When do they do the Michael Voss tribute to Robert Harvey ? That seemed to run longer than Harvey's actual career.
List Mgmt. 2021 Mid-Season Draft
- Thread starter Jeremias
- Start date
- Tagged users None
When do they do the Michael Voss tribute to Robert Harvey ? That seemed to run longer than Harvey's actual career.
- May 1, 2016
- 28,818
- 56,171
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #151
My impression as well.
People need to realize, at VFL level Cas would go beyond domination. He'd kick 30+ goals a season as a ruckman, or 50+ as a KPF, or captain a team as a KPD. He's bigger, stronger, fitter and more agile than most his size and height.
Wooller is one to monitor, but I don't see him possessing AFL attributes.
While Stengle is free to find a new AFL home next month, some clubs are keen to see how he performs over the length of a full season.
Should he be recruited to move to Melbourne, Stengle would likely link up with former Crows teammate and Carlton veteran Eddie Betts who remains a close mentor. Betts and Stengle also shared time together late last year.
www.afl.com.au
Should he be recruited to move to Melbourne, Stengle would likely link up with former Crows teammate and Carlton veteran Eddie Betts who remains a close mentor. Betts and Stengle also shared time together late last year.
Key to Tigers' mid-season draft, backline move to pay off with sweet deal
Callum Twomey, Mitch Cleary and Michael Whiting with all the latest trade news
www.afl.com.au
You need to stop reading Bigfooty before bedtime.Even in my dreams, the Carlton team selection and coaching sucks
- May 1, 2016
- 28,818
- 56,171
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #154
Would be cheap, question becomes is he worth another chance?While Stengle is free to find a new AFL home next month, some clubs are keen to see how he performs over the length of a full season.
Should he be recruited to move to Melbourne, Stengle would likely link up with former Crows teammate and Carlton veteran Eddie Betts who remains a close mentor. Betts and Stengle also shared time together late last year.
Key to Tigers' mid-season draft, backline move to pay off with sweet deal
Callum Twomey, Mitch Cleary and Michael Whiting with all the latest trade news
I've not watched enough of him playing.
- Nov 3, 2020
- 3,023
- 11,199
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Sandringham Zebras, Melbourne Renegades
I honestly don't see why we should pick him up. I get the connection with Betts, but it just takes up a list spot which we could use elsewhere. I think Owies, Durdin, Philp, Honey, Fisher, Fog and Cunners are enough young small-mid forwards to develop.While Stengle is free to find a new AFL home next month, some clubs are keen to see how he performs over the length of a full season.
Should he be recruited to move to Melbourne, Stengle would likely link up with former Crows teammate and Carlton veteran Eddie Betts who remains a close mentor. Betts and Stengle also shared time together late last year.
Key to Tigers' mid-season draft, backline move to pay off with sweet deal
Callum Twomey, Mitch Cleary and Michael Whiting with all the latest trade news
ferrisb
Brownlow Medallist
Every player deserves a 2nd chance.
Stengle is at least up to his 4th by now.
Hard pass.
ferrisb
Brownlow Medallist
Not old enough for Geelong...
Stengle under Betts tutelage would be a wise selection. Very talented and brings something none of our small forwards do.
- Banned
- #159
You got my joke
- Sep 30, 2014
- 1,444
- 2,575
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Throw in kebab stack & willie no bongs Rioli
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,160
- 100,963
- AFL Club
- Carlton
We have other needs addressed before another small forward
- Aug 16, 2015
- 10,959
- 18,404
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
Would any harm come out of picking him and putting him on a 6 month trial? VFL only and if you stay out of trouble, you will get an extension.
TENACIOUS
Premiership Player
- Aug 16, 2008
- 3,179
- 12,497
- AFL Club
- Carlton
While Stengle is free to find a new AFL home next month, some clubs are keen to see how he performs over the length of a full season.
Should he be recruited to move to Melbourne, Stengle would likely link up with former Crows teammate and Carlton veteran Eddie Betts who remains a close mentor. Betts and Stengle also shared time together late last year.
Key to Tigers' mid-season draft, backline move to pay off with sweet deal
Callum Twomey, Mitch Cleary and Michael Whiting with all the latest trade news
If his the guy the club want, then I'd back their judgement in..
Drug issues aside...
From memory, he wasn't actually that good, was he?
thylacine60
Premium Platinum
- Banned
- #164
however good he was, we can make him worse..........
TENACIOUS
Premiership Player
- Aug 16, 2008
- 3,179
- 12,497
- AFL Club
- Carlton
however bad he was, we can make him better.............................
The Return of the Paf
Club Legend
- Aug 22, 2020
- 1,355
- 1,601
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Last edited:
- May 1, 2016
- 28,818
- 56,171
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #167
I think there's an element of permissiveness to Richmond's current status quo; they've talked about honesty, and working together and being who they are, the freedom to express themselves etc, but so too has there been incidents concerning not indiscipline from a footy context but a societal one. They viciously protect their own from their societal responsibilities, using their reach to intervene and set the narrative.
One imagines going from a hyper-discipline context in Pyke's Adelaide to an ultra-permissive Richmond could lead to something like this. Richmond's culture is about bringing out one's personality and contributing on that basis; the question becomes could we actually bring him in and seek to curb that a bit?
I don't know, I suppose, is my answer. But it would be a risk.
Last edited:
I'd prefer Tyrone Thorne from WA.
I don't think Stengle is good enough on ability, let alone with the baggage.
Pass thanks.
Pass thanks.
Take McKay as a F/S in the normal draft unless he is best available.
Take the best available player at our pick. If they fill a hole that's a bonus, if they upgrade on a player who plays seniors regularly that's a bonus as well.
Don't worry so much about recruiting for this season, this season is not our season.
Take the best available player at our pick. If they fill a hole that's a bonus, if they upgrade on a player who plays seniors regularly that's a bonus as well.
Don't worry so much about recruiting for this season, this season is not our season.
- Aug 22, 2014
- 13,676
- 49,683
- AFL Club
- Carlton
FTFY
The Return of the Paf
Club Legend
- Aug 22, 2020
- 1,355
- 1,601
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I just had a thought (first time for everything) and I'm thinking some clubs may have hidden a few draft targets in their local leagues. I think there'll be a number of players drafted that just aren't being talked about.
Nothing more certain. While he may have dropped off the radar or gone down another path, Henry Walsh playing local footy, but on Geelong Falcon’s roster “to join at a later date”. Giving two other prospects some time to shine supposedly. Sounds classic Cats move, their quota coming direct from local footy off the charts.
There are more seemingly good ruck prospects than I could count on one hand (without Walsh). Unless we opt to get ahead of the curve taking Charlie McKay if we believe he would end up in the first couple of rounds next year, or perhaps an obscure KPP hiding somewhere, surely we take a project ruck.
Levi’s rapid decline, knee and form makes his tenure very shaky. We would surely be in the market for two developing or back up rucks to support TDK and Pitto.
Not the right thread, but to make such a statement, you must look at their talls. They have more than 5 possibles, but......
Hawkins almost 33, partnered by Cameron (28) up forward. Ratugolea forward/ruck when he can get up.
Pretty much guarantee Jenkins and Fort will be gone at season’s end.
You mention Neale as a ruck. He played predominately forward in the WA colts with short stints in the ruck. View him as the Hawkins replacement, not a first string ruck. Ratugolea, when he can get on the park has been talked of as a ruck, but only 198cm. More forward than ruck.
Stanley 31 by season’s end is still bouncing in and out of the side despite being their no. 1 ruck. No long term guarantee and they have young rookie speculative Tsapatolis in his first season.
Down back Henderson pushing 32 is partnered by 30 yo Blicavs who doubles as ruck, wing and whatever. Mature draftee Krueger not yet given a game is a swing man. Throw in under sized jet Stewart and workmanlike 3rd tall Kolodjashnij and the balance is thin.
The current great white hope is SDK, De Koning the younger who has played forward, ruck and defence.
So for your assertions, they do not have a bankable first ruck beyond this season.
If Neale more forward, and I think he is, similarly Ratugolea, and SDK is likely a defender to succeed Hendo and/or Blicavs.
So Stanley who can’t cement at first ruck after many years, Fort who can’t get a game at 28, Jenkins the Hawkins insurance out of contract and rookie Tsapatolis and pinch hitters is their ruck division with no room for additions.
Think again.
I have no idea if Henry is on their radar, but your statement is just wrong.
Similar threads
