MVP Votes v Geelong - Round 4, 2025

[FootyGuy13]

Melbourne Demons Twitter gave up on showing highlights after the first minute.

Please give out 12 votes to all of the best players in this game in your opinion in any fashion you like. Maximum 12. Minimum 8. You can award a negative set (won't be counted) in addition to a positive set if you want to vent. You have 3 days to vote.

A11dAtP0w3R, booshboy, Charlie_s123, Daemon, Dancing Potato, danster168, Demon Attack, Dory_77, Headless, jhong, Lord Nev, mrmonkey, PerfectFooty, @Scythe94, stEdy, @Toump

 

[Lampers]

Urgghh

6 May
3 Trac
2 Pickett
1 Bowey

If Fritsch had finished his shots at goal and been cleaner with his general disposal he could’ve had a decent game. But he didn’t.

 

[Dancing Potato]

Really hard to find 12 votes in that uninspiring slog. So I won't, here's 8.

5 Trac
1 May
1 TMac
1 Pickett

 

[PerfectFooty]

6 Tmac
2 Chin
2 May
2 Trac

 

[Scythe]

5 - May
3 - Petracca
2 - McDonald
1 - Pickett (rusty, but still makes things happen)
1 - Sparrow (had five possessions, yet finally impacted a game by tagging Holmes out of it)

 

[Daemon]

Ok here goes.

Trac - 5
Langford - 3
Chin - 2
TMac 1
May - 1

Edit: sorry Langdon and Spargo (happy 100 games, hope you enjoyed warming the bench). I totally forgot Chin and needed to add him.

 

[booshboy]

can't do it sorry.

 

[Lord Nev]

Are people giving Trac votes for being best arm waver on the ground?

 

[Charlie_s123]

Can't give the full points. Will give:

T-Mac - 6

 

[PerfectFooty]

Are people giving Trac votes for being best arm waver on the ground?

Might have something to do with him being a third of our goals tonight

 

[Lampers]

Are people giving Trac votes for being best arm waver on the ground?

I didn’t like Trac’s attitude out there, but he kicked a third of the goals and gave off a couple that should’ve been goal assists. So pretty effective as a forward/mid all things considered.

 

[Lord Nev]

Might have something to do with him being a third of our goals tonight

I like how you make it sound like a big number.

 

[Lord Nev]

I didn’t like Trac’s attitude out there, but he kicked a third of the goals and gave off a couple that should’ve been goal assists. So pretty effective as a forward/mid all things considered.

Had 1 tackle for the game. His defensive efforts were non-existent.

 

[PerfectFooty]

I like how you make it sound like a big number.

with the way we score it is. I'm actually trying to make out how small of a number it is

I didn't want to give votes to May either for his brain fade wrestle while the ball was in play, but he played well enough.

At this point i don't even know who or what i want to vote for

 

[Daemon]

Negative votes:

Goody -1,000,000,000,000,000
Petty - 10
Oliver - 7.87
Salem - just go away, the points don't matter
Viney - love ya, feign a career ending injury and enjoy your golden contact
JVR - 1 (it's not you, it's me)

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Arguing about who did and didnt deserve votes after another spanking

 

[Scythe]

Yeah, shit on each other in the GBF thread instead. Vote the way you like

 

[Lord Nev]

9 - May
2 - Chandler
1 - McDonald

 

[Lampers]

Arguing about who did and didnt deserve votes after another spanking

Maybe if we think about it as the least worst players, instead of the best players it will be easier?

 

[Scythe]

Maybe if we think about it as the least worst players, instead of the best players it will be easier?

I like it. Everybody starts on -12, least terrible player wins

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

8 TMac
4 Chandler

 

[markm106]

5 May
4 Tmac
1 Chandler
1 Pickett
1 Sparrow

 

[Grimey Sylvia]

Pretty grim...

Tmac - 3
May - 2
Chin - 2
Trac - 2
Koz - 1
Sparrow - 1
Fritsch - 1

Feels a bit like giving out 'participation' ribbons but that's where we are at...

 

[DemonJim]

2 - May
2 - Tmac
2 - Chandler
2 - Pickett
1 - Trac

-186 - Soft free kicks killing any sort of momentum we were getting

 

[Toump Ass]

I asked chatgpt to divvy up 12 random votes, apologies for the environmental damage I did.

• TMAC: 5 votes
• TRACC: 2 votes
• CHIN: 5 votes

Seems reasonable enough!