Phantom Draft Big_Newon Phantom Draft

[Big_Newon]

Please don't criticise this because I had a few sleepless nights thinking about the Bulldogs and Brisbane picks. I havent taken points off teams like Collingwood and Bulldogs for matching father son bids because its too much of a hassle. Anyway i gave it a crack so i hope you agree with some of the picks.




July Phantom Draft:

1st Round:

Pick 1: Western Bulldogs: Sam Darcy

Pick 2: Collingwood: Nick Daicos

Pick 3: North Melbourne: Jason Horne

Pick 4: Hawthorn: Finn Callaghan

Pick 5: Adelaide: Josh Gibcus

Pick 6: GWS: Josh Sinn

Pick 7: Gold Coast: Matthew Roberts

Pick 8: Carlton: Ben Hobbs

Pick 9: Richmond: Josh Rachele

Pick 10: Essendon: Jack Williams

Pick 11: GWS: Matthew Johnson

Pick 12: St Kilda: Jye Amiss

Pick 13: GWS: Joshua Fahey

Pick 14: Gold Coast: Bodhi Uwhland

Pick 15: West Coast: Darcy Wilmot

Pick 16: Fremantle: Arlo Draper

Pick 17: Sydney: Rhett Bazzo

Pick 18: Port Adelaide: Mac Andrew

Pick 19: Brisbane: Jacob Van Rooyen

Pick 20: Richmond: Tyler Sonsie

Pick 21: Western Bulldogs: Sam Butler

Multiple players found. Use birthday to differentiate. eg [PLAYERCARD="23/11/1962"]Joe Smith[/PLAYERCARD]

Pick 22: Brisbane: Neil Erasmus

Bit of Second Round:

Pick 23: North Melbourne: Josh Goater

Pick 24: Hawthorn: Josh Ward

Pick 25: Adelaide: Judson Clarke

Pick 26: Hawthorn: Connor Macdonald

Pick 27: Gold Coast: Ned Long

Pick 28: Carlton: Cooper Murley

Pick 29: Richmond: Blake Howes

Pick 30: Geelong: Lewis Rayson

Pick 31: Geelong: Sam Breuer

Pick 32: Richmond: Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera

Pick 33: West Coast: Lachlan Rankin

Pick 34: Fremantle: Joshua Browne

Pick 35: Sydney: Hugh Jackson

 

[PMBangers]

Interested to know why you don't have us (GWS) matching West Coasts bid for Josh Fahey? Do we just have too much of his sort?

 

[daniel23]

Arlo draper is going to have a tough choice deciding if he wants to play for Fremantle or Western bulldogs

 

[briztoon]

**This is not a criticism**

You have Arlo Draper being drafted by both Fremantle and Bulldogs.

Josh Faye is tied to GWS, who will 100% match the bid. There is no restriction on Northern academies matching their kids in the first round.

Erasmus is a good first pick for Brisbane. Would have preferred Jacob Van Rooyen.


**this is an observation**
Whoa, buck the truck up, how is Josh Goater not drafted by anyone? I would be throwing a shoe at the television if we passed on Goater if he was still available.

 

[Mutineer]

Crows would almost be a certainty to take a midfielder, hard to see them taking a KPD with young tall defenders Jordan Butts, Nick Murray, Fischer McAsey

3

Fischer Mcasey

Age

23

Ht

196cm

Wt

96kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

6.8

2star

K

3.3

1star

HB

3.5

3star

M

1.8

2star

T

1.3

3star

MG

102.3

2star

D

6.8

1star

K

3.3

1star

HB

3.5

2star

M

1.8

2star

T

1.3

2star

MG

102.3

2star

D

7.2

2star

K

3.6

2star

HB

3.6

3star

M

1.8

2star

T

1.6

4star

MG

114.8

2star

, Josh Worrell, and James Borlase on the list already.

 

[Turbocat]

No Goater or MacDonald in the top20 ... as Geelong only has picks in the 20's I guess I could have that sort of quality slips thru..

 

[Dewyyyyy]

**This is not a criticism**

You have Arlo Draper being drafted by both Fremantle and Bulldogs.

Josh Faye is tied to GWS, who will 100% match the bid. There is no restriction on Northern academies matching their kids in the first round.

Erasmus is a good first pick for Brisbane. Would have preferred Jacob Van Rooyen.


**this is an observation**
Whoa, buck the truck up, how is Josh Goater not drafted by anyone? I would be throwing a shoe at the television if we passed on Goater if he was still available.

Goater could push top 5 if his form was like he played the other day.

 

[Big_Newon]

**This is not a criticism**

You have Arlo Draper being drafted by both Fremantle and Bulldogs.

Josh Faye is tied to GWS, who will 100% match the bid. There is no restriction on Northern academies matching their kids in the first round.

Erasmus is a good first pick for Brisbane. Would have preferred Jacob Van Rooyen.


**this is an observation**
Whoa, buck the truck up, how is Josh Goater not drafted by anyone? I would be throwing a shoe at the television if we passed on Goater if he was still available.

Thats my bad. Sorry about that. What do you think the dogs needs are? Its hard to see any holes on their list. Maybe a half back or back pocket like Bodhi Uwlhand.

 

[Big_Newon]

Sorry guys for the mistakes. I will change it now to satisfy your observations.

 

[PMBangers]

Thats my bad. Sorry about that. What do you think the dogs needs are? Its hard to see any holes on their list. Maybe a half back or back pocket like Bodhi Uwlhand.

The bulldogs will lose that pick when they match the bid for Sam Darcy

 

[Big_Newon]

The bulldogs will lose that pick when they match the bid for Sam Darcy

Yes for sure, but thats why I said before the draft I havent taken points off Bulldogs and Collingwood for father son matching.

 

[briztoon]

Sorry guys for the mistakes. I will change it now to satisfy your observations.

Bulldogs won’t have the pick, so simplest thing to do is just take them out of the first round. Don’t give them a pick.

Give GWS their kid, move every other team back, and do a redraft after the GWS (as you have done).

And... don’t change your first draft because of whinging fans like me.

Listen to what different posters say about their club needs, take it on board, and do a second phantom draft after the season ends.

For those of us who live on the draft board, we get to know what other clubs need.

For example, GC need KPP’s at both ends. Adelaide, Hawthorn and Carlton need mids. Fremantle need a KPF and West Coast need mids, etc...

 

[Big_Newon]

Bulldogs won’t have the pick, so simplest thing to do is just take them out of the first round. Don’t give them a pick.

Give GWS their kid, move every other team back, and do a redraft after the GWS (as you have done).

And... don’t change your first draft because of whinging fans like me.

Listen to what different posters say about their club needs, take it on board, and do a second phantom draft after the season ends.

For those of us who live on the draft board, we get to know what other clubs need.

For example, GC need KPP’s at both ends. Adelaide, Hawthorn and Carlton need mids. Fremantle need a KPF and West Coast need mids, etc...

I agree with everything here. Thanks for the advice I appreciate it. Surely West Coast dont need more mids though.

 

[briztoon]

I agree with everything here. Thanks for the advice I appreciate it. Surely West Coast dont need more mids though.

Ask west coast fans.

 

[theGav56]

I agree with everything here. Thanks for the advice I appreciate it. Surely West Coast dont need more mids though.

I think WC do need mids, and I would expect that Erasmus and Johnson would be in their sights, and despite Fremantle needing a KPF we would be tempted as well. I like Draper, but wouldn't see much separation between him and Erasmus, so would prefer local.

Getting Browne at our 2nd would be great value. And from your draft, suspect we would take JVR with our first.

I think there is a fair amount of fluidity for the top 30 players. For Fremantle, Erasmus at our first and Williams (or one of the talls) at our second would be purple dreamtime. JVR and Browne wouldn't be far off either.

 

[Swiggy]

cant see Jacob Van Rooyen getting passed freo pick to be honest

 

[Davo-27]

Callaghan, Ward and Clarke, love it.

Not exactly who i would pick, but i cant complain.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Big_Newon, great work taking feedback on board. It can be tough when you do these because everyone has an opinion and some have VERY loud opinions.

I look forward to the next one you do!!

 

[the big lebowski]

On behalf of North we reluctantly accept Horne and Goater.

 

[briztoon]

Big_Newon, great work taking feedback on board. It can be tough when you do these because everyone has an opinion and some have VERY loud opinions.

I look forward to the next one you do!!

This needed a “like” and a “lol” from me.

 

[Big_Newon]

Big_Newon, great work taking feedback on board. It can be tough when you do these because everyone has an opinion and some have VERY loud opinions.

I look forward to the next one you do!!

Thank you for the positive message.

 

[BronCrow]

Not sure Collingwood have the points to match a bid for Daicos. They traded their first this year to GWS.

 

[Rioli8217]

Pick 14: Gold Coast: Bodhi Uwhland

I like this kid and am glad you put him in. He is very hard at the footy and that was shown in the GC vs Swans VFL game. but I see him as a bit later then 14. Definitely draftable and could go higher with a strong champs (if it happens).

 

[Big_Newon]

August Phantom Draft

1st round:

Pick 1: Collingwood: Nick Daicos

Pick 2: Western Bulldogs: Sam Darcy

Pick 3: North Melbourne: Jason Horne

Pick 4: Hawthorn: Finn Callaghan

Pick 5: Adelaide: Ben Hobbs

Pick 6: Gold Coast: Matthew Roberts

Pick 7: GWS: Mac Andrew

Pick 8: St Kilda: Josh Rachele

Pick 9: Carlton: Josh Ward

Pick 10: Richmond: Neil Erasmus

Pick 11: Essendon: Josh Sinn

Pick 12: GWS: Arlo Draper

Pick 13: Fremantle: Josh Gibcus

Pick 14: West Coast: Campbell Chesser

Pick 15: Gold Coast: Bodhi Uwhland

Pick 16: Brisbane: Darcy Wilmot

Pick 17: Sydney: Blake Schlensog

Pick 18: Port Adelaide: Toby Conway

Pick 19: GWS: Joshua Fahey

Pick 20: Brisbane Lions: Tom Brown

Pick 21: Richmond: Sam Butler

Multiple players found. Use birthday to differentiate. eg [PLAYERCARD="23/11/1962"]Joe Smith[/PLAYERCARD]

Pick 22: Western Bulldogs: Jesse Motlop
2/3 of 2nd round:

Pick 23: Gold Coast: Judson Clarke

Pick 24: North Melbourne: Jye Amiss

Pick 25: Hawthorn: Tyler Sonsie

Pick 26: Adelaide: Jack Williams

Pick 27: Gold Coast: Connor Macdonald

Pick 28: Hawthorn: Josh Goater

Pick 29: Richmond: Matthew Johnson

Pick 30: Carlton: Hugh Jackson

Pick 31: Richmond: Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera

Pick 32: Geelong: Cooper Murley

Pick 33: Geelong: Rhett Bazzo

Pick 34: Fremantle: Jacob Van Rooyen

Pick 35: West Coast: Joshua Browne

 

[PMBangers]

Please keep feedback constructive, no need to rip into someone having a crack because you don't agree on the rating of a player