Remove this Banner Ad

QAFL 2025

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

thunderdoc said:
Why is Luca Winton 6 points at Morningside, Leahy and Templeton 6 at Aspley, Simpson 6 at PBC and Wilson 6 at Maroochydore
Click to expand...
All these guys received 2 point penalty on top as they moved to club in same league. All except Templeton were 4 pointers due to be QAFL as last league plus 2 goals on top for point penalty. Believe Templeton was 5 pointers due to being classed as VFL player then became 7 with 2 point penalty after moving back to Aspley from Noosa, would be 6 now after losing point due to years of service I’d imagine.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Footyboy2020 said:
All these guys received 2 point penalty on top as they moved to club in same league. All except Templeton were 4 pointers due to be QAFL as last league plus 2 goals on top for point penalty. Believe Templeton was 5 pointers due to being classed as VFL player then became 7 with 2 point penalty after moving back to Aspley from Noosa, would be 6 now after losing point due to years of service I’d imagine.
Click to expand...
Emphasises what a joke points system really is. Played for Grange in 2023 and has played for 4 clubs in 2 years. So you can leave a QAFL club, play 1 game elsewhere and then play at another QAFL club at only be 4 points
 
thunderdoc said:
Why is Luca Winton 6 points at Morningside, Leahy and Templeton 6 at Aspley, Simpson 6 at PBC and Wilson 6 at Maroochydore
Click to expand...

Because they went directly from one QAFL club to another, the rules are pretty simple.

Still Me said:
So no loading for 3 clubs in 3 years?
Click to expand...

3 clubs in 2 years is the rule, and also specifies SEQ

thunderdoc said:
Emphasises what a joke points system really is. Played for Grange in 2023 and has played for 4 clubs in 2 years. So you can leave a QAFL club, play 1 game elsewhere and then play at another QAFL club at only be 4 points
Click to expand...

Not really. the entire point of it is to stop the wealthy clubs who cheat the cap from poaching the best players from the clubs playing by the rules. The salary cap is not really enforced, so the points system is in play.

Eagles left Grange in mid 2023, played in Victoria and then played in Cairns for a full season. He wasn't poached or recruited directly out of Grange, so the penalty does not apply and nor should it.

You cannot just play 1 game elsewhere and get around the rule, you would need to play a full season elsewhere to get around the rules - which is a big sacrifice to reduce your points value.

if any club upset at their players high rating, they can just pretend to get them VFL listed anyway as we have seen.
 
Miller1971 said:
Because they went directly from one QAFL club to another, the rules are pretty simple.



3 clubs in 2 years is the rule, and also specifies SEQ



Not really. the entire point of it is to stop the wealthy clubs who cheat the cap from poaching the best players from the clubs playing by the rules. The salary cap is not really enforced, so the points system is in play.

Eagles left Grange in mid 2023, played in Victoria and then played in Cairns for a full season. He wasn't poached or recruited directly out of Grange, so the penalty does not apply and nor should it.

You cannot just play 1 game elsewhere and get around the rule, you would need to play a full season elsewhere to get around the rules - which is a big sacrifice to reduce your points value.

if any club upset at their players high rating, they can just pretend to get them VFL listed anyway as we have seen.
Click to expand...
Besides Simpson to PBC this year from Labrador what other quality player “poaching” direct within QAFL has actually occurred in the past decade?
 
Freeman & Tempo to Aspley

Leahy & McDonald to Aspley

Smith & Carbone to Redland

Chapman to Redland

Winton to Morningside

Milford to Morningside

Waters to Morningside (had a year lower level in-between thus avoided the 2 point penalty)

Greenaway to Morningside

Baker to Wilston Grange (somehow avoided the penalty)

Wilson to Maroochydore

Cameron & O'Sullivan to Redland (avoided penalty due to VFL alignment status)

Aston to Redland and back to Morningside (VFL alignment saves penalty)

Buzza to Morningside (VFL loophole)
 
Maroochy
Palmy
Redlands
Aspley
Surfers
Morningside

Almost went with Noosa, got a gut feel but I went with that all last year and came last… so will go with head
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Miller1971 said:
Freeman & Tempo to Aspley

Leahy & McDonald to Aspley

Smith & Carbone to Redland

Chapman to Redland

Winton to Morningside

Milford to Morningside

Waters to Morningside (had a year lower level in-between thus avoided the 2 point penalty)

Greenaway to Morningside

Baker to Wilston Grange (somehow avoided the penalty)

Wilson to Maroochydore

Cameron & O'Sullivan to Redland (avoided penalty due to VFL alignment status)

Aston to Redland and back to Morningside (VFL alignment saves penalty)

Buzza to Morningside (VFL loophole)
Click to expand...
Good list - well done.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Big news out of Redlands, Matt hammerman out due to concussion protocol, apparently Tyler Hausfeld and hammer had a biff at training Thursday night and Tyler has sent him into concussion protocols. Noosa by 25+
 
seargent squirt said:
Big news out of Redlands, Matt hammerman out due to concussion protocol, apparently Tyler Hausfeld and hammer had a biff at training Thursday night and Tyler has sent him into concussion protocols. Noosa by 25+
Click to expand...
Is this true, who’s your source??? Always thought Tyler was a bit of a w***er, should’ve seen his late hit against a Sherwood player last week, minimum 3….
 

Remove this Banner Ad

QAFL 2025

Similar threads

Toucan Soup
QAFL 2025 - Tradition V Trivia
2 3
Replies
55
Views
5K
Toucan Soup
Toucan Soup
G
QAFL 2024 season
99 100 101 102 103
Replies
3K
Views
231K
Backpocket101
B

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top