Deaneus!
We Await Silent Tristero's Empire
Last edited:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I've noted Josh Sinn has dropped down the boards a lot this year when he was talked up as being right in the top few at the start of the year.
Given Vic haven't had much footy but he's had 3 decent games at the start of the year, what's been happening here?
Jacob Weitering looked nothing like #1 first few yearsAll key position draftees should be given 3 years before judging harshly , the 3 year is when most would show something which is next year for Fish
heck we’ve given Fog way more than that and no one seems to mind about that
Big final for South Adelaide and their Premiership drought is as long as Melbourne's. They'd both likely play in the prelim. Which they won't win cos they're playing the mighy bays!South, if the WAFL are keeping their players I assume the SANFL will too
Reckon this gets trotted out and over stated a lot. Weitering actually did look good in his first year, and then in his following seasons had a couple of leaner years. Getting thrown forward wasn't a good move for him.
Maybe try doing some research before posting ...
Yes, but then the 2nd year blues came into effect .....that ego & swagger he had as a #1 pick, was battered, he lost confidence, and then he was in/out of the side ....and shifted down fwdlooked awesome in his debut year.
Wouldn't that be the case most years ...the #1 pick rarely ends up the best player in the Draft yearLever's first year > Weitering's first year
I doubt Weitering goes #1 again if you re-do the 2015 draft
Lever's first year > Weitering's first year
I doubt Weitering goes #1 again if you re-do the 2015 draft
Lever was playing behind a significantly better performing side and in an easier role and still wasn't better and was dropped to the 2s to finish the season. Your second point might be correct.
Campo dropped Lever for Mackay as one of his many acts of coaching idiocy. There isn't a single person here that agreed with that decision at the time, or now. He was performing very well
My memory was that he'd really hit a wall, but maybe you're right.Campo dropped Lever for Mackay as one of his many acts of coaching idiocy. There isn't a single person here that agreed with that decision at the time, or now. He was performing very well
My memory was that he'd really hit a wall, but maybe you're right.
It's right that we dropped him for Cheney instead of Mackay. (We dropped Lyons and Lever for Cheney and Mackay hahaha, what a call knowing how those players went on to perform)
I think he copped a slight injury in about round 20 or something and he missed a week or two, came back, then Campo decided he wanted experience for the finals series after we lost to Geelong in Geelong. Cheney hadn't played in weeks and was pretty average
They be happy with both ….. Weitering is so far from a bust it’s not funny . Walsh Weitering and McKay are 3 of the better players for their positions in the compYep. Carlton still did pretty well to get McKay with #10 so they should be happy
Yep, Carlton’s best talent is up there with the best in the leagueThey be happy with both ….. Weitering is so far from a bust it’s not funny . Walsh Weitering and McKay are 3 of the better players for their positions in the comp
I'm warming to the idea of offering 4 and next year's first for JHF. Big big cost, but could set us up nicely after getting Dawson, and our youth coming through.
I’d be just as happy with Callaghan than I would with JHF. So if we can get Callaghan with pick 4 I’d be stokedI'm warming to the idea of offering 4 and next year's first for JHF. Big big cost, but could set us up nicely after getting Dawson, and our youth coming through.