Remove this Banner Ad

Toast Sam De Koning

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Think you had a crack at me as I was very obviously taking the piss on the night out of the melters lol.
No harm no fowl.


Should always give every draftee a chance before we get the pitchforks out.

Numerous full time talent scouts + part time state based consultants actually watching numerous games of dozens of players + then adding in the various means of footage available vs the average fan who watches a few clips or matches online.

Chalk and cheese really.

Wasn't trying to be a smartarse at any individual btw. Great that some on here have a passion for youth football. Budda230 turned it into a career, as has Knightmare. But we're all amateurs compared to the masters.

Was genuinely interested to see what the perception of SDK on draft night was. Fair to say lots of people's opinions of him have grown this year!

The notable draft misses where Wells is perceived to have reached is remembered far more than the times he nails it.

Yeah I think I did lol.
Wouldn't have been the first nor last time, nor vice versa.
No harm no chicken as you say.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

He must be broadly acknowledged now as being a very good prospect for Geelong ... one only has to look at other clubs threads...like the suns for example... and they are calculating how long a deal and how much to offer him to get him to their club. I think we are lucky that appears to be happy and enjoying his time at Geelong. Still contracted but I hope they are monitoring his willingness to extend.
 
Sign him up before they move him forward when he will be worth much more.

Why would he be moved forward?

We have more potential young forwards coming through compared with young defenders, and SDK is making a name for himself as one of the best young defenders in the comp
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Why would he be moved forward?

We have more potential young forwards coming through compared with young defenders, and SDK is making a name for himself as one of the best young defenders in the comp
He is a potential star very tall player, can mark, kick and good on the ground. It is much easier to get a good tall back to do the job compared to getting a match winning tall forward. That is why such players are on the big money and there are few of them. Of course Geelong will try him out as a forward at some stage. I never said they would do it soon. I have been complaining since the end of the season to the mid season draft that we needed another very tall defender, and that failure to do something could come back to bite us. As for comparable young forwards coming through, there is only Neale who is raw and has played one game. Esava is shorter and is taking his time in coming through.
 
They're not moving him forward
True. I should have been clearer. I meant get him on a long generous deal now rather than a shorter deal during which he will be tried as a forward and if successful, his market value will increase substantially by the next renewal.
 
Be a long time before he goes forward other than 5 or 10 mins here and there
Yes. I meant to say that in the future, not this season, he will be moved forward to see how he goes, and if successful, he will be worth a lot more. But he is out of contract this year I believe, so I hope they offer a lot to get a long contract. Wasn't he moved forward in the last quarter in the Pies match? If behind in the last in a final, they might repeat it.
 
Yes. I meant to say that in the future, not this season, he will be moved forward to see how he goes, and if successful, he will be worth a lot more. But he is out of contract this year I believe, so I hope they offer a lot to get a long contract. Wasn't he moved forward in the last quarter in the Pies match? If behind in the last in a final, they might repeat it.
thought he was signed until the end of 2023
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Yes. I meant to say that in the future, not this season, he will be moved forward to see how he goes, and if successful, he will be worth a lot more. But he is out of contract this year I believe, so I hope they offer a lot to get a long contract. Wasn't he moved forward in the last quarter in the Pies match? If behind in the last in a final, they might repeat it.

SDK is contracted for another year, and there's no reason to throw him forward

And he was thrown forward against Collingwood, but that was also after Ratugolea was subbed out, and allowed us to keep a similar structure to what we'd been playing until that stage - since that match we've changed our structure, and not sure we'll necessarily be looking at throwing him forward any time soon, unless absolutely necessary like both Cameron & Hawkins going down in the same match

Right now, observing how he's going as a KPD, I don't get see why there would be any consideration to move him forward - he's looking an AA level defender, and they aren't exactly easy to find. He's only going to improve, and when you've got a youngster like SDK who can lock down an end for the next 10 years, you don't play around with the sort of thing
 
He is a potential star very tall player, can mark, kick and good on the ground. It is much easier to get a good tall back to do the job compared to getting a match winning tall forward. That is why such players are on the big money and there are few of them. Of course Geelong will try him out as a forward at some stage. I never said they would do it soon. I have been complaining since the end of the season to the mid season draft that we needed another very tall defender, and that failure to do something could come back to bite us. As for comparable young forwards coming through, there is only Neale who is raw and has played one game. Esava is shorter and is taking his time in coming through.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Toast Sam De Koning

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top