Admin Notice S37 Rules & Tribunal Thread

[Headless]

Serial probably classes Leigh Brown a Fremantle premiership player as well, such are the wonderful bows he draws.

oh!

 

[serial_thrilla]

Serial probably classes Leigh Brown a Fremantle premiership player as well, such are the wonderful bows he draws.

Don't forget West Coast triple premiership player Tim Watson...

 

[Pie 4 Life]

All I know is I should have had serial_thrilla as my lawyer when Cadsky and Tigerturbulance worked out damicky stole the Mobbs Medal votes!

 

[AnUltimateRessie]

Do you have anymore serial_thrilla might as well get all these decisions done in one go down in the committee hole

 

[Tadpole]

Pity he hasn't been set on fire.

 

[serial_thrilla]

Do you have anymore serial_thrilla might as well get all these decisions done in one go down in the committee hole

 

[DragoDelph]

I do believe the wording needs to be adjusted here to save any ambiguity moving forward. However it's obvious enough that a returning player should fall under the exact same sign up rules as a new player. IMO they are a new player, having not been on a list immediately prior to being signed.

Agree with this

Option #2 is my preference. Reword the rules for the future, stating that both new and returning players need to post on the subforum prior to (re)listing. Then ensure that the four Hawks breaches are rectified ASAP, with no penalty (I believe a couple have posted today already) .

 

[T2B_]

serial_thrilla do you have an official league capacity or is it fine to put you on ignore and give a * only when actual league delegates bring up issues relevant to my team?

 

[DragoDelph]

Also, will have to say that the intent in the rule would be new or returning players. But there is clearly too much room for interpretation and the rule needs to be amended.

How has it been ruled in the past? That should be how these current matters are addressed, and the rule redefined.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Also, will have to say that the intent in the rule would be new or returning players. But there is clearly too much room for interpretation and the rule needs to be amended.

How has it been ruled in the past? That should be how these current matters are addressed, and the rule redefined.

A new player does not necessarily understand what the competition entails and what they are committing to. A returning player does.

Chalk and cheese.

 

[Gralin]

A new player does not necessarily understand what the competition entails and what they are committing to. A returning player does.

Chalk and cheese.

Wait you understand what the competition entails?
But you went to the Hawks....

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Wait you understand what the competition entails?
But you went to the Hawks....

One season with you was enough dear chap.

 

[damicky]

A new player does not necessarily understand what the competition entails and what they are committing to. A returning player does.

Chalk and Remy the Rat.

Fixed it for you

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Fixed it for you

serial_thrilla if you peruse the rules to find a way to deregister damicky I’ll be nicer to you?

 

[serial_thrilla]

serial_thrilla if you peruse the rules to find a way to deregister damicky I’ll be nicer to you?

Even if I can't, we probably should petition Elton Johns Wig for an amendment.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Even if I can't, we probably should petition Elton Johns Wig for an amendment.

Spirit of the rules amirite?

 

[Gralin]

One season with you was enough dear chap.

I've walked straight into that one

 

[Cadsky]

serial_thrilla if you peruse the rules to find a way to deregister damicky I’ll be nicer to you?

Think you need to blame the Rats here

 

[damicky]

serial_thrilla if you peruse the rules to find a way to deregister damicky I’ll be nicer to you?

 

[Tadpole]

Think you need to blame the Rats here

They have a rat in their ranks.

 

[Headless]

Oh. And this obvious one, with Demons' phantom acquisition appearing on the INs, but not the actual squad:

View attachment 1893985


As per Rule 4B:

4B) Squad Changes

Any changes to the previous season's final squad must be listed in the current season's initial squad submission denoting the additions as "INs" and subtractions as "OUTs".

If a change is required to a team list for any addition or subtraction it must be noted in a post in the current season's squad submission thread.

The change must include alteration to both the player list, and the list of any additions ("Ins") and subtractions ("Outs")

The initial squad submission must be altered (preferred) or re-posted (if original poster unavailable) to reflect these changes.

Once initiated, squad changes are only considered complete once both of these above actions have been carried out concurrently.

Any players involved in squad changes are unable to be named in a team sheet for the new team until a valid change has been completed.

Any players that have closed or permanently banned accounts are not considered to be active and therefore those players must be removed from the submitted squad and the squad minimum criteria must still be met.

A player may only have one account as a listed player in the Sweet FA. No aliases allowed. A minimum 8 game suspension applies for a breach. Alias accounts may be used in a joking manner in media and match threads only, any alias accounts posting in a sign up thread will be considered a breach.

Failure to adhere to these Rules will be punished under Sec[6] of these Rules, as determined by the Administrator


And a very obvious Minor Offence for the Demons:

6B) Minor Offence

The following list of offences will result in a Strike under a 'Three-Strike Policy'. Which is outlined below:

1. Official Warning
2. 1-game suspension to the captain, if there are multiple captains at a club, the captain of the offending club will be randomly selected for suspension.
3. 2 point deduction, plus a 2-game suspension for the captain (if there are multiple captains at a club, the captain of the offending club will be randomly selected for suspension)

• Incorrect squad changes as per 4B

Throw the book at them Elton Johns Wig.

manangatang

 

[por_please_ya]

If Elton Johns Wig needs evidence of consent, Callums_Guns can provide it. Plenty of PMs were sent and approval granted. Nobody was signed without them wanting to be.

 

[Headless]

If Elton Johns Wig needs evidence of consent, Callums_Guns can provide it. Plenty of PMs were sent and approval granted. Nobody was signed without them wanting to be.

Yeah this is a pretty clear no penalty scenario IMO.

 

[Headless]

Oh. And this obvious one, with Demons' phantom acquisition appearing on the INs, but not the actual squad:

View attachment 1893985


As per Rule 4B:

4B) Squad Changes

Any changes to the previous season's final squad must be listed in the current season's initial squad submission denoting the additions as "INs" and subtractions as "OUTs".

If a change is required to a team list for any addition or subtraction it must be noted in a post in the current season's squad submission thread.

The change must include alteration to both the player list, and the list of any additions ("Ins") and subtractions ("Outs")

The initial squad submission must be altered (preferred) or re-posted (if original poster unavailable) to reflect these changes.

Once initiated, squad changes are only considered complete once both of these above actions have been carried out concurrently.

Any players involved in squad changes are unable to be named in a team sheet for the new team until a valid change has been completed.

Any players that have closed or permanently banned accounts are not considered to be active and therefore those players must be removed from the submitted squad and the squad minimum criteria must still be met.

A player may only have one account as a listed player in the Sweet FA. No aliases allowed. A minimum 8 game suspension applies for a breach. Alias accounts may be used in a joking manner in media and match threads only, any alias accounts posting in a sign up thread will be considered a breach.

Failure to adhere to these Rules will be punished under Sec[6] of these Rules, as determined by the Administrator


And a very obvious Minor Offence for the Demons:

6B) Minor Offence

The following list of offences will result in a Strike under a 'Three-Strike Policy'. Which is outlined below:

1. Official Warning
2. 1-game suspension to the captain, if there are multiple captains at a club, the captain of the offending club will be randomly selected for suspension.
3. 2 point deduction, plus a 2-game suspension for the captain (if there are multiple captains at a club, the captain of the offending club will be randomly selected for suspension)

• Incorrect squad changes as per 4B

Throw the book at them Elton Johns Wig.

manangatang

Yeah this one is also pretty clearly no penalty IMO.

 

[por_please_ya]

I'm glad we are seeing some sense here.

Giant Strides one is fair enough and we will accept the warning strike.