Strategy Changes: Round 9 Fremantle vs. Collingwood

[Lach72]

Perhaps it’s time to move Reid midfield?

We need first hands and creative movement…

 

[#1JohnHuttonFan]

It's actually crazy. All our depth is injured.

Voss possibly could come in. Not sure how though, we already seem too tall.

Voss should 100% come in and he better. At least he has some agro and mongrel too him. Apart from him and Treacy the rest are just a bunch of fake tough guys. I’m sick of this sh*t club. Pissweak.
In Voss McDonald Brodie
Out Young Draper Johnson

 

[freocuz]

Perhaps it’s time to move Reid midfield?

We need first hands and creative movement…

It was pretty funny when he handballed straight into Darcy's face last night. By that stage in the match I was looking for anything to keep me from busting up my TV.

 

[Footskill]

Perhaps it’s time to move Reid midfield?

We need first hands and creative movement…

Think we need big bodied mid that can create space or shovel...Bolton rotates there as a creative mid already..adding another slight mid won't solve the issue

 

[apuchar]

Fyfe came to the rescue more than we realized I think. For all his perceived weaknesses, he was often brought on to stop the bleeding when our usual midfield was getting monstered. To think we didn't at least try to go like for like when he wasn't available this season is a little staggering.

 

[Footskill]

Fyfe came to the rescue more than we realized I think. For all his perceived weaknesses, he was often brought on to stop the bleeding when our usual midfield was getting monstered. To think we didn't at least try to go like for like when he wasn't available this season is a little staggering.

Who would be like for like we have..Brodie?

Biggest knock on Brodie is his def two way ..is Fyfe just as bad or better..although don't know is the bull Fyfe is

 

[JunglistPosse]

Out : Vanilla
In : Kinder surprise

 

[G Mus]

Serong needs to be put on notice, he’s quickly becoming a short Tom Rockliff

11

Tom Rockliff

Age

36

Ht

185cm

Wt

85kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

23.9

5star

K

13.2

5star

HB

10.7

5star

M

3.5

4star

T

4.7

5star

CL

4.7

5star

D

20.5

5star

K

10.7

4star

HB

9.8

5star

M

2.5

3star

T

5.3

5star

CL

3.0

4star

D

15.8

4star

K

9.0

4star

HB

6.8

5star

M

3.0

3star

T

3.4

5star

CL

2.8

5star

 

[academicbowl]

Brodie isn't going to solve anything. He'll be walking stoppage to stoppage, no defensive accountability. Can't be carrying that
Out: Young, Switta, Draper
Wagner moves back to provide rebound, Erasmus takes his role.
Jackson takes Youngs role, Voss up fwd.
Anyone who can run comes in for Switta, he looks cooked
Johnson and Fredrick on notice but there's really no one putting pressure on their spot

 

[E Shed]

I’d like to see Voss, O’Mac, Ras & Brodie.

Anyone calling out Serong I just don’t get it. He’s leading the AFL or top 10 in so many stats & he’s absolutely key to our game & tries his guts out. Other teams know it & he’s getting monstered by taggers.

The real question is why do we refuse to try something different to cope with it? Get nasty with blocking & scragging his taggers?

 

[FreoRicci]

For me, I would make quite a few changes after Friday night. The club cannot accept that result "as business as usual" and the way a footy team demonstrates that is by swinging the axe. So its time for the lumberjack.

I would make six unforced changes. Won't happen ... especially the last three. But a hard club would.

Out:
Young
Will be a big loss.

Draper, Johnson
I am not "blaming" these guys for the loss or calling them spuds. But both have been ordinary for several weeks now and as young players could do with a spell. Sometimes the correct way of handling poor form is gut up and work through it. But sometimes the best way forward is to step back and reset. A couple of weeks away from the pressure of playing in a dogshit team might do both the world of good.

Switta
You have to earn it and at the moment, Switta isn't. Playing someone who doesn't earn it is corrosive to the team's culture. Go back and find form, kick goals, do goals assists, get a run through the midfield. And then come back into the seniors in form.

Darcy, Serong, Bolton
What happened on Friday night was unacceptable. And these three did not fire a shot. Not effing one. For Darcy and Serong that is the second time in three weeks. As leaders, as highly paid talent, you just have to be better. You have to find a way to contribute. Bolton comes into the club on a big paycheck, costing a lot of draft picks, as a marque player. You can't walk around the park (literally walk at various times on Friday) getting frustrated and then late in the fourth spud up a routine shot at goal. If you want to be the marque player, if you want the biog paycheck, you have to be more responsible ... you aren't here to be a highlight reel you are here to be a serious footballer, a leader. And if you don't want to be a leader, don't accept the marque paycheck.

None of these three will be dropped. But at least one should be. And I would drop all three. I'd let the team know we aren't offering up that rubbish again ... and that everyone is accountable.

Said at the time that Switta has played a half of football in 6 months, and coming straight's in based on reputation is entitlement.

Surprise surprise he has absolutely sucked.
Meanwhile we’re telling players such as Erasmus, Brodie, Simpson, Banfield to earn their spots. Such poor messaging.

 

[FreoRicci]

Will be watching East Perth Peel. And that midfield would still boss around Brayshaw, Serong and MJ.
It’s absolutely pathetic that is what this club has come to.

 

[FreoRicci]

Who would be like for like we have..Brodie?

Biggest knock on Brodie is his def two way ..is Fyfe just as bad or better..although don't know is the bull Fyfe is

Jackson.

So ****ing obvious.

Why didn’t we try Treacy in the ruck? No mongrel at all.

Even Jackson, Treacy and Reid would be a better midfield then the crap of Serong, Brayshaw and MJ put up last night

 

[Lach72]

Jackson.

So ****ing obvious.

Why didn’t we try Treacy in the ruck? No mongrel at all.

Even Jackson, Treacy and Reid would be a better midfield then the crap of Serong, Brayshaw and MJ put up last night

I wa s thinking half way through the third that maybe we should actually try Treacy as a mid…I was getting that desperate t see something change

 

[Footskill]

Jackson.

So ****ing obvious.

Why didn’t we try Treacy in the ruck? No mongrel at all.

Even Jackson, Treacy and Reid would be a better midfield then the crap of Serong, Brayshaw and MJ put up last night

Jackson was playing mid in last quarter..think he had mpact initially first clearance but not thereafter I I recall

 

[FreoRicci]

Jackson was playing mid in last quarter..think he had not of impact initially first clearance but not thereafter I I recall

Should persist with it. If Serong struggles with a tag, someone big and keen for the ball like Jackson would make the opposition think twice. There’s no tall midfielder to help.

Voss has to come in. Miss someone that doesn’t mind getting in hard. 100% would put him small forward ahead of Switkowsi.

 

[noise36]

Deck chairs on the titanic at this point season is cooked.

Feel like one of Voss or OMac need to come back in and Switta needs a run in the twos

Midfield needs help at clearances, not sure where it comes from, is there some magnets that could be moved around? Jackson as a midfielder?

 

[Alfonz]

Have not banged on about my pet peeve for a while, but we have gone back to a critical mass of too many small players. Serong, Bolton, Brayshaw, Wagner, Switta, Narkle, Reid, Dudley, Freddy. That's 9 players at under 6 foot (I include Brayshaw cause he is clearly much shorter than his listed height). It's one thing if they are all guns, but when you are carrying average players who are small, you are better off replacing them with equally average players with more size (e.g. Erasmus).

Sometimes it can work when the opposition also has a bunch of smalls ... Adelaide played 8 in this category. Or maybe you just have a good day. But it is not sustainable. It's no wonder we can fall to pieces when such a large percentage of the side can be physically dominated. Hearing JL bang on and on about "the contest" for years is such mind numbing stuff when he often has selected a side that is not actually built to win the contest.

The Pies will roll out 5 players at 183cm and under, or 7 if you include Daicos and Sidebottom who are listed at 184cm. They balance this with more players in the 185-195cm range, and with great positional flexibility as well. Most of these types are good runners as well. This is where they beat up on most teams by always having a presence of big bodied mid/flankers around the ball and contest. They are going to physically destroy us around the ground unless there are big changes.

We've now lost Young, which makes us even weaker in this area. And our injury list doesn't help.

We really have no option but to keep Johnson in the side and bring in Erasmus. But we still haven't gone anywhere to rectifying the size issue. The likes of Banfield and Brodie need to be considered. Yuck.

Send Wagner back to defence and then we can rebalance and look at moving Chapman and/or Worner into more mid centric roles. Try something out of the box like Draper on a wing. Bring in Voss as a KPF and make Jackson play as a mid.

My changes:
Out: Young, Switta, Narkle
In: Erasmus, Banfield, Voss
Switch: Wagner to defence, Chapman to mid, Jackson predominantly midfield

 

[south beach]

I’d like to see Voss, O’Mac, Ras & Brodie.

Anyone calling out Serong I just don’t get it. He’s leading the AFL or top 10 in so many stats & he’s absolutely key to our game & tries his guts out. Other teams know it & he’s getting monstered by taggers.

The real question is why do we refuse to try something different to cope with it? Get nasty with blocking & scragging his taggers?

Spot on. Umps need to be questioned by the coach get a fine don’t care. He was manhandled all night literally held off the ball and they ignored it. Imagine Cripps getting that treatment. Team mates just let it happen too should have fuken smashed the tagger don’t care if you get rubbed out show some spine look after your mates.

 

[FreoRicci]

Have not banged on about my pet peeve for a while, but we have gone back to a critical mass of too many small players. Serong, Bolton, Brayshaw, Wagner, Switta, Narkle, Reid, Dudley, Freddy. That's 9 players at under 6 foot (I include Brayshaw cause he is clearly much shorter than his listed height). It's one thing if they are all guns, but when you are carrying average players who are small, you are better off replacing them with equally average players with more size (e.g. Erasmus).

Sometimes it can work when the opposition also has a bunch of smalls ... Adelaide played 8 in this category. Or maybe you just have a good day. But it is not sustainable. It's no wonder we can fall to pieces when such a large percentage of the side can be physically dominated. Hearing JL bang on and on about "the contest" for years is such mind numbing stuff when he often has selected a side that is not actually built to win the contest.

The Pies will roll out 5 players at 183cm and under, or 7 if you include Daicos and Sidebottom who are listed at 184cm. They balance this with more players in the 185-195cm range, and with great positional flexibility as well. Most of these types are good runners as well. This is where they beat up on most teams by always having a presence of big bodied mid/flankers around the ball and contest. They are going to physically destroy us around the ground unless there are big changes.

We've now lost Young, which makes us even weaker in this area. And our injury list doesn't help.

We really have no option but to keep Johnson in the side and bring in Erasmus. But we still haven't gone anywhere to rectifying the size issue. The likes of Banfield and Brodie need to be considered. Yuck.

Send Wagner back to defence and then we can rebalance and look at moving Chapman and/or Worner into more mid centric roles. Try something out of the box like Draper on a wing. Bring in Voss as a KPF and make Jackson play as a mid.

My changes:
Out: Young, Switta, Narkle
In: Erasmus, Banfield, Voss
Switch: Wagner to defence, Chapman to mid, Jackson predominantly midfield

If you’re small, have to have qualities to overcome the height difference.
Switkowski is easily beaten for speed and agility by a Milera-Wanganeen who is 187cm. It’s embarrassing. He had 3 tackles last night. Dudley had 8, Wagner 16!:

Dudley and Reid should be the only ones at that height due to their game ability and creativeness.

Daicos brothers are freaks. Fast, creative, agile and strong. Sidebottom runs all day. None of our smalls have all those qualities.

Could put a Sam Collins on Switta and still he would be faster and agile. Taller players these days are playing small, medium or tall players dependance on structure.

 

[FreoRicci]

I wa s thinking half way through the third that maybe we should actually try Treacy as a mid…I was getting that desperate t see something change

He was struggling v Wilkie. Get him inside and bash around.

 

[Quazar2]

IN: Beveridge and Bontempelli (secret trapdoor golden handshake style-biznizz..)

OUT: Long-bore (dressed up as pre-2016 Alastair "Crowley" Clarkson and Bailey Banfield

41

Bailey Banfield

Age

28

Ht

190cm

Wt

88kg

Pos.

D/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

13.6

3star

K

7.2

3star

HB

6.5

4star

M

2.9

3star

T

3.9

5star

MG

175.5

3star

D

9.5

2star

K

5.3

2star

HB

4.3

3star

M

2.0

2star

T

2.8

4star

MG

109.5

2star

D

14.4

4star

K

7.6

3star

HB

6.8

5star

M

3.8

4star

T

3.2

5star

MG

200.4

4star

(dressed up as Harley Reid).

Let's see if the Bulldogs notice

 

[Feathercap]

I’d like to see Voss, O’Mac, Ras & Brodie.

Anyone calling out Serong I just don’t get it. He’s leading the AFL or top 10 in so many stats & he’s absolutely key to our game & tries his guts out. Other teams know it & he’s getting monstered by taggers.

The real question is why do we refuse to try something different to cope with it? Get nasty with blocking & scragging his taggers?

This should be Johnson’s job but he has not footy IQ or has been poorly coached.

 

[StingBitten]

Out: Cox, Young
In: Mc'Donald, Erasmus

 

[Feathercap]

Rather than specific changes I will go with a theme.

Freos midfield is bog average once the big three fall away.

Young hammie and serong and snea tagged and that’s the game - we don’t have shit running through there after than. Johnson is a liability.

Driz injured, O’Meara injured (and average), fyfe cooked, Brodie on the outer for unclear reason, and JLo has botched Erasmus’ development.

The wings are equally bad if not worse. Sharp is Ok but a poor kick (call a spade a spade)

So what are we doing about this critical vulnerability? We don’t have many options but we can start trying to build a roster and depth in mid.

For the rest of the year I wound like to see:

- Erasmus plays every game with significant minutes inside. If he’s shit then so be it - at least we know.

- Jackson plays at least a few games exclusively as a midfielder - I mean he does not play ruck at all. Omac or Voss can cover second ruck. Let’s have a look at what he can do for Christ sakes!

- Driz when back straight in and gets minutes inside and also attacking wing (50/50)

- Reid comes into the rotation, particularly CBA as that’s where he can be really damaging with creative hands. He can also get wing minutes.