Traded Luke Jackson [Traded with #44 and #67 to Fremantle for #13, F1 and F2]

[King Huskii]

so contracted what is he worth?

He's not contracted so it doesn't matter

 

[danster168]

He's not contracted so it doesn't matter

convenient

 

[mrpez]

I would suggest some in this thread need to settle down, a long way to go with trade week (month?). It's likely the deal can't get done until other pieces are put in place first.

Freo want 13 and F1
Melb want 7ish and F1

I think history will show that it will be done for something in the middle, ie.

7ish and F1 with something coming back to Freo OR
13 and F1 + later round pick

 

[King Huskii]

convenient

What drugs are you on?

He's uncontracted so it's a moot point. I think you purposely post nonsense to get a reaction

 

[WilloTree]

true. but that's because you've restricted your thinking. Maybe Jackson could be the afl's first 199cm inside mid. He has those abilities. Ashcroft will only ever be a run of the mill midfielder. Jackson could be anything. Wce or freo are paying for elements of potential but also paying from what they've already seen. which is remarkable for a guy so young.

Bit harsh on Ashcroft there - poor dude hasn't played a game yet. I'll reserve judgement though, as you seem to be pretty good an valuing players.

 

[danster168]

What drugs are you on?

He's uncontracted so it's a moot point. I think you purposely post nonsense to get a reaction

This is the luke jackson thread. what do you think he is worth uncontracted? other than 'melbourne will take what freo offer'?

pick 13 and a future 1?

 

[Mudman85]

yeah you're club are paying upto 900k over 7 years for a 21yr old based on nothing.

All are hypothetical but draft picks are sure things. Lol. I guess Jonathan O Rourke is a gun then

Now it’s $900k!

Guarantee it’s nothing close to $900 x 7.

 

[Tony_Clifton]

This is the luke jackson thread. what do you think he is worth uncontracted? other than 'melbourne will take what freo offer'?

pick 13 and a future 1?

Hpnfooty's trade calculator rates him as equal to pick 2 or equal to pick 13 + 14.

13 and 14 is pretty much what we are offering.

 

[WilloTree]

I would suggest some in this thread need to settle down, a long way to go with trade week (month?). It's likely the deal can't get done until other pieces are put in place first.

Freo want 13 and F1
Melb want 7ish and F1

I think history will show that it will be done for something in the middle, ie.

7ish and F1 with something coming back to Freo
13 and F1 + later round pick

What about lots more moving parts just for the spectacle? This is going on film after all.

13, F1, F2, 76 for Jackson, 27, a F4 and a banana.

 

[Mudman85]

What about lots more moving parts just for the spectacle? This is going on film after all.

13, F1, F2, 76 for Jackson, 27, a F4 and a banana.

Throw in 4 tickets to the Melbourne Grand Prix in a corporate box

 

[danster168]

Hpnfooty's trade calculator rates him as equal to pick 2 or equal to pick 13 + 14.

Appreciate the correction. yeah Jackson was taken at pick 3. After winning the RS and producing at a high level in 2021, he's clearly worth more than pick 2 alone ,if contracted.

 

[eastfreo75]

Appreciate the correction. yeah Jackson was taken at pick 3. After winning the RS and producing at a high level in 2021, he's clearly worth more than pick 2 alone ,if contracted.

If Contracted.

That’s the main point.

I am pretty sure Jackson’s performance will get better but we don’t know that.

A lot of young players has started out well but his performances are not AA.

 

[Tony_Clifton]

Appreciate the correction. yeah Jackson was taken at pick 3. After winning the RS and producing at a high level in 2021, he's clearly worth more than pick 2 alone ,if contracted.

HPN rates his future output as the equivalent of what the average pick 13 and 14 output would be. I say average to let you know that their calculations include the hits and misses.

So they independently value him as 13 and 14. If he's contracted Melbourne could reject any offer they didn't like so it's hard to say how much over 13 or 14 would be needed to satisfy them. I guess it would depend on the desperation of the buyer.

That brings us to the fact that he is uncontacted. It follows that the buyer offering more than 13 and 14 would be overpaying. In fact, making a fair offer is in fact quite generous.

 

[Tony_Clifton]

After winning the RS and producing at a high level in 2021, he's clearly worth more than pick 2 alone ,if contracted.

Why no mention of his efforts in 2022? Surely his latest year has more relevance to his current worth.

 

[danster168]

Why no mention of his efforts in 2022? Surely his latest year has more relevance to his current worth.

Let me think..maybe because he's 20. A bit rich to focus on Jackson's 2022 when Sean Darcy was worse.

 

[danster168]

If Contracted.

That’s the main point.

I am pretty sure Jackson’s performance will get better but we don’t know that.

A lot of young players has started out well but his performances are not AA.

I agree. but at least he has started well. Draft picks are far more speculative.

 

[danster168]

Now it’s $900k!

Guarantee it’s nothing close to $900 x 7.

Another example of someone who shoots someone down without putting their name next to an actual figure. what a comfy position to be in

 

[eastfreo75]

I

I agree. but at least he has started well. Draft picks are far more speculative.

They are.

More speculative than young players 1-4 years.

The reality is that picks are overrated but that’s how the market is.

Sure picks 13 and F1 is unders but he is uncontracted and the threat of the preseason draft is in the back of the minds of all parties.

Anyway see what happens.

 

[danster168]

They are.

More speculative than young players 1-4 years.

The reality is that picks are overrated but that’s how the market is.

Sure picks 13 and F1 is unders but he is uncontracted and the threat of the preseason draft is in the back of the minds of all parties.

Anyway see what happens.

I think Melbourne will eventually cave in.

But this is why the points system is flawed. The quality of the picks in the top 5 is exponentially better than other first rounders.

for example, what would you prefer:
Pick 1? or Pick 13,15 & 25? According to the draft pick points calculator theyre the same but at the end of the day Pick 1 gives you access to elite talent, option 2 gives you none.

 

[Tony_Clifton]

Let me think..maybe because he's 20. A bit rich to focus on Jackson's 2022 when Sean Darcy was worse.

I think when evaluating Jackson's worth in 2022 you can't say how well he performed in 2021, say how he won the rising star in 2021 without at least mentioning his 2022 performance. It is disingenuous.
And your counter argument as to why Jackson's 2022 performance should not be used in assessing his worth has something to do with how well Sean Darcy played.

 

[eastfreo75]

I think Melbourne will eventually cave in.

But this is why the points system is flawed. The quality of the picks in the top 5 is exponentially better than other first rounders.

for example, what would you prefer:
Pick 1? or Pick 13,15 & 25? According to the draft pick points calculator theyre the same but at the end of the day Pick 1 gives you access to elite talent, option 2 gives you none.

Points is flawed and I wish people stop using it.

Top picks are 30-50% undervalued.

Pick 1 should be 4000-4500 points and not 3000.

 

[Tony_Clifton]

for example, what would you prefer:
Pick 1? or Pick 13,15 & 25? According to the draft pick points calculator theyre the same but at the end of the day Pick 1 gives you access to elite talent, option 2 gives you none.

You speak in such definitives.

 

[gawndog37]

Why no mention of his efforts in 2022? Surely his latest year has more relevance to his current worth.

Every Freo supporter acting like he was absolute garbage this year. This year compared to 2021 he almost doubled per game his tackles, centre clearances, inside 50s, whilst also making great improvements in stoppage clearances, intercepts, and cutting down on turnovers. It might be irrelevant because he's going to be playing with Darcy but his one game playing as sole ruck vs Brisbane he was one of our best players with 21 touches and 9 tackles showcasing the strides he has made. He was battling a knee injury in the second half of the year and the shorter pre season combined with the loss of our fitness boss lead to a lot of our players running out of gas by the end of the year which I believe Jacko was a culprit of.

 

[Tony_Clifton]

Noone said his 2022 was trash. Just pointing out that Danster, when arguing Jackson's worth, only mentioned Jackson's 2021 performance.

 

[Kanye West]

Every Freo supporter acting like...

No need to read any further!