dardy.
Thinking Schache is verging on salary dump territory tbh. He’s contracted for next year as well... There’s no way we’d be trading any more than a third rounder for him.
Weideman probably would hinder our draft position more than we’d want. He’s a pretty decent player just at the wrong club imo.
I find it interesting some people want to recruit Hugh Dixon back. CBF checking whether it’s the same posters that are saying Schache and Weideman are spuds but boy those people would be delusional if they were.
I think we need another tall on list that isn’t an 18 year old draftee tbh. I would not willing to trade a first or second rounder. I’m realistic though - if we recruit said player they’re going to be kind of sh*te but they’ll most likely offer more than Treacy or an 18 year draftee would in the next two-three seasons. If Treacy or an 18 year draftee develop freakishly quickly then so be it - that’s good for the club.
Weideman probably would hinder our draft position more than we’d want. He’s a pretty decent player just at the wrong club imo.
I find it interesting some people want to recruit Hugh Dixon back. CBF checking whether it’s the same posters that are saying Schache and Weideman are spuds but boy those people would be delusional if they were.
I think we need another tall on list that isn’t an 18 year old draftee tbh. I would not willing to trade a first or second rounder. I’m realistic though - if we recruit said player they’re going to be kind of sh*te but they’ll most likely offer more than Treacy or an 18 year draftee would in the next two-three seasons. If Treacy or an 18 year draftee develop freakishly quickly then so be it - that’s good for the club.
Dixon will have to be kicking 3-4 goals a game to even be considered. Has the work ethic of a pea heart. Talent is there but gee that and Tabs’ work rate and he could be something.
More inclined to give Strnadica another chance then him.
How many would pick Bolton ahead of Logue if you could re-do the 2016 draft?
Probably not the best time to ask with potentially both Ryan and Cox out. Logue might be our only KPD left to take on a very tall WC forward line. Bolton wouldn't help us with that.
Hearing Hogan is rooming with Mumford, I wonder if we do enough of this to get the best out of all players.
wakojako
Norm Smith Medallist
- Nov 15, 2020
- 6,268
- 10,084
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
The only reason they are rooming is so Hogan can do lines off Mummy's ass.
Rack The Crack
Hes from WA though. What are we going to do? Move him out of his mums house to move in with a Freo player?
In all seriousness I think he was living with Lachie Schultz
white line fever
With hindsight, absolutely.
played two
Purple Jesus
not jess
Have a look at Walters Instagram and tell me we’re not into Bolton.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
