List Mgmt. 2022 AFL Draft & Rookie Draft

[Aphrodite]

 

[DangerousD]

TDK… Likely 5 on the bench…

TDK could rotate Fwd/Ruck and chop out in defence…

I still think it’s silly, we have two great forwards, neither ruck which is fine, if we add another forward, if they don’t or can’t ruck, it really limits flexibility. I like the sound of Keeler or any ruck who can actually be a threat up forward.

 

[Arr0w]

I still think it’s silly, we have two great forwards, neither ruck which is fine, if we add another forward, if they don’t or can’t ruck, it really limits flexibility. I like the sound of Keeler or any ruck who can actually be a threat up forward.

I agree, I would rather look at a Barnett, Foster, Verrell, Petric types through the draft

 

[Arr0w]

Kid I like last year before doing an ACL. Luke Taylor, Sam's brother. Came back to the WAFL colts & reserves, kicking 6 goals in 4 games.

Can play both ends

Might be a worthwhile rookie/ssp option

 

[Coona Blues]

Kid I like last year before doing an ACL. Luke Taylor, Sam's brother. Came back to the WAFL colts & reserves, kicking 6 goals in 4 games.

Can play both ends

Might be a worthwhile rookie/ssp option

Nice pick up. Checked for him a couple of times through the year. Stopped looking. You found him. Low numbers, but two colts games then played reserves finals. Interesting. May need a body of work next year, but definitely a watch.

 

[FitzroyBlueBagger]

Like a few have already suggested,
Be good if we could split our 10/29 picks and add another second rounder by trading out a future second/maybe some shuffling of later picks, If we don’t keep 10 i like these four around the 13-27 range, traits we need are speed skill/polish decision making/ball use 2way run/pressure & scoreboard damage would be good…

Hotton :forward - midfielder
George :forward
Hewett : midfielder
Burgiel : midfielder - forward

 

[katmanblue]

You could be right. I have no problem with Sheezel at pick 10, I am just not sure he is a top 5 pick.

He'll go pick 2 or 3.

On SM-F926B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Arr0w]

Nice pick up. Checked for him a couple of times through the year. Stopped looking. You found him. Low numbers, but two colts games then played reserves finals. Interesting. May need a body of work next year, but definitely a watch.

You know I have always been keen. More likely he gets picked up as a rookie by a WA club, but I am definitely interested

 

[Arr0w]

Like a few have already suggested,
Be good if we could split our 10/29 picks and add another second rounder by trading out a future second/maybe some shuffling of later picks, If we don’t keep 10 i like these four around the 13-27 range, traits we need are speed skill/polish decision making/ball use 2way run/pressure & scoreboard damage would be good…

Hotton :forward - midfielder
George :forward
Hewett : midfielder
Burgiel : midfielder - forward

Hewett will also start as a forward

 

[Juice030103]

What’s the knock on Phillopou?

190cm blokes that are quick don’t grow on trees so why’s he not top 3?

 

[LemmingMaster]

I feel we have some depth in KP defence for 2023 (Weitering, Young, Marchbank, Kemp, SDurdin, Akui (developing), McGov & Plowman (3rd talls).
We need forward key position depth to develop and push through, so I would take one of Keeler or Lemmey with our second - forward/ruck.
Would be stoked if we drafted one at 2nd and one at 3rd.
Take the best available midfielder/runner at pick 10 - probably Humphrey/Pillipou/Hewett/George.
Take the best defender available with our 4th - depending on what is available.
There my thoughts.

First round picks should be best available and only using positional needs if it is a borderline selection.

Often a good player can slide in a draft and who knows which player that may be for Carlton.

Pick 29 - Which will most likely be 31 or so on draft night....

Hustwaite, Weddle, Barrnett styled tall player may draft in the draft. If Allan dropped this far, certainly jump on board.
Darcy Jones or Hagan player that drops due to their height are also great options. Elite level footballers that are vertically challenged.
I was a big Liam Baker fan in his draft year and the only reason he dropped as far as he did was purely height related.
You could even say the same thing about Caleb Daniel as well, elite levels football players with height concerns.

 

[LemmingMaster]

What’s the knock on Phillopou?

190cm blokes that are quick don’t grow on trees so why’s he not top 3?

Is he an AFL level midfielder is the real question. If not, what position will he play at AFL level?

Many of the guys rated ahead of him have a larger body of evidence to be able to play midfield. This is why Ginbey jumped up the order, he went for a HBF to dominating as an inside midfielder at higher levels.

 

[Arr0w]

First round picks should be best available and only using positional needs if it is a borderline selection.

Often a good player can slide in a draft and who knows which player that may be for Carlton.

Pick 29 - Which will most likely be 31 or so on draft night....

Hustwaite, Weddle, Barrnett styled tall player may draft in the draft. If Allan dropped this far, certainly jump on board.
Darcy Jones or Hagan player that drops due to their height are also great options. Elite level footballers that are vertically challenged.
I was a big Liam Baker fan in his draft year and the only reason he dropped as far as he did was purely height related.
You could even say the same thing about Caleb Daniel as well, elite levels football players with height concerns.

Contenders you like for our first pick LM?

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

What’s the knock on Phillopou?

190cm blokes that are quick don’t grow on trees so why’s he not top 3?

Is he quick?

Don't know why but just not warming to Phillipou. Getting some major Ben Lennon vibes about him and feels like a bit of a trap. Just a gut feel.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

What’s the knock on Phillopou?

190cm blokes that are quick don’t grow on trees so why’s he not top 3?

Wouldn't say he's quick by any measure. He's a good runner in comparison but he's much more on the Cripps side of speed than a Bontempelli, Danger etc. Strong over the ball and a good kick but he's not the type who's going to stream away in open space.

 

[macky99]

Wouldn't say he's quick by any measure. He's a good runner in comparison but he's much more on the Cripps side of speed than a Bontempelli, Danger etc. Strong over the ball and a good kick but he's not the type who's going to stream away in open space.

Nothing wrong with that, Pendlebury at Collingwood is a great example of that, good decision making and ball use by foot or hand is equally important.

 

[Arr0w]

Wouldn't say he's quick by any measure. He's a good runner in comparison but he's much more on the Cripps side of speed than a Bontempelli, Danger etc. Strong over the ball and a good kick but he's not the type who's going to stream away in open space.

Although, does run a sub 3 sec 20 metres, for a 192cm guy, who will shed, then build a core, it's a nice starting point

Also, has a decent tank

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Nothing wrong with that, Pendlebury at Collingwood is a great example of that, good decision making and ball use by foot or hand is equally important.

I think Philippou looks a tad slow with his decision making too, doesn't seem to play as much off instinct as for instance a Tsatas or Sheezel, but that could be down to all sorts of reasons. Has all the tools to be a quality player and even a top echelon mid/fwd if developed well... But I think in combination, a few of these factors are the reason he's not a top 3 prospect which is what the poster above posed the question about.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Although, does run a sub 3 sec 20 metres, for a 192cm guy, who will shed, then build a core, it's a nice starting point

Also, has a decent tank

As he sheds down and adds to his explosiveness in the gym he'll probably gain that yard or two of pace and agility that he'd need to be a top line player. Similar to Cripps when he first came into the league.

 

[Arr0w]

As he sheds down and adds to his explosiveness in the gym he'll probably gain that yard or two of pace and agility that he'd need to be a top line player. Similar to Cripps when he first came into the league.

Has better forward craft than Cripps, in fact he is a forward more than a mid

 

[ctwenty1]

Think he is gone earlier than that.

If I was doing a phantom draft, without Ashcroft

GWS Cadman
North Wardlaw
North Sheezel
* Tsatas
GC Hollands
Hawks McKenzie
Cats Clark
WC Busslinger

Saints, no idea what they do

Well can you give that a bit of thought? Apparently they are scouting bigfooty for ideas.

 

[JuddgementDay]

I think Philippou looks a tad slow with his decision making too, doesn't seem to play as much off instinct as for instance a Tsatas or Sheezel, but that could be down to all sorts of reasons. Has all the tools to be a quality player and even a top echelon mid/fwd if developed well... But I think in combination, a few of these factors are the reason he's not a top 3 prospect which is what the poster above posed the question about.

Philipou has deficiencies and doesn’t make the cut for top 5, in fact I’ve seen him running away from a booze bus - only Carlton would take on a player like that

 

[Dadda Dave]

Agree with DD, we need a draft a key position forward.

Cheers..
Anytime...

 

[ctwenty1]

Philipou has deficiencies and doesn’t make the cut for top 5, in fact I’ve seen him running away from a booze bus - only Carlton would take on a player like that

Well if that’s the case then , as long as he doesn’t play basketball socially, or use stairs, I’d be happy with him

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Is he an AFL level midfielder is the real question. If not, what position will he play at AFL level?

Many of the guys rated ahead of him have a larger body of evidence to be able to play midfield. This is why Ginbey jumped up the order, he went for a HBF to dominating as an inside midfielder at higher levels.

Definitely starts as a medium forward at AFL level. Dont think there would be to much trouble transitioning into midfield regardless. Would be an excellent get for us.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Has better forward craft than Cripps, in fact he is a forward more than a mid

Definitely a forward first.