Is the top 4 set?

[SuperSub17]

Sore loser? Please. We hated that ground. It wasn't our home ground and was never a true reflection of who we are and the game style that we played back then. I don't factor that in to this whole "Pies have the wood over Sydney in Sydney" record. Your record at the SCG is poor. Ours is good. We've been better at the SCG this year then the last 3 years. There's a reason why you're $3.90 or whatever it is for this game.

I wouldn’t say poor, it’s 4-2 to Sydney in recent times and two of those losses we pissed away from winning positions. Last year when we were terrible we cracked in for a half before falling away in the last quarter.

And unless we get smashed on Friday night, I’ll be shocked if Collingwood start that game longer than $3.

 

[My Tilly]

I’ll be shocked if Collingwood start that game longer than $3.

Currently $3.73 odds.

 

[PieLebo87]

Currently $3.73 odds.

Quote the full paragraph

And unless we get smashed on Friday night, I’ll be shocked if Collingwood start that game longer than $3.

 

[South of the Yarra]

Pies seem to stack up as good if not better than anyone against the top 8 sides.

Why Pies might be legit: Your club's record against the top eight

The Magpies have their doubters, but they have a good record against current top-eight sides

www.afl.com.au

 

[Fadge]

Those odds against Sydney are ridiculous.

Can't get enough on it.

 

[PieLebo87]

Pies seem to stack up as good if not better than anyone against the top 8 sides.

Why Pies might be legit: Your club's record against the top eight

The Magpies have their doubters, but they have a good record against current top-eight sides

www.afl.com.au

This won’t go down well on BF

Ironically, Pies have one of the highest percentages in the competition in that ladder vs top 8 sides.

 

[Fadge]

This won’t go down well on BF

Ironically, Pies have one of the highest percentages in the competition in that ladder vs top 8 sides.

Yeah, but we've struggled to beat the 10 x bottom 4 sides, so we're clearly no good...

 

[SuperSub17]

This won’t go down well on BF

Ironically, Pies have one of the highest percentages in the competition in that ladder vs top 8 sides.

We were shouted down all throughout 2018 because we apparently could only beat bottom sides—now it’s the other way around for some reason.

Anything less than 22-0 @ 200% isn’t good enough for some people here.

 

[00Stinger]

We were shouted down all throughout 2018 because we apparently could only beat bottom sides—now it’s the other way around for some reason.

Anything less than 22-0 @ 200% isn’t good enough for some people here.

And what did you win in 2018?

 

[Fadge]

And what did you win in 2018?

Yeah, less than a kick from a flag suggests we were genuine contenders ya dill.

 

[CheapCharlie]

Currently $3.73 odds.

Seems astounding, but could be a reflection of Collingwood coming off an intensive game against Port and likely Melb, whereas Sydney has an easy run against GWS and probably North and will be fresher

 

[Arr0w]

This won’t go down well on BF

Ironically, Pies have one of the highest percentages in the competition in that ladder vs top 8 sides.

Can change quickly though, Dogs or Tigers replace Saints and your record then becomes 3 - 3 with a reduced %

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Can change quickly though, Dogs or Tigers replace Saints and your record then becomes 3 - 3 with a reduced %

Even worse when Dogs and Tigers replace Saints and Blues

 

[Arr0w]

Even worse when Dogs and Tigers replace Saints and Blues

If the Dogs replace Saints, both us and you have a 3-3 record

Essentially, means little in the scheme of things. More about the health and form come 1st week of finals

 

[Corn Cobbers]

If the Dogs replace Saints, both us and you have a 3-3 record

Essentially, means little in the scheme of things. More about the health and form come 1st week of finals

Yes, 2016 is still fresh in the memory

 

[OniAu]

Can change quickly though, Dogs or Tigers replace Saints and your record then becomes 3 - 3 with a reduced %

I love how the goal posts are changed every time Collingwood has something said about them

"But if this and this happened it wouldnt be the case"

 

[Arr0w]

I love how the goal posts are changed every time Collingwood has something said about them

"But if this and this happened it wouldnt be the case"

Don't get so defensive, I ain't bagging your side

 

[PJays]

This won’t go down well on BF

Ironically, Pies have one of the highest percentages in the competition in that ladder vs top 8 sides.

Yeah but they were comprehensively beaten by 9th and 10th

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I love how the goal posts are changed every time Collingwood has something said about them

"But if this and this happened it wouldnt be the case"

Nothing creates panic like Collingwood success

Eg last two times we won a flag, the AFL added a new team and changed the bench rules dramatically for the next season

 

[OniAu]

Don't get so defensive, I ain't bagging your side

Not defensive , so amusing how conflicting all the points of view on the pies are

 

[PieLebo87]

Yeah but they were comprehensively beaten by 9th and 10th

Facts finally get shared, and because they go against your opinion, you still come up with something to shoot us down.

 

[Arr0w]

Not defensive , so amusing how conflicting all the points of view on the pies are

You must have missed this "Essentially, means little in the scheme of things. More about the health and form come 1st week of finals"

A statement for any side that makes finals

 

[PJays]

Facts finally get shared, and because they go against your opinion, you still come up with something to shoot us down.

Collingwood 4-2 vs top 8

That's a tiny sample size, meaning that AFL com au piece is just hype fluff

But, the point I was making was there's little separating 7th-10th, and in fact the bookies rate 9th and 10th a good chance of making the 8 ($1.91 and $2.00), a better chance than 8th ($4.00).

Whining when I mention highly relevant results vs 9th and 10th, again shows you need to take off your black and white glasses and pick a more neutral shade

 

[PieLebo87]

Collingwood 4-2 vs top 8

That's a tiny sample size, meaning that AFL com au piece is just hype fluff

But, the point I was making was there's little separating 7th-10th, and in fact the bookies rate 9th and 10th a good chance of making the 8 ($1.91 and $2.00), a better chance than 8th ($4.00).

Whining when I mention highly relevant results vs 9th and 10th, again shows you need to take off your black and white glasses and pick a more neutral shade

You’re sooking again.

“Tiny sample size”, “It’s fluff” bla bla bla… all you’ve got is negativity towards the Pies. I initially thought you were up for proper debates but all you do is sprout s**t about Collingwood. It’s a public forum, so it’s within your right, but you’ve exposed yourself as a hater and there’s nothing impartial about you or your opinions on Collingwood.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

You’re sooking again.

“Tiny sample size”, “It’s fluff” bla bla bla… all you’ve got is negativity towards the Pies. I initially thought you were up for proper debates but all you do is sprout s**t about Collingwood. It’s a public forum, so it’s within your right, but you’ve exposed yourself as a hater and there’s nothing impartial about you or your opinions on Collingwood.

He's not a hater, he's just jealous, they all are