Autopsy AFL 2022 Round 14 - Tigers v Blues Thurs June 16th 7:20pm (MCG)

[beema limapep]

Total free kicks for Round 1 and last night:-

Carlton 45
Richmond 40.

Total 50m penalties awarded over both games:-

Carlton 7
Richmond 1.

Percentage of umpiring decisions awarded to each team:-

Carlton 57%
Richmon 43%

Richmond fans:- "Ok, maybe we need to focus on playing better as we can't control the umpires"
Carlton fans:- "It's not fair! We need more free kicks!!!"

 

[jooce8891]

Weitering and Cerra are the two obvious ones replacing Durdin and Newnes. Who are the others that were out tonight and who do they replace?

cerra doesnt replace newnes, shows how much you know about our team.

 

[tiger_tough]

Are there worse losers in the comp than Carlton fans? Suck it up sooks, you got bullied in the wet by a team that had supposedly hit the cliff 12 months ago. Hope Grimes remembers to take Curnow out of his pocket before his Mrs does the washing.

 

[jooce8891]

Total free kicks for Round 1 and last night:-

Carlton 45
Richmond 40.

Total 50m penalties awarded over both games:-

Carlton 7
Richmond 0.

Percentage of umpiring decisions awarded to each team:-

Carlton 58%
Richmon 42%

Richmond fans:- "Ok, maybe we need to focus on playing better as we can't control the umpires"
Carlton fans:- "It's not fair! We need more free kicks!!!"

probably the worst 50m penalty i've ever seen

 

[Rich01]

cerra doesnt replace newnes, shows how much you know about our team.

Who does he replace?

 

[jooce8891]

Who does he replace?

cottrell

 

[Rich01]

I thought the umpiring was ok last night.

Harry played a great game without getting his regulation two frees from flopping.

Richmond’s discipline with the stand and dissent rule was much better than round one where we gave up 8 goals to these silly free kicks.

Cripps got away with a couple of quick throws in the contest but I’m sure it evened out elsewhere.

Teams were made to earn their goals on the main which was great.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

cerra doesnt replace newnes, shows how much you know about our team.

Only the teams in contention are worth examining

 

[bmaurizio]

I thought the umpiring was ok last night.

Harry played a great game without getting his regulation two frees from flopping.

Richmond’s discipline with the stand and dissent rule was much better than round one where we gave up 8 goals to these silly free kicks.

Cripps got away with a couple of quick throws in the contest but I’m sure it evened out elsewhere.

Teams were made to earn their goals on the main which was great.

Yup overall we accept that umpiring decisions & interpretations vary and fluctuate, its the nature of the game.Overall last night was an acceptable standard.
A tough, relentless game by two teams at different stages of progress at this time.
if the Baggers get a sniff come September , Weitering & Pitto return firing it will be very interesting indeed.
Give Harry & Charlie a reasonable ball supply and they’ll decimate any opposition.

 

[PenfoldsFan]

Both average teams in all honesty but atleast Carlton have an excuse with their injury list.
Richmond had the rub 2 weeks in a row against average teams and still only won both games by 15pts.
Destined to be the next Geelong, making up the numbers in the 8 due to 'factors' and bundled out come finals.

 

[Plugger35]

probably the worst 50m penalty i've ever seen

That's pretty bad but some of the dissent 50m penalties paid this year were worse like McKenzie getting pinged for telling the umpire the ball bounced.

 

[jooce8891]

Only the teams in contention are worth examining

fair enough

 

[Dinith]

Both average teams in all honesty but atleast Carlton have an excuse with their injury list.
Richmond had the rub 2 weeks in a row against average teams and still only won both games by 15pts.
Destined to be the next Geelong, making up the numbers in the 8 due to 'factors' and bundled out come finals.

 

[bourbons]

Moving forward, you think we will see players ‘twinkling’ their fingers when attempting to smother?

Or, will clubs get the guy from Police Academy to teach players how to mimic the sound of a ball being touched?

Spirit fingers!!

 

[Gratees]

Just gonna say from a tigers perspective, thought saad played a ripper

 

[JyeDye]

Anyone complaining about the free kicks costing Carlton the match are delusional. We were outplayed considerably and honestly the score board flattered us. Apart from a hot 5 minutes in the final term Richmond were comfortably better for most of the game. Injuries happen, we’ve had terrible luck, but our defense was not the issue. We were beaten around the ball in a wet game and I don’t know if Richmond train for it but they soccered the ball of the ground to a mark like 10 times. Was insane how good they played the conditions. We’ve seen our best is up there with the best in the league, but we can’t keep it up consistently and against a well drilled side like Richmond they showed us up.

 

[tiger_tough]

probably the worst 50m penalty i've ever seen

Kidding aren't ya? Took an eternity.

 

[jooce8891]

Kidding aren't ya? Took an eternity.

if he throws the ball back early, he hits grimes in the back and its 50 meters anyway.

 

[tiger_tough]

if he throws the ball back early, he hits grimes in the back and its 50 meters anyway.

Doubt that very much. Not curnows fault if grimes isn't watching.

Curnow had one intention and that was to delay giving the ball back as long as possible. It was dumb footy.

 

[jooce8891]

Doubt that very much. Not curnows fault if grimes isn't watching.

Curnow had one intention and that was to delay giving the ball back as long as possible. It was dumb footy.

i guarentee you if curnow throws the ball hits grimes in the back, ball drops onto the ground umpire pays a 50 meter penalty, smart from grimes ill give you that as he definitely knew what he was doing but the umpire should've recognised that.

 

[Area51]

probably the worst 50m penalty i've ever seen

Ump didn't give him 50, only 35.

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

weitering - best defender and our vice captain
pittonet - only true ruck option
marchbank - looked 1000x better with him playing last week
cerra - starting 22 midfielder
williams - starting 22 defender
mcgovern - looked 2000x better when he played earlier in year and was close to BOG rd 1 vs. tiges

cunningham - was best 22 last year and would be this year, but hasn't played all year so can't count him
o mcdonald - best 22 at start of year but only played 1 game, so can't count him
ed curnow - likely finished but decent depth if required
williamson - showed promise early and played plenty of seniors, but handy depth but off for mental health reasons
parks - played seniors last year, fringe this year.

so 6 bona-fide best 22 and mostly key players, followed by 5 depth/fringe players.

in case anyone wanted a true understanding of the injury list.

Would love to know who players like
McDonald
Ed Curnow
Williamson
Parks
Machbank
McGovern

Woudl replace if there was no injuries at all , I doubt 5 out of 6 would even be selected in the best side

 

[G String]

Would love to know who players like
McDonald
Ed Curnow
Williamson
Parks
Machbank
McGovern

Woudl replace if there was no injuries at all , I doubt 5 out of 6 would even be selected in the best side

theyd be lucky to be selected in our VFL side

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Would love to know who players like
McDonald
Ed Curnow
Williamson
Parks
Machbank
McGovern

Woudl replace if there was no injuries at all , I doubt 5 out of 6 would even be selected in the best side

It's not even worth discussing, they're still a bottom 6 side, nothing has changed

They'll beat the Eagles in round 17 but lose every other game and finish 13th-14th

 

[bourbons]

We were beaten around the ball in a wet game and I don’t know if Richmond train for it but they soccered the ball of the ground to a mark like 10 times.

Ha yep, meant to mention this - how many times did they hack a kick forward off the ground or even out of mid-air and flush it to a teammate on the tit! Incredible