Position 2022 Defenders

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[marcmurphy3]

Is Rich a better option than Dawson?

No

 

[Faz 2000]

Hmmnnn, was looking for value in Dawson or Rich, but maybe I need to stretch up to Crisp.

 

[toxic]

Hmmnnn, was looking for value in Dawson or Rich, but maybe I need to stretch up to Crisp.

Dawson

Don't look back

 

[Sammy1992]

Is Zorko playing more midfield minutes since coldmen has been back? Both 120+ scores in the last 2 weeks. At 522k seems like good value

 

[toxic]

Is Zorko playing more midfield minutes since coldmen has been back? Both 120+ scores in the last 2 weeks. At 522k seems like good value

Indeed it does

 

[Judd_Magic]

Hmmnnn, was looking for value in Dawson or Rich, but maybe I need to stretch up to Crisp.

Ideally you want both Crisp and Dawson like how I am planning on doing this week and next week.

 

[Hawkboy62]

Dawson

Don't look back

I started Dawson and he has been okay but not great. Generally does not get enough possessions for my liking and Smith has by far the better role. Takes very few kick-ins when Brodie Smith is in the team, and those he does take he is expected to boot it long and hard. Not a safe 3 points kick like the Gull, with a chance to run by and get another kick.

Surrounded by better team mates, who would look to use him he could be a real star. Would fit in well at the Swans as he can clear a zone with his kicking and they have decent marking forwards. Maybe he will improve as he had an interrupted preseason.

I think Cumming is the pick of my defenders for role and as a rounded defender. Kick-ins, contested marks, play maker off half back with good skills. A better Whitfield, but without the tank. Has seriously improved since the start of '21, when he was marginal best 22.

 

[weltschmerz]

Next week I'll be making my final defender upgrade. Got Short, Crisp, Docherty, Sinclair, and Hewett, and will be upgrading NOD to someone. I'm leaning towards Sicily, but haven't really made up my mind yet.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Next week I'll be making my final defender upgrade. Got Short, Crisp, Docherty, Sinclair, and Hewett, and will be upgrading NOD to someone. I'm leaning towards Sicily, but haven't really made up my mind yet.

Stewart if you can affordhim but sicily otherwise both are guns.

 

[Deliverance]

Next week I'll be making my final defender upgrade. Got Short, Crisp, Docherty, Sinclair, and Hewett, and will be upgrading NOD to someone. I'm leaning towards Sicily, but haven't really made up my mind yet.

Sicily is overpriced. CJ is a week away and will steal some of Sicily's R50s

 

[Gene Simmons]

I started Dawson and he has been okay but not great. Generally does not get enough possessions for my liking and Smith has by far the better role. Takes very few kick-ins when Brodie Smith is in the team, and those he does take he is expected to boot it long and hard. Not a safe 3 points kick like the Gull, with a chance to run by and get another kick.

Surrounded by better team mates, who would look to use him he could be a real star. Would fit in well at the Swans as he can clear a zone with his kicking and they have decent marking forwards. Maybe he will improve as he had an interrupted preseason.

I think Cumming is the pick of my defenders for role and as a rounded defender. Kick-ins, contested marks, play maker off half back with good skills. A better Whitfield, but without the tank. Has seriously improved since the start of '21, when he was marginal best 22.

I am trying to decide between Dawson v Cumming myself.

I'm really tempted by Cumming's less than 1% ownership as my team is starting to look very cookie cutter.

 

[Me Myself and I]

The somewhat POD defence I've ended up with. Lloyd at D6, a rare sight. Got McCartin forward.

 

[BFMC]

The somewhat POD defence I've ended up with. Lloyd at D6, a rare sight. Got McCartin forward.

View attachment 1398717

Thats not a bad go hard or go home D line. Hopefully option 1 prevails for you.

 

[Sherman41]

Its a shame Richmond and Crows play at the same time. Cant loop Hinge.
Confident enough to field Paddy over Hinge, Paddy has gone 60 plus in all games except one, (excluding concussion game).

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Looking at a Defender this week

Crisp vs Zorko vs Dawson vs Cumming

 

[pieman123]

Looking at a Defender this week

Crisp vs Zorko vs Dawson vs Cumming
View attachment 1398734

Crisp out of those 4 options imo.

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Crisp out of those 4 options imo.

My only hesitation with Crisp is I might need the savings from Zorko/Dawson to fund Brayshaw

 

[SC fish]

Its a shame Richmond and Crows play at the same time. Cant loop Hinge.
Confident enough to field Paddy over Hinge, Paddy has gone 60 plus in all games except one, (excluding concussion game).

Richmond play Saturday arvo and Crows play Saturday evening. You still can't loop Hinge though, but I agree field Paddy ahead of him

 

[Sherman41]

Richmond play Saturday arvo and Crows play Saturday evening. You still can't loop Hinge though, but I agree field Paddy ahead of him

Sorry you're spot on. Gibcus playing first was the problem as you stated. Shouldnt cost me too many points at worst (I hope).

 

[Faz 2000]

I'm still all over the shop on which premo defender to bring in for NOD...



Dawson seems value. Looking into him as an option, what I like is he's got North and West Coast twice each still to go, including in finals. He hasn't set the world on fire, but he sure CAN score.

Crisp seems like the can't miss option, playing a great role, but is priced higher and does have the tougher draw. Not sure if it will impact him, though. Seems to ton up all the bloody time, though doesn't present value at the moment.

Stewart and Doc look like the final guys to target, but will get one of them after their bye with Daicos.

 

[buttox]

I'm still all over the shop on which premo defender to bring in for NOD...

View attachment 1398782

Dawson seems value. Looking into him as an option, what I like is he's got North and West Coast twice each still to go, including in finals. He hasn't set the world on fire, but he sure CAN score.

Crisp seems like the can't miss option, playing a great role, but is priced higher and does have the tougher draw. Not sure if it will impact him, though. Seems to ton up all the bloody time, though doesn't present value at the moment.

Stewart and Doc look like the final guys to target, but will get one of them after their bye with Daicos.

Dawson/Zorko seem the best value IMO.
Stewart would be best for your byes and probably best overall.
Get Doc after his bye IMO.

 

[Eddie19]

Looking at Sicily, Zorko or Cumming?
Which one presents better value and long term scoring potential?
Already have Doch, Crisp, Short, Hewett down back.

 

[buttox]

Looking at Sicily, Zorko or Cumming?
Which one presents better value and long term scoring potential?
Already have Doch, Crisp, Short, Hewett down back.

I think you have them in order.
Cumming has a r12 bye if you want him pick him up r13.

 

[JuddgementDay]

I'm still all over the shop on which premo defender to bring in for NOD...

View attachment 1398782

Dawson seems value. Looking into him as an option, what I like is he's got North and West Coast twice each still to go, including in finals. He hasn't set the world on fire, but he sure CAN score.

Crisp seems like the can't miss option, playing a great role, but is priced higher and does have the tougher draw. Not sure if it will impact him, though. Seems to ton up all the bloody time, though doesn't present value at the moment.

Stewart and Doc look like the final guys to target, but will get one of them after their bye with Daicos.

Witherden - he scores so easily

 

[Faz 2000]

Witherden - he scores so easily

Yeh, but he doesn’t deserve any of the scores and he’s not a good footballer .