Opinion 2025 Fantasy - Player X vs Y vs Z

[Lukesera]

Still weighing up this one, but really between Options 1 and 3 atm

If Cerra, Callaghan and Rankine all become 95 players (285), then I'd need Petracca and Horne Francis to go over 100 and NOD to go near 80 just to match it.

But big if on those 3 going at 95.

I’d still back in 1. If Petracca goes 105, you have two keepers as appose to the one keeper, Rankine, in 3.

 

[Coasters7]

Sanders and FOS vs Knevitt and Taylor?

Davidson on field in the second option. Trainor probably on field in both, with Taylor on the bench.

 

[Anzac16]

Prior (D6) + Knevitt (M7) + Sanders (F3) vs SDK (D6) + Hollands (M6) + Berry (F7 - Davidson F6)

 

[happy_eagle]

I’d still back in 1. If Petracca goes 105, you have two keepers as appose to the one keeper, Rankine, in 3.

I'm becoming more and more swayed by the fun of the mid-price madness that comes with Cerra, Callaghan and Rankine.

 

[Trav 20]

Gawn or Xerri

I'd go Xerri.

Xerri is right in his prime, tackles more, and there's a chance they rest Max for a game or two with Tom Campbell now at the club. It's even conceivable they play both Gawn and Campbell in a couple of games.

 

[wahooo]

Sheezel and Kako

Or pending selection, Schoenmaker and JHF?

 

[DukeX]

Langford vs Lalor?
If Lalor starts forward, could really limit his scoring ability

 

[Barrybran]

Sheezel and Kako

Or pending selection, Schoenmaker and JHF?

Sheezel and Kako. I think Kako will have some job security but it's too early to say for sure that Schoenmaker will have the same.

Langford vs Lalor?
If Lalor starts forward, could really limit his scoring ability

How about Lindsay? Both Langford and Lalor will play predominantly forward with stints in the middle.

 

[Funbeanman]

F8

Josh Dolan, Aiden Johnson, Ty Gallop, Finnbar Maley, Max Hall or Archer Reid

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

NOD or Knevitt now Sheldrick isn’t an option?

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

NOD or Knevitt now Sheldrick isn’t an option?

I just worry that Scott will give Knevitt the Jhye Clark/Tanner Bruhn treatment and get poor TOG.

 

[happy_eagle]

I just worry that Scott will give Knevitt the Jhye Clark/Tanner Bruhn treatment and get poor TOG.

Is Knevitt a sub risk ?

 

[Funbeanman]

Is Knevitt a sub risk ?

View attachment 2247936

I would think either Mullin or Clark will be the sub

 

[Sixpence]

Will Ashcroft or Tom Powell? I feel Powell, but I already have Xerri, FOS, Sheezel and Daniel for North and 5 might be too much.

 

[Barnzy]

NOD or Knevitt now Sheldrick isn’t an option?

Personally I think NOD is an overrated pick. He's a winger. One week he might go 80 and next 50. Yes, he might get slightly more midfield time with Young out but Young is back very soon.

I'd prefer Knevitt based off role in theory but he doesn't come without his own risks (Brad Scott doing Brad Scott stuff).

 

[MaxiBont]

Personally I think NOD is an overrated pick. He's a winger. One week he might go 80 and next 50. Yes, he might get slightly more midfield time with Young out but Young is back very soon.

I'd prefer Knevitt based off role in theory but he doesn't come without his own risks (Brad Scott doing Brad Scott stuff).

Yep, funny you say that. I’ve just gone Knevitt over NOD. NOD just seems like a trap but could easily be better than Knevitt

 

[Pee Tear Griffin]

Jack Sinclair or Max Holmes + $77k?

 

[Nunez]

Will Ashcroft or Tom Powell? I feel Powell, but I already have Xerri, FOS, Sheezel and Daniel for North and 5 might be too much.

Powell has pig written all over him. I think he and Croft will both be in the best 10 for the year. Day into Powell is definitely a play after his price rise I reckon.

 

[dplggr47]

Jack Sinclair or Max Holmes + $77k?

I like the latter only because Sinclair is coming back from injury.

 

[ShotTaker1]

Option 1: Will Day [M5] + Harry Perryman [D3] +$3k
Option 2: Harry Sheezel [D1] + Murphy Reid [M9] +$79k (And FOS on-field [M8]).
Option 2.5 (A): Harry Sheezel [D1] + Josh Freijah [D5]
Option 2.5 (B): Max Holmes [D1] + Will Day [M5] (And FOS [Ut] + Sam Taylor [D5]).

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Option 1: Will Day [M5] + Harry Perryman [D3] +$3k
Option 2: Harry Sheezel [D1] + Murphy Reid [M9] +$79k (And FOS on-field [M8]).
Option 2.5 (A): Harry Sheezel [D1] + Josh Freijah [D5]
Option 2.5 (B): Max Holmes [D1] + Will Day [M5] (And FOS [Ut] + Sam Taylor [D5]).

I have option 1.

 

[Barnzy]

Dawson vs Brayshaw?

Feels like upside (Dawson 113 avg in 2023) vs safety (Brayshaw role might be more consistent). But I like going for upside

If Adelaide's coach wasn't an idiot Dawson would in at 80% CBA and averaging 120.

 

[One Dimensional]

Farrell or Bergman?

 

[tigs2010]

Dawson vs Brayshaw?

Feels like upside (Dawson 113 avg in 2023) vs safety (Brayshaw role might be more consistent). But I like going for upside

If Adelaide's coach wasn't an idiot Dawson would in at 80% CBA and averaging 120.

I'm on Dawson but does Windy go to him tomorrow? Durham next week and willPhil the week after? He's probably to big for the last one but could be a slow start

 

[Barnzy]

I'm on Dawson but does Windy go to him tomorrow? Durham next week and willPhil the week after? He's probably to big for the last one but could be a slow start

It's a possibility.

As a previous Dawson owner there is nothing more frustrating watching him with a tag. They move him forward or back and he kind of just floats around. And he's first target of a tag.

Serong seems to take all the tags off Brayshaw