Rank our U23's

[Enviable Tradition]

I compiled this list to do a comparison with a mate v the Crows after a discussion we had about who had the better list moving forwards.

I am sure this will get a bit of discussion going ranking certain young players.

I did it primarily on performance so far, especially at AFL level (sorry Joel).

What would you change.

1. Butters
2. GeorgiadEs
3. Drew
4. Rozee
5. Duursma
6. Marshall
7. Bergman
8. Farrell
9. Jones
10. Frederick
11. Hayes
12. Woodcock
13. McEntee
14. Williams
15. Garner
16. Schofield
17. Mead
18. Lord
19. Pasini
20. Burgoyne

 

[backtozero]

What would you change.

2. Georgiadis

Just one letter probably.


But honestly, who has better youth out of us and the Crows? Its not even a question. Every club in the league has better youth than them.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Just one letter probably.


But honestly, who has better youth out of us and the Crows? Its not even a question. Every club in the league has better youth than them.

Here's my comparison list. I tried to be as impartial as possible (and probably failed) and i'll be the first to admit that my knowledge of the bottom end of the Crows list is based on very little watching. I feel like we have a better top end and they have more depth of youngsters (who MAY develop).

I'd definitely take ours.

Port U23 v Crows U23


Butters > Schoenberg

Georgiadis = Thilthorpe

Drew = Butts

Rozee = Scholl

Duursma > Fogharty

Marshall > Murphy

Bergman = Murray

Farrell = Rowe

Jones > McHenry

Frederick < Berry

Hayes < Hamill

Woodcock < Pedlar

McEntee < McPherson

Williams < Jones

Garner > Hately

Schofield = Worrell

Mead = McAsey

Lord > Gollant

Pasini = O’Connor

Burgoyne < Cook, Borlase, Newchurch Parnell

 

[chiwigi]

Here's my comparison list. I tried to be as impartial as possible (and probably failed) and i'll be the first to admit that my knowledge of the bottom end of the Crows list is based on very little watching. I feel like we have a better top end and they have more depth of youngsters (who MAY develop).

I'd definitely take ours.

Port U23 v Crows U23


Butters > Schoenberg

Georgiadis = Thilthorpe

Drew = Butts

Rozee = Scholl

Duursma > Fogharty

Marshall > Murphy

Bergman = Murray

Farrell = Rowe

Jones > McHenry

Frederick < Berry

Hayes < Hamill

Woodcock < Pedlar

McEntee < McPherson

Williams < Jones

Garner > Hately

Schofield = Worrell

Mead = McAsey

Lord > Gollant

Pasini = O’Connor

Burgoyne < Cook, Borlase, Newchurch Parnell

Scholl equal to Rozee???

Clucking bell!

 

[Sleezy]

I compiled this list to do a comparison with a mate v the Crows after a discussion we had about who had the better list moving forwards.

I am sure this will get a bit of discussion going ranking certain young players.

I did it primarily on performance so far, especially at AFL level (sorry Joel).

What would you change.

1. Butters
2. GeorgiadEs
3. Drew
4. Rozee
5. Duursma
6. Marshall
7. Bergman
8. Farrell
9. Jones
10. Frederick
11. Hayes
12. Woodcock
13. McEntee
14. Williams
15. Garner
16. Schofield
17. Mead
18. Lord
19. Pasini
20. Burgoyne

No SPP? Same draft as Marshall & Drew

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Scholl equal to Rozee???

Clucking bell!

Yeah that was probably me trying to hard to be impartial. I guess I was thinking of the lack of impact Rozee has had at times in the last 12 months.

 

[Brian McGee]

Scholl equal to Rozee???

Clucking bell!

There is trying to be impartial and then there is going so far the opposite way that even the most die hard crows fans would disagree with you.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

No SPP? Same draft as Marshall & Drew

He's 23. You have to draw the line somewhere.

We have a great crop of 23-24 year olds though with the likes of SPP, Ladhams, Houston, Burton.

I just didn't want to be accused of rigging the age bracket in our favour

 

[Enviable Tradition]

There is trying to be impartial and then there is going so far the opposite way that even the most dow hard crows fans would disagree with you.

I'd post it over there but it wouldn't be worth the shitfight lol.

I am sure they would find plenty where they think I am being unfair on them.

 

[chiwigi]

I'd post it over there but it wouldn't be worth the shitfight lol.

I am sure they would find plenty where they think I am being unfair on them.

The Thilthorpe v Georgiadas argument would be interesting.

 

[manureid]

Is that injured Farrell = Fatty Rowe?

I mock a little, as Kane has been quite hit and miss, but his ball use >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Fatty at least.

 

[EskimoPAFC]

Is current performance the best measure of forward potential?

Seems strange to not see Hayes higher.

 

[EskimoPAFC]

Also just saw Farrell = Rowe...

I don't even know where to begin.

I'd take Farrell if he was only allowed to use his non-preferred over Rowe.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Also just saw Farrell = Rowe...

I don't even know where to begin.

I'd take Farrell if he was only allowed to use his non-preferred over Rowe.

Me too but Rowe has kicked 14 goals this year.

 

[powerrrrrrrrrrrr]

Quite a similar list but I think Drew has been excellent this year playing full time mid with less than 30 games and is currently in 2nd.

Georgiades could easily be first with a better forward structure holding him back a bit but the talents certainly there.

That top 10 has some serious talent and we should be getting as many games as we can into them (especially Hayes before we loose him).


1. Butters
2. Drew
3. Georgiades
4. Duursma
5. Rozee
6. Bergman
7. Marshall
8. Jones
9. Farrell
10. Hayes
11. Woodcock
12. Frederick
13. Garner
14. Mead
15. Williams
16. Pasini
17. Schofield
18. Lord
19. Mcentee
20. Burgoyne

 

[Adz2332]

and expanding to a 24 and under makes the gap much much bigger from us to them. we have nothing to worry about from inside our own state for awhile

 

[Coobk001]

My Crack

1. Butters
2. Rozee - Up
3. Duursma - Up
4. Georgiades - Down
5. Marshall - Up
6. Drew - Down
7. Hayes - Up
8. Bergman - Down
9. Jones
10. Farrell - Down
11. Garner - Up
12. Frederick - Down
13. Woodcock - Down
14. Mead - Up
15. Williams - Down
16. Schofield
17. McEntee - Down
18. Lord
19. Pasini
20. Burgoyne

 

[Enviable Tradition]

and expanding to a 24 and under makes the gap much much bigger from us to them. we have nothing to worry about from inside our own state for awhile

Correct

 

[RangaInTeal]

I don’t know, I don’t care, at one point in time Carlton looked blessed with Under 23 talent however achieved eff all! Gold Coast have the pick of the litter, still tripe! St.Kilda had the best 2 under 23 year old key forwards since Tredrea and Lockwood, never won a Premiership...

 

[backtozero]

Me too but Rowe has kicked 14 goals this year.

At least a third of those from flopping like a fish in front of the umpire.

 

[RossFC]

I compiled this list to do a comparison with a mate v the Crows after a discussion we had about who had the better list moving forwards.

I am sure this will get a bit of discussion going ranking certain young players.

I did it primarily on performance so far, especially at AFL level (sorry Joel).

What would you change.

1. Butters
2. GeorgiadEs
3. Drew
4. Rozee
5. Duursma
6. Marshall
7. Bergman
8. Farrell
9. Jones
10. Frederick
11. Hayes
12. Woodcock
13. McEntee
14. Williams
15. Garner
16. Schofield
17. Mead
18. Lord
19. Pasini
20. Burgoyne

Garner > Williams, McEntee and Woodcock.

 

[Young Gun #6]

1. Butters
2. Georgiades
3. Rozee
4. Drew
5. Duursma
6. Jones
7. Bergman
8. Marshall
9. Hayes
10. Farrell

 

[davesnothere]

Also just saw Farrell = Rowe...

I don't even know where to begin.

I'd take Farrell if he was only allowed to use his non-preferred over Rowe.

Farrell is on crutches still?

 

[Chizza12]

Interesting topic, I've ranked ours and the Crowies based on how I project the players to perform in coming years. The question is though, how many of these players will become genuine A graders? In my opinion, you need at least 6 to challenge for a Premiership (4 Midfielders, 1 Forward, 1 Back). We definitely need to get a defender (draft/trade) into this age bracket who could become an A grader.


1) Butters
2) Georgiadis
3) Rozee
4) Duursma
5) Hayes
6) Bergman
7) Drew
8) Jones
9) Marshall
10) Mead

1) Thilthorpe
2) Butts
3) Schoenberg
4) Hamill
5) Berry
6) Pedlar
7) Scholl
8) Jones
9) Murray
10) Fogarty

 

[Rising Power]

Everyone 6 inches taller + 5-10 kg heavier