Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

[Strapping Young Lad]

2024 Picks



2025 Picks

 

[smish]

Rotham or Melican as tall backs?

Melican will be 28 next year and we can get him for nothing as he's a UFA. Not opposed to that at all.

Rotham however is a RFA. I reckon we may have been trying to get him over last year too.

 

[Blackhawk42]

I rate Melican.

 

[PenAndPaper]

I rate Melican.

Yep, he is very solid and works his ass off.

 

[Hot Cheese Rioli]

Would we get anything for these Hawk FA's?

Luke Breust
Blake Hardwick
Harry Morrison
Conor Nash
Cooper Stephens*
Chad Wingard*

When have we typically looked to lock in new contracts for our free agents? Thinking about when we should start to worry with Hardwick and Nash. Guessing around mid-season bye period?

I know that usually the longer it goes, the more you have to worry about...

Edit: just noticed the bye is not until round 15. Feels a lot later than previous seasons.

 

[FB19]

We could probably split our first round pick.

Ours may end up being top 5. Gold Coast have their own first plus one tied to the Dogs. They could both be in the 8-12 range. One of them would be more reasonable for Smith.

Would make sense if we get Bailey Smith given the top picks are mids. O Farrell is a KPD likely to be late top 10 pick at this stage.

 

[Hot Cheese Rioli]

We could probably split our first round pick.

Ours may end up being top 5. Gold Coast have their own first plus one tied to the Dogs. They could both be in the 8-12 range. One of them would be more reasonable for Smith.

100% this. We would definitely split a top 5 pick if a 1st rounder is required for Smith.

 

[AlwaysHawks15]

Only Hardwick and Nash would be worth looking at. Especially the former.

Hardwick in a team close to their premiership window would be in hot demand. Bloke deserves to be part of a team that is contending. Hopefully that's us 1 day.

 

[H00t]

We could probably split our first round pick.

Ours may end up being top 5. Gold Coast have their own first plus one tied to the Dogs. They could both be in the 8-12 range. One of them would be more reasonable for Smith.

If it’s a top 5 pick I’d prefer we just take the pick and think of different way pay for Smith.

Early picks are worth their weight in gold.

 

[cryptor]

Early picks are worth their weight in gold.

How much does a draft pick weigh?

 

[rei154]

If it’s a top 5 pick I’d prefer we just take the pick and think of different way pay for Smith.

Early picks are worth their weight in gold.

If pick purchasing comes in this year or next I wouldn't mind us spending a couple of early picks worth of gold on some top end juniors.
IF we were able to nab Josh Smillie as well as the top performing KPD of the draft I'd say our list would look very exciting moving forward.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Melican is a good shout. 27 until November. Could still have 4+ years ahead of him.

24yr old, 197cm Payne is running around the Lions VFL too, and I assume we'd have enquired.

 

[FB19]

Feel like we are a year too late on melican he seems established best 22 in a team looking likely to contend and who puts pressure on him Hamling? Doubtful.

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

I think that the hawks should now be looking to trade picks.

They have got an excellent young core, mostly in the midfield. These kids have already started growing together and would want to be pushing finals next year. Young kp players take years to develop so I'm not sure drafting there is the best option. Plus they already have Mccabe - who is really exciting - and Ryan developing

I want to see them be aggressive and start trading in 23-28 year olds at either end, particularly down back.

I'd be offering a F1 for Smith too. He'll come. They'll probably be able to buy back a first next year anyway.

 

[suburb whispers]

Melican is a good shout. 27 until November. Could still have 4+ years ahead of him.

24yr old, 197cm Payne is running around the Lions VFL too, and I assume we'd have enquired.

Would be ideal
But signed a contract extension with the Lions until the end of 2029!
Sunshine Coast boy.

 

[smish]

I want Jagga Smith with our first. Looks an absolute stud.

Would be fantastic if we could scrape together the capital for Baz without touching this or next years first if he wants to come to us. How though? Might need to get creative here.

 

[MasterSamurai]

Both jagga and Smillie will be gone by the time we get our turn on draft night I'm afraid. Unless we finish bottom two .

 

[smish]

Both jagga and Smillie will be gone by the time we get our turn on draft night I'm afraid. Unless we finish bottom two .

Draper and O'Sullivan look alright too

 

[FB19]

Both jagga and Smillie will be gone by the time we get our turn on draft night I'm afraid. Unless we finish bottom two .

They will be top 5 but that’s an early
Crow! Finn osullivan a jet Sid Draper too and Ashcroft goes top 5 father son. If we get Smith I don’t see the point in drafting another mid unless we see them as being elite and too good to pass up. As another poster said would hope we are already talking to suns about their first and dogs first for ours.

 

[Sonny Hayes]

I think that the hawks should now be looking to trade picks.

They have got an excellent young core, mostly in the midfield. These kids have already started growing together and would want to be pushing finals next year. Young kp players take years to develop so I'm not sure drafting there is the best option. Plus they already have Mccabe - who is really exciting - and Ryan developing

I want to see them be aggressive and start trading in 23-28 year olds at either end, particularly down back.

I'd be offering a F1 for Smith too. He'll come. They'll probably be able to buy back a first next year anyway.

I think that still might be 12 months away for me personally, i think we hit the draft hard this year and reassess next year.

Happy to look at a Smith at the right price and again look for more value pick ups like a Chol, Ginni and D'ambrosio but our first should be pretty much off the table.

 

[BIGHAWK23]

Both jagga and Smillie will be gone by the time we get our turn on draft night I'm afraid. Unless we finish bottom two .

No they wont

 

[GinniAndTonic]

Say we finish 3rd last and Hardwick decides to leave as a RFA do you reckon we’ll end up with pick 4 as compensation?

 

[Howe Amazing]

Hsun saying other clubs list managers indicating Hawks have 3-4 mill to spend and Rough incentives to land the players. This has to give us a fair bit of hope going forward with existing talent in place. Get it done Rough

 

[Sonny Hayes]

Say we finish 3rd last and Hardwick decides to leave as a RFA do you reckon we’ll end up with pick 4 as compensation?

I would be very very surprised, he is great at what he does but the role itself just isn't really valuable enough to get the sort of offers it requires.

 

[TheFourPillars]

Dimma isn't leaving

 

[Kanga Commando]

Dimma isn't leaving

I hope he gets a healthy contract. Deserves it for the effort he puts in, not to mention reliability and durability.