Prediction Jordan Dawson : Becomes A Crow What Day OF The Trade Period? 1 - 10?

[Crow_68]

Well, Judas only committed one betrayal

Who names their kid Judas? I wonder if he's Catholic and got to choose his middle name himself?


Anyways ... what do we think of Dawson & Syd pick 31 for our 23 & 37?

We might not have list room to use 3 picks and this way we move up 6 picks on 37.

Umm, that values Dawson around pick 28?.

Perhaps 23 and our 2022 2nd for Dawson and 31 is a bit more reasonable. Based on this year, this would value him around 17. Of course, the draft points are all pretty subjective.

 

[70lethal]

I don't think next years 2nd will be involved as we will want as much ammo as possible.

If Swans aren't in a rush to take pick 23 then simply wait and watch how the CCJ deal goes because NM don't want to give pick 20 and don't have much else to offer. Richmond also need NM to trade for Tarrant.

Then how do Collingwood pay for Lipinski?

If CCJ ends up in the PSD and Sydney are being headstrong then pick 23 is off the table if we are certain Dawson isn't going to flip.

If we aren't looking at anyone else then there's no need to rush

What we get for Kelly may have some bearing depending what compo pick is award.

Harley early postering suggests he knows they have no hand and is projecting to Swans fans only after letting Alir go cheaply and him having a huge year.

It's in the players interest to get it done early and both clubs are genuinely reasonable.
Hately last year was bit of a surprise thou

 

[Crowked]

Doesn’t everything happen on the last day? This one might be on the buzzer.

 

[FR0GGY]

Dawson wouldn’t want us selling the farm, he wants to play with quality players.
He knows we rate him and want him.

 

[craig crowing]

Getting really annoyed at those posters saying we have to give up 2 second round picks as that is pretty major and because of season gone the draft is a bit of a lottery and there has to be some gold in 2nd round.
If we have to add to 23 then throw in Kellys compo. pick.

 

[Bearded Clam]

Getting really annoyed at those posters saying we have to give up 2 second round picks as that is pretty major and because of season gone the draft is a bit of a lottery and there has to be some gold in 2nd round.
If we have to add to 23 then throw in Kellys compo. pick.

I get annoyed with those posters that squeal and constantly want more and more when its one of our players (ie jake lever two firsts please as a recent example) who then try and claim a player thats OOC coming our way is barely worth a 2nd rounder!..

this is a lad in his prime that finished top 3 in his current clubs B&F (where did jake end up in our 2017 B&F again?) and all of a sudden he’s worth * all and we should be scummy PSD flogs about it all..

our club has always been fair and reasonable at the trade table and I cant see why that wouldnt be the case in this instance..

I’d expect 23 plus something else, possibly the melbourne second aswell or a player, is where this trade eventually lands..

 

[1990crow]

I get annoyed with those posters that squeal and constantly want more and more when its one of our players (ie jake lever two firsts please as a recent example) who then try and claim a player thats OOC coming our way is barely worth a 2nd rounder!..

this is a lad in his prime that finished top 3 in his current clubs B&F (where did jake end up in our 2017 B&F again?) and all of a sudden he’s worth fu** all and we should be scummy PSD flogs about it all..

our club has always been fair and reasonable at the trade table and I cant see why that wouldnt be the case in this instance..

I’d expect 23 plus something else, possibly the melbourne second aswell or a player, is where this trade eventually lands..

How many flags have we won being fair?

 

[Crow_Magnon]

That was site vandalism, only edited today. I have changed it back to show only "Jordan Dawson". It was probably a disgruntled Sydney fan, or a jealous port adelaide power person,..... or someone from Geelong.

Can you possibly edit the Wiki pages for Judas Lever, Gunston, Davis, et al?

 

[flashcrow]

Can you possibly edit the Wiki pages for Judas Lever, Gunston, Davis, et al?

Never heard of them.

 

[Mutineer]

I'm predicting the Swans will play hard ball which is fair enough on their part.
Trade period opens on Monday 4th October - Closes Wednesday 13th October
I'll plonk for day 9 - October the 12th.

Though I think day 10 would be favourite if a poll was held.

Bump

In by a whisker

 

[Thetrader15]

Bump

Missed it by a few hours.

 

[relapse]

Almost every trade now goes down to the wire these days, I'd expect something similar with Dawson.

My prediction, a multi club trade invoiving Dawson will happen on Day 9

I was very very close.

The deal was agreed to on Day 9 (paperwork filed on the last day) and it took a prior multi club trade to get the capital needed to get the deal over the line so I'm claiming it as a win.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I was very very close.

The deal was agreed to on Day 9 (paperwork filed on the last day) and it took a prior multi club trade to get the capital needed to get the deal over the line so I'm claiming it as a win.

It's as if List Managers are measured on their ability to stretch negotiations out .....as if it symbolizes "the good fight"

I did see somewhere that SYD were praised for exploring all their options for a better deal ......seems you need the 9 days to explore your options, when most observers saw that it could have been done in 3 ......but SYD wouldn't get brownie points for that

 

[Vhaluus]

It's as if List Managers are measured on their ability to stretch negotiations out .....as if it symbolizes "the good fight"

I did see somewhere that SYD were praised for exploring all their options for a better deal ......seems you need the 9 days to explore your options, when most observers saw that it could have been done in 3 ......but SYD wouldn't get brownie points for that

They did it to show their supporters they fought for a better deal and to cast themselves in the role of victim.

It worked.

 

[Golumless]

Too late to say I reckon it'll happen at 10pm on October 12th?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Too late to say I reckon it'll happen at 10pm on October 12th?

 

[Thylacinus]

And a German thread

Instead of a Poll thread and German thread we could just keep it simple and call it a Prussian thread!

 

[Westozswan]

I think you have got the steal of the decade. Victoria don't care so the AFL don't care. But if this was Bulldogs then there would be an investigation. And the PSD would be finished. I personally think non Vic's should help each other but I'm completely Anti Vic. But it seems WA and SA are screwing the non VICS alot these days. Sydney Dont have anyone that 'wants to come home'. But I like Adelaide and hope to see Dawson delivering that perfect pass to your forwards all year
.

 

[jackster83]

I think you have got the steal of the decade. Victoria don't care so the AFL don't care. But if this was Bulldogs then there would be an investigation. And the PSD would be finished. I personally think non Vic's should help each other but I'm completely Anti Vic. But it seems WA and SA are screwing the non VICS alot these days. Sydney Dont have anyone that 'wants to come home'. But I like Adelaide and hope to see Dawson delivering that perfect pass to your forwards all year
.

Watch the stink the Vics kick up when Luke Jackson leaves Melbourne to go to the Eagles to replace NicNat in a couple of years.

 

[Vhaluus]

I think you have got the steal of the decade. Victoria don't care so the AFL don't care. But if this was Bulldogs then there would be an investigation. And the PSD would be finished. I personally think non Vic's should help each other but I'm completely Anti Vic. But it seems WA and SA are screwing the non VICS alot these days. Sydney Dont have anyone that 'wants to come home'. But I like Adelaide and hope to see Dawson delivering that perfect pass to your forwards all year
.

You don't have anyone who wants to go home because no good kids get to leave. You get them via academy picks so you don't ever have to pay the premium to lure them home.

Over half your good players are academy picks.

Give us SA academies and we wouldn't have to lure kids home either.