We have few alternatives if Lobb goes and is not replaced. But I quite like the Hamling forward suggestion, Cox defender/ruck.If this is the team you are going to go with then Cox would basically have to play Forward/Ruck.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
We have few alternatives if Lobb goes and is not replaced. But I quite like the Hamling forward suggestion, Cox defender/ruck.If this is the team you are going to go with then Cox would basically have to play Forward/Ruck.
I would be happy with any of Cox, Hamling or Logue tried forward. Cox would make the best forward IMHO but apparently doesn’t want to do it. Hamling was reported as wanting to do it a couple of years ago so that is a good place to start.We have few alternatives if Lobb goes and is not replaced. But I quite like the Hamling forward suggestion, Cox defender/ruck.
Brodie?Defenders:
Pearce
Hamling
Cox
Logue
Young
Wilson
Ryan
Chapman
Hughes
Walker
Aish
Rucks:
Darcy
Meek
Benning
Cripps
Midfielders:
Serong
Brayshaw
Mundy
Tucker
Fyfe
Fredrick
O'Driscoll
Valente
Western
Crowden
Banfield
Blakely
Acres
Clark
Erasmus
Forwards:
Walters
Henry
Schultz
Lobb
Switta
Colyer
Sturt
Treacy
Taberner
Van Rooyen
Rachelle
No bias from me he’s a champ. Very doubtful he’s back on the park at the start of next season. Hope I’m wrong.I think recency bias is making people forget just how good a backman Hamling is. If he's fit he's a lock for the best 22.
B: Ryan - Cox - Logue
HB: Young - Pearce - Chapman
C: Clark - Serong - Aish
HF: Walters - Treacy - Colyer
F: Schultz - Taberner - Sturt
R: Darcy - Fyfe - Brayshaw
I/C: Mundy - Henry - Hamling - Brodie
EMERG: Lobb - Walker - Frederick - Tucker
IF we can keep everyone fit, this suddenly becomes a pleasingly challenging exercise. Big pre-season ahead.
(Probably overly harsh on Lobb, but you know what? fu** him.)
Don't really have anything to change after the trade period, I was sneaky and already included ClarkFB: Ryan, Cox, Logue
HB: Walker, Pearce, Young
C: Frederick, Serong, Clark
HF: Switkowski, Taberner, Walters
FF: Schulz, Lobb, Treacy
R: Darcy, Fyfe, Brayshaw
Bench: Mundy, Aish, Sturt, Chapman
Colyer should be phased out next year if injuries allow us, depth only
Sturt and Switkowski need to stay fit but otherwise Colyer/Henry/Western take one of their spots
If we lose a Key then Hamling comes in
If Logue or Ryan go down then Hughes is likely first in line
Wilson is backup for Young/Walker dependant on their form and if Wilson is terrible at Peel then Clark has the ability to move back.
Taberner, Lobb and Treacy will be backed up by pick 6 or 8, whichever one is the tall. We must play 3 talls, really need Lobb as second ruck.
Meek the clear backup for Darcy and should only play if Darcy is missing.
Freddy and Clark are my first choice wingers, Aish and Chapman can roll through there of both roll through defense.
Tucker is the interesting one, don't really have a spot for him but if he is in the team it is as a mid IMO, so probably first in line as a mid over Blakely.
Kelm2nds
????? Hamling Hughes
Wilson Chapman O’Driscoll
Acres Brodie ?????
Crowden Sturt Banfield
?????? ????? Western
Meek Blakeley Tucker
Int: ????? ????? ????? ?????
1sts
Ryan Pearce Cox
Walker Logue Young
Clark Fyfe Walters
Switta Lobb Schultz
Treacy Taberner Colyer
Darcy Serong Brayshaw
Int: Mundy Frederick Aish Henry
Did I forget anyone?
Would be pretty incredible trading if Clark and Brodie are best 22.B: Logue - Cox - Ryan
HB: Young - Pearce - Walker
C: Clark - Fyfe - Aish
HF: Sturt - Treacy - Frederick
FF: Walters - Tabs - Lobb
Ruc: Darcy - Brayshaw - Serong
Bench: Mundy - Brodie - Tucker - Henry
Sub: Chapman
If Tucker is in our best 22 then we have no hope of playing finals next year, the guy is a B- player at the best and we should exit him and bring in a young kid who might develop into a good playerWould be pretty incredible trading if Clark and Brodie are best 22.
Can’t all be A graders.If Tucker is in our best 22 then we have no hope of playing finals next year, the guy is a B- player at the best and we should exit him and bring in a young kid who might develop into a good player
For those that are his fans i ask what other team would he get a game with, maybe North but definately not in a top 8 team, the club needs to get rid of the list cloggers
If Tucker is in our best 22 then we have no hope of playing finals next year, the guy is a B- player at the best and we should exit him and bring in a young kid who might develop into a good player
For those that are his fans i ask what other team would he get a game with, maybe North but definately not in a top 8 team, the club needs to get rid of the list cloggers