Preview Changes: R10 vs St Kilda, Saturday May 21, 7.00pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval

[jackster83]

I thought Sholl was ok last week. Glad we've kept Soligo who I'm guessing will spend more time on the wing.

**** knows how Brown stays in. He must have Mackay's photos.

Glad to see TT back in.

 

[dogs105]

No news on Butts and he hasn't been named an emergency.

7 days would be a pretty lucky recovery. 60% still symptomatic after 7 days when testing was required to end isolation.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Going in with an undersized defence again is a worry

 

[Afcprophet]

Good changes unfortunate about Butts. But what was the supposed player to be dropped for bad behavior?

 

[thebirdman 24]

Nice changes. Berg & Sholl have been bad for a while. Welcome back RT.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[SellarStardom]

No news on Butts and he hasn't been named an emergency.

Yeah I thought that was weird. Worrell finally named at least as an emergncy

 

[CrowBloke]

IN:
Thilthorpe, Murphy

OUT:
Himmelberg, Sholl

Just here for the melts,

in 3,2,1..................

Brown still in.

NOOOOOOOO ....

 

[Scorpus]

Going in with an undersized defence again is a worry

If we picked Frampton it's effectively going in undersized

 

[Bernie L]

Meh, Im ok with that.

 

[Hell Boy6669]

Why is pedlar the medi sub again?? Can he not run out a full game of sanfl

 

[Danger in Texas]

Why is pedlar the medi sub again?? Can he not run out a full game of sanfl

It’ll be Sholl

 

[dogs105]

Why is pedlar the medi sub again?? Can he not run out a full game of sanfl

Who are the emergencies?

 

[LeftyLuke]

Wtf

 

[dogs105]

Wtf

Brown or Rachele?

 

[Danger in Texas]

Sooo, is the bad behaviour player in the side still or…?

 

[dogs105]

Sooo, is the bad behaviour player in the side still or…?

Peter Doherty has cast a shadow over Berg and Sholl now...

 

[George Kramer]

Why is pedlar the medi sub again?? Can he not run out a full game of sanfl

He’s not, he’s an emergency, sub still to be named but you’d be guessing Sholl

 

[footy4ever]

IN:
Thilthorpe, Murphy

OUT:
Himmelberg, Sholl

Look, I didn't post it here, but that's exactly what our home selection panel, which is made up of me, my wife and the cat, held at the dinner table, came up with.

I like Himmelberg more than most on here but time to throw Thilthorpe in.

And Murphy, if he's fit, again, not to everybody's liking on here, is a no-brainer inclusion for mine.


And my wife is pleased for Sholl's omission, swearing he is not that elite kick everyone bangs on about. And she is correct...this time.

 

[dogs105]

Look, I didn't post it here, but that's exactly what our home selection panel, which is made up of me, my wife and the cat, held at the dinner table, came up with.

I like Himmelberg more than most on here but time to throw Thilthorpe in.

And Murphy, if he's fit, again, not to everybody's liking on here, is a no-brainer inclusion for mine.

I'd like to meet your cat.

 

[Bay62]

Sooo, is the bad behaviour player in the side still or…?

Yeah we got a whole TEAM of bad boys…


Said no Crows supporter ever

 

[George Kramer]

Sholl out hopefully means Dawsons playing wing as named and Hinge in defence. Hinge doesn’t get it enough to be wing and has played his best footy in defence, same with Dawson on the wing

 

[Wazzy36]

I think we've reached my preferred tall forward set-up.

 

[jackster83]

Sholl out hopefully means Dawsons playing wing as named and Hinge in defence. Hinge doesn’t get it enough to be wing and has played his best footy in defence, same with Dawson on the wing

Doubt it. Think we'll roll with how we set up last week.

Doedee on King or Marshall is going to end in tears.

 

[footy4ever]

I'd like to meet your cat.

Is a very astute feline, that one.

 

[Bay62]

A few AFL games Year 1. Time to develop in SANFL. Work on whatever stuff we didn't like this year then.

More AFL games Year 2. The odd rest/refresher as required.

Regular player Year 3.

Himmelberg is irrelevant. Form is irrelevant. Win-loss is irrelevant.

If Himmelberg had kicked 2 or 3 goals last week would Thilthorpe be coming in this week? Unlikely. How can the development of our list depend on such an inconsequential and random event?

I’m not totally disagreeing with your approach, but I think a reasonable answer to that question is: developing a winning culture is important to the development of individual players. To know that a game style works, to not drop their head because we’re picking the best prospects each week but always losing, for the good prospects who are in the team to learn how to play and win

Just my 2c