Remove this Banner Ad

Werewolf BEaston Basic* WW Part V - Vampires Win!

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Not sure I understand why MWPP can be accused of going so hard but the rookie gets defensive, has a bit of a melt and apparently proves to almost everybody on the board, they're evil.

I don't know whether JHF is lying or not but I do remember being a rookie and melting more than once when I was being lynched as a simple villager, so I'm not prepared to say a bit of a melt is proof of much.

We could test it though I suppose.
I don't think you've played many games with me but people who have would remember all those times I fought all day before being lynched as a villager. Plus, Tarks was lying about missing on me anyway. Not voting for JHF relies on believing MC and believing he hasn't been recruited/was always a DS. Also, nobody has played many games with JHF. He has had a great run by surviving so late in both of his first games though. He has been known to melt on other boards though..
 
Actually, DemurePrincess is a good shout. She's never this quiet!

Let's start there.

Thanks BEaston.
Interesting choice of the 3. BFew's post about the pages makes me go back to him (he was an early vote of mine yesterday, and this time, there's no being busy on a Tuesday excuse). Is DP always active in WW though like she is in the SFA? I thought not for some reason.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Well for one if JHF flips head vamp you're likely compromised. If he doesn't then you're likely in the clear.
Yeah, MC isn't likely in the clear no matter how JHF flips. That response to porps question was in itself dodgy. So, protected someone for entertainment and then claims/puts himself out in the open despite not being close to leading the lynch?

Mwerps really metagaming.
How so?
 
Yeah, MC isn't likely in the clear no matter how JHF flips. That response to porps question was in itself dodgy. So, protected someone for entertainment and then claims/puts himself out in the open despite not being close to leading the lynch?


How so?
I want to stop replying to you for a bit but why on gods green earth would he go in to bat for JHF if he wasn't the doc and was able to not die from a targeted kill night 1?
 
Yeah, MC isn't likely in the clear no matter how JHF flips. That response to porps question was in itself dodgy. So, protected someone for entertainment and then claims/puts himself out in the open despite not being close to leading the lynch?


How so?
You can say that until you're blue in the face, but I actually AM in the clear regardless of what JHF flips as.
 
I want to stop replying to you for a bit but why on gods green earth would he go in to bat for JHF if he wasn't the doc and was able to not die from a targeted kill night 1?
That's exactly why I think he isn't the doc- there's no reason for the good doc to go and bat for an unknown in JHF. A useful town role sure. MC had the perfect disguise of pretending to be NI - so evil may have left him alone if they hadn't picked up on his soft doc claim and left him for a lynch on the other day. Also, the choice of target and the reason followed by the claim is unbelievable even from him.
 
You can say that until you're blue in the face, but I actually AM in the clear regardless of what JHF flips as.
You're only in the clear when you die. That goes for everyone in this game really (even the flogs). You cannot be verified and your supposed actions make even less sense than Tarks' did.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Why though?
Because he was posting sweatier than a sinner in church. Waited today to see what would transpire from the missed kills and obviously you claimed doc, he's still suspicious so it's a fairly straight forward thing IMO. I don't believe they're a drifting soul/villager etc. they have just seemed off compared to last game and more so since being announced as a miss hit.

There's a lot of back and forth which goes around in circles, but sometimes this game is a lot more simple than that and I think the smokescreens people create we have to look around.
 
Let me just add it wasn't a diss but the numerous references to old games, posting habits of others on different boards, referring to streaks of yours a few times. Just a lot of data that is being pulled from outside the game that's currently on. From memory and this is a few years ago when we were both playing regularly, that is something you usually do when innocent and desperate to get that point across. I do struggle to think village when you're this prolific in your posting is my only issue. It's just so intense, again, not a diss.
 
Let me just add it wasn't a diss but the numerous references to old games, posting habits of others on different boards, referring to streaks of yours a few times. Just a lot of data that is being pulled from outside the game that's currently on. From memory and this is a few years ago when we were both playing regularly, that is something you usually do when innocent and desperate to get that point across. I do struggle to think village when you're this prolific in your posting is my only issue. It's just so intense, again, not a diss.
You're right about the first part- I do all of those things (not to mention, the focus on mechanics of this game which I've also done all game) as town. I don't bother as evil.

And I've never been this outright #1 prolific as evil/neutral in terms of the gap between myself and the second most active person. I've done it plenty of times trying to defend myself though. So your last point about this prolific/this intense doesn't match up with that.
 
You're right about the first part- I do all of those things (not to mention, the focus on mechanics of this game which I've also done all game) as town. I don't bother as evil.

And I've never been this outright #1 prolific as evil/neutral in terms of the gap between myself and the second most active person. I've done it plenty of times trying to defend myself though. So your last point about this prolific/this intense doesn't match up with that.
Matches up for me mwerps. We've got different perspectives. It's the intensity. You've been prolific but more reasonable or diplomatic for lack of a better word. Today has just felt like you've been looking for anything to shift the spotlight. It's felt less focussed than usual and more urgent. Tarks didn't help with his claim and whatnot and I'm leaning not evil on you, it's just been a confusing day regarding trying to read you.
 
Matches up for me mwerps. We've got different perspectives. It's the intensity. You've been prolific but more reasonable or diplomatic for lack of a better word. Today has just felt like you've been looking for anything to shift the spotlight. It's felt less focussed than usual and more urgent. Tarks didn't help with his claim and whatnot and I'm leaning not evil on you, it's just been a confusing day regarding trying to read you.
It's my second game back. I didn't actually get many accusations in my first game back when I was the Vig so there was no need to defend myself (and then evil outed me anyway). These days I only sign up if I have the time and don't bother if I won't/don't. The impact is real. I wasn't playing like this yesterday when I had multiple votes on me (the closest I came was to tag people closer to deadline if people didn't change to Gralin, which I maintain is fair enough given the lack of reactions/response to Chip's post by that point despite multiple responses/reactions to post thereafter). I was otherwise much more cool about it . I do stand up when things don't add up and I feel I'm either being framed or someone has made a mistake. Turns out he was outright lying anyway.
 
MC Bad Genius - the other I was looking at was Cadsky. A weird stray vote from Gralin. And Cadsky is openly doing disengaged in this game anyway - in contrast to your game when he was the doc and worked well with other townies (including the ones without roles).
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

You're only in the clear when you die. That goes for everyone in this game really (even the flogs). You cannot be verified and your supposed actions make even less sense than Tarks' did.
No, that's not actually how it works. I'm not in the clear in your opinion, but actually, I'm the Doctor (and an unrecruited one at that) no matter what anyone else thinks.
 
No, that's not actually how it works. I'm not in the clear in your opinion, but actually, I'm the Doctor (and an unrecruited one at that) no matter what anyone else thinks.
I was referring to recruitment - even if you are the doc you are not in the clear
 
Because he was posting sweatier than a sinner in church. Waited today to see what would transpire from the missed kills and obviously you claimed doc, he's still suspicious so it's a fairly straight forward thing IMO. I don't believe they're a drifting soul/villager etc. they have just seemed off compared to last game and more so since being announced as a miss hit.

There's a lot of back and forth which goes around in circles, but sometimes this game is a lot more simple than that and I think the smokescreens people create we have to look around.
I'm going off how he played in the last game. Was similarly melty about being painted as the possible Serial Killer. Once I saw that WAbulldog actually had missed a kill on him, I wanted to see how he would respond. And it was the same response.

So I'm pretty sure he is as claimed.
 
I'm going off how he played in the last game. Was similarly melty about being painted as the possible Serial Killer. Once I saw that WAbulldog actually had missed a kill on him, I wanted to see how he would respond. And it was the same response.

So I'm pretty sure he is as claimed.
I felt he was a lot more measured last game, playing the oblivious card (which he turned out to be). He was quick to reply to any doubts more this game defensively, which is what stood out to me here.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Werewolf BEaston Basic* WW Part V - Vampires Win!

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top