Remove this Banner Ad

MVP Votes v St Kilda - Round 12, 2025

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

We now go back to your regular programming.

Please give out 12 votes to all of the best players in this game in your opinion in any fashion you like. Maximum 12. Minimum 8. You can award a negative set (won't be counted) in addition to a positive set if you want to vent. You have 3 days to vote.

A11dAtP0w3R, Daemon, Dancing Potato, Demon Attack, Dory_77, Headless, jhong, LNev, PerfectFooty, Scythe, stEdy, Charlie_s123, danster168, Grimey Sylvia, omit, space_cowboy, Toump, booshboy, Lampers, markm106, DemonJim, DemonZombie_001, wingersclub
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Only 2 guys that deserved votes for me.
8 Gawn
4 Turner

-1 Petracca (the best of the worst. 2 good goals. 1 horrific miss. And only 1 tackle for an inside mid is a disgrace. Sloppy skills and handballs that never hit a target).
-8 Oliver (just blasting it long. Didn't even try to lower his eyes)
-8 Lindsay (3 behinds)
-9 Sharp (turnover handball resulting in goal. And missed a basic snap from 25m)
-9 Langford (maybe hitting rookie fatigue)
-9 Melksham (2 basic misses)
-9 Windsor (his comparisons with Jayden Hunt were unfair on Jayden)
-10 May (Got given a bath by a child when the game was in the balance)
-10 Lever (Speaks for himself)
-10 Bowey (pathetic from start to finish)
-10 Trent Rivers (we get it, you can kick it long. At the expense of sharing the ball around and getting a better i50)
-10 Pickett (Massive liability. Lazy, tone setting brain fade).

-50 Goodwin (Paid no respect to Sinclair and NWM who racked up at will and played Pickett for too long in the midfield. Also a retrospective vote for not working on goal kicking at pre-season. Mark Williams also at fault here.
 
Only 2 guys that deserved votes for me.
8 Gawn
4 Turner

-1 Petracca (the best of the worst. 2 good goals. 1 horrific miss. And only 1 tackle for an inside mid is a disgrace. Sloppy skills and handballs that never hit a target).
-8 Oliver (just blasting it long. Didn't even try to lower his eyes)
-8 Lindsay (3 behinds)
-9 Sharp (turnover handball resulting in goal. And missed a basic snap from 25m)
-9 Langford (maybe hitting rookie fatigue)
-9 Melksham (2 basic misses)
-9 Windsor (his comparisons with Jayden Hunt were unfair on Jayden)
-10 May (Got given a bath by a child when the game was in the balance)
-10 Lever (Speaks for himself)
-10 Bowey (pathetic from start to finish)
-10 Trent Rivers (we get it, you can kick it long. At the expense of sharing the ball around and getting a better i50)
-10 Pickett (Massive liability. Lazy, tone setting brain fade).

-50 Goodwin (Paid no respect to Sinclair and NWM who racked up at will and played Pickett for too long in the midfield. Also a retrospective vote for not working on goal kicking at pre-season. Mark Williams also at fault here.
I don't take exception to your votes but I do take exception to your assertion that Oliver didn't lower his eyes. I remember him doing it at least twice, which was two times more than any of his other mates during the game.
 
I don't take exception to your votes but I do take exception to your assertion that Oliver didn't lower his eyes. I remember him doing it at least twice, which was two times more than any of his other mates during the game.
it was just a couple of occasions that stuck out late to me. Like he burnt Lindsay and lindsay turned around with a 'wth?'. Rivers was probably worse.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Remove this Banner Ad

MVP Votes v St Kilda - Round 12, 2025

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top