Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy 2025 Rd 4 Blues to petition AFL to halve the length of games

Who played well for the Blues in Round 4 vs the Pies?


  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

He’ll be 20 in a week. If his current level of cardio vascular fitness can’t get him past a quarter as we’ve seen with other players in the same boat at his age it’s quite rare for it to improve considerably beyond maybe half a game.

He had a hip problem through his 18 year which meant he didn't do a proper preseason last offseason and was a slow build through 24.

To think that a 20 year old coming off a bad injury can't improve their fitness is crazy.
 
Doc looks like the game has passed him by, just doesn't have the touch and feel of the game anymore, routinely makes poor decisions, it's almost like he is trying to compensate and tries too hard and isn't handling the heat. He needs a spell in the 2s to get some form and confidence.
Wish his 'trying too hard' would be putting a hit on when it's laid out in front of him.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Look at his goals in 2024 - he averaged pretty much 1 goal/game against non-bottom 4 sides. If he was giving us other things in the areas I mentioned I wouldn't mind but he didn't.
1 goal a game - who else do we have giving that to us ATM.

Owies had forward craft, if nothing else.

He kicked CLUTCH goals in tight games constantly.

Our forward line misses him.
 
So Cooks legacy down the drain, next up is Graham Wright he'll be in his office in the foetal position within a year wondering what the **** he has got himself into.

Voss must go, but I think if Jesus Christ himself coached us, he wouldn't be able to fix us.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I said I wouldn’t be shocked if Harry retires. We’ve seen plenty of players do it.

And from past history how we’ve dealt with problem players, Elijah may not be done as a footballer but in recent times we’re more inclined to let them go.
In recent times?

I’d give Elijah a chance to redeem himself - god knows we need his link up & ball use.

I/we have no idea what’s going on in Harry’s life. Discussing his retirement from football is deliberate grandstanding.

Unless you know something we all don’t?
 
Josh Daicos had 31 @ 74% and 4 score involvements
Acres 30 @ 56% and 2 si
Doc 27 @ 63% and 2 si

So there are some measures that say our wings didn't outplay theirs.
And then there are critical moments which impact momentum & deflate the team also……
Doc & Acres had plenty of moments as did many others.
 
Kane Cornes & David King on SEN this morning mentioned we are too tall, and its hard to argue against this.

Being 'not proud' or disappointed means SFA when he still has no answers as to why the 3rd quarter happened...again.. Our issue is not personal, its an inability to react when the opposition take away our strengths.. Voss and the coaches set the game up well hence our first half leads, but during the game when the oppo coach reacts we are a deer in headlights with no ability to counter.
Wait till Pitto is fit again.
 
He kicked CLUTCH goals in tight games constantly.
What?
Like that clutch running into an open goal to finish off the Crows? Oh wait.
What about the clutch 20 meter chip to Saad all by himself to seal the Melbourne game and make the finals for the first time in a decade?

Owies kicked some goals, but he was not a clutch player.
Stunk it up in our first 2 finals too, which is why he got dropped for the prelim.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Weren't Sydney losing a few years ago while trying to embed a new game plan? Then all of a sudden it clicked.

I think we can see what they are trying to do. There was a concerted effort to lower the eyes today. The problem is that it only takes a weak link for it to fall down.

It's going to look ugly until it doesn't.

Dunno, I thought there were signs that were promising. Yes the problems exist but are not insurmountable.

On SM-F946B using BigFooty.com mobile app
I mean, there was some effort to lower the eyes. I don't know if that's a gameplan, or just a given in football.

I was probably most disheartened by last night of all four...even Rd1. Composure, effort and execution were all miles off for mine.
 
I mean, there was some effort to lower the eyes. I don't know if that's a gameplan, or just a given in football.

I was probably most disheartened by last night of all four...even Rd1. Composure, effort and execution were all miles off for mine.
Yeah agree

We took the ball off the centre line and lowered the eyes going inside 50

Until we didn’t, and we dumped it on the head of:

Kemp, whose strength is as a lead up forward

Young, whose strength is as a lead up forward

Moir, whose strength is as a lead up forward or a crumbing forward

And we just flat out refused to target our two time Coleman medalist in the second half

Also, if you’re going to play three marking talls they can’t be coming across eachother
 
He pulled out of at least 3 contests, one that cost us a goal in the 3rd quarter when they made their move. Even had the gall to tell Ollie off for not being closer to Schultz even though Doc was in a far better position to impact the contest. He cannot stick a tackle at all. He is playing very selfish football. He is certainly no orphan as a few others, McGovern and Williams most notably, have been as bad if not worse. IMO we need to move past all 3 asap. Unfortunately that won’t happen until the end of the year because we don’t have any ready made replacements and injuries (once again) are taking their toll. It’s hard to see any of those blokes being dropped for the next game especially after Cowan did his hammy.
dropping the three of them would be a good start....
 
Surely this game should indicate to the MC that our game plan is not suited to the current game and change is needed.

Wet weather where contested footy is king and we were still beaten in clearances, let alone general play.

The Hawthorn/Adelaide run/spread to make the ground seem big with the ball (there's been some footage that show how these teams spread with the ball and most of the work is done by players without the ball running into 'dead' space to draw opposition and then cut into dangerous space if their opponents zone off) then apply pressure with quick, agile players without the ball and use a team defence mentality is now the blueprint.

IMO, our game plan and tactics are just old and not the blueprint for success in the current era of footy.
 
Surely this game should indicate to the MC that our game plan is not suited to the current game and change is needed.

Wet weather where contested footy is king and we were still beaten in clearances, let alone general play.

The Hawthorn/Adelaide run/spread to make the ground seem big with the ball (there's been some footage that show how these teams spread with the ball and most of the work is done by players without the ball running into 'dead' space to draw opposition and then cut into dangerous space if their opponents zone off) then apply pressure with quick, agile players without the ball and use a team defence mentality is now the blueprint.

IMO, our game plan and tactics are just old and not the blueprint for success in the current era of footy.
Spot on!
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I mean, there was some effort to lower the eyes. I don't know if that's a gameplan, or just a given in football.

I was probably most disheartened by last night of all four...even Rd1. Composure, effort and execution were all miles off for mine.
I have noticed there is a concerted effort to look for the right option entering forward 50 and not just blaze away.

Problem is we are trying to pin point to a player and the margin for error is infantisimal, our set up for the forwards is so bad we can never get good separation.
 
What?
Like that clutch running into an open goal to finish off the Crows? Oh wait.
What about the clutch 20 meter chip to Saad all by himself to seal the Melbourne game and make the finals for the first time in a decade?

Owies kicked some goals, but he was not a clutch player.
Stunk it up in our first 2 finals too, which is why he got dropped for the prelim.
You're wrong - he kicked clutch set shots repeatedly.
 
I have noticed there is a concerted effort to look for the right option entering forward 50 and not just blaze away.

Problem is we are trying to pin point to a player and the margin for error is infantisimal, our set up for the forwards is so bad we can never get good separation.

Like that time Charlie had TDK in about 40m of space and somehow missed him by 5m?

Nah, we're still crap even when the target gets free.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy 2025 Rd 4 Blues to petition AFL to halve the length of games

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top