Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[A Bit Dusty]

Factoring in price, Curnow > Coleman > Rioli > Gresham

Hey Ingy what are your thoughts on Charlie Dean I've heard a few people say he could be in the starting 22

 

[Ingy]

Hey Ingy what are your thoughts on Charlie Dean I've heard a few people say he could be in the starting 22

Yeah it wouldn't surprise. Apparently he's been training well.

I dunno about Round 1, but he seems to be in the mix for early games.

Keane has left the building, Kelly's training as a forward, not too many in front of him

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Yeah it wouldn't surprise. Apparently he's been training well.

I dunno about Round 1, but he seems to be in the mix for early games.

Keane has left the building, Kelly's training as a forward, not too many in front of him

I have had him parked at D8 for a while now I might end up starting with him if he dosen't play early will be a good loop at $102k

 

[Ingy]

I have had him parked at D8 for a while now I might end up starting with him if he dosen't play early will be a good loop at $102k

Yep sounds like a plan

 

[MacStradbroke]

Pre season watch on role
Upside is gresham who’s averaged 80’s before and nay get midfield time
Coleman finished strong but reports of zorko moving back may affect his scoring? Answerth another fighting for that spot
Rioli looks great and would be my pick here as we know he’ll start at half back in the Houli role. We saw how well the gulls did last year and the aim would be to find the impey/hall/ziebell of this year which imo he is most likely
Curnow apparently fit and firing and a better price. But will find it harder in his role to score then the others. It’s the kpp syndrome. Who scores easier, Curnow at chf relying on contested marks and goals vs Rioli taking kick outs and getting cheap marks/along with Coleman who’s similar or gresham pinch hitting in the middle crumbing goals and getting 20+ a game

Yeah I’m not sold on anything with Coleman except price atm. With Rich and Zorko back there, how much cheap pill will there be? Even Harris Andrews rolls off opponents and scores well. will be a wait and see for me I think.

 

[kool kangas]

So l have 1 field spot left and cant decide between J.Caldwell (Ess) or F.Macrae (Coll)...need help..

 

[MacStradbroke]

So l have 1 field spot left and cant decide between J.Caldwell (Ess) or F.Macrae (Coll)...need help..

Macrae (and change) comfortably.

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Gresham & F.Macrae v C.Curnow & Berry

Currently going with Curnow & Berry but its close, can anyone sway me?

 

[King_Steele]

Gresham & F.Macrae v C.Curnow & Berry

Currently going with Curnow & Berry but its close, can anyone sway me?

Curnow & Berry

 

[Ingy]

Gresham & F.Macrae v C.Curnow & Berry

Currently going with Curnow & Berry but its close, can anyone sway me?

Curnow, FinMac and some cash to spend elsewhere

 

[Northernsoul74]

So l have 1 field spot left and cant decide between J.Caldwell (Ess) or F.Macrae (Coll)...need help..

I’d probably just take a rookie and do something with the cash.

 

[kool kangas]

I’d probably just take a rookie and do something with the cash.

l have a few rookies on the bench so l really need another on field player..

 

[Dark Sharks]

Yeo and Rowell

or

Walsh (or another SP) and Finlay




Top option is off the beaten path, yet i feel i've been stitched by getting fallen premo's and midpricers for the last couple of years and it hasn't worked.

Might just stick with G&R in 2022.

 

[Significant]

Yeo and Rowell

or

Walsh (or another SP) and Finlay




Top option is off the beaten path, yet i feel i've been stitched by getting fallen premo's and midpricers for the last couple of years and it hasn't worked.

Might just stick with G&R in 2022.

Fairly certain Yeo has had a stop start preseason with a few setbacks, so that doesn't fill me with hope. IMO Rowell is the key to this comparison also. If he looks to be a 105+ player, then the first option for sure.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Fairly certain Yeo has had a stop start preseason with a few setbacks, so that doesn't fill me with hope. IMO Rowell is the key to this comparison also. If he looks to be a 105+ player, then the first option for sure.

Yeo just being managed. There's no setbacks they are just giving him sessions off to make sure he's cherry ripe and not overloaded.

For me Mcrae is the main one. I'm not frothing over him as a rookie like some others are. Will need to reassess this one come pre season.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Yeo and Rowell

or

Walsh (or another SP) and Finlay




Top option is off the beaten path, yet i feel i've been stitched by getting fallen premo's and midpricers for the last couple of years and it hasn't worked.

Might just stick with G&R in 2022.

GnR in the mid's. You need as many SP's as you can get come the end of the year and neither Yeo nor Rowell will be that.

 

[King_Steele]

Yeo and Rowell

or

Walsh (or another SP) and Finlay




Top option is off the beaten path, yet i feel i've been stitched by getting fallen premo's and midpricers for the last couple of years and it hasn't worked.

Might just stick with G&R in 2022.

Walsh & Finlay

 

[Significant]

GnR in the mid's. You need as many SP's as you can get come the end of the year and neither Yeo nor Rowell will be that.

I disagree with Rowell, but would like to see some preseason form.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I disagree with Rowell, but would like to see some preseason form.

I hope he goes SP this year, but suspect he'll be 90-100.

He is training the house down apparently.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

I hope he goes SP this year, but suspect he'll be 90-100.

He is training the house down apparently.

So is everybody this time of year even me. I ate and drank so much they pulled down half the house to get me out to go to work NOW THAT'S TRAINING THE HOUSE DOWN

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

So is everybody this time of year even me. I ate and drank so much they pulled down half the house to get me out to go to work NOW THAT'S TRAINING THE HOUSE DOWN

Living your best life!

 

[Significant]

Going with a 4-5-2-1 structure with Whitfield, Neale, Grundy, Dunkley the lowest $$ term on each line, plus Coniglio and Curnow, but three on field forward rookies doesn't inspire.

Oliver and 3rd on-field forward rookie

vs

Rowell and De Goey

ATM from a structure perspective, I think I need that extra forward, unless rookies pop their heads up.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Ridley vs Whitfield

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Ridley vs Whitfield

if Whitfield gets through pre season without bruising his liver worse than Here2tellyouwhy he will be in my side.

 

[Skipper_]

Dunkley and Rowell vs Rayner and Clarry vs Rioli and Walsh