List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[gringo2011]

Hall does it pretty well, Henry also should be doing it if not injured.

Both more mobile high half forwards than crumbers.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Do people really not want to pay Windy $800k?

Like if thats the line between stay or go youd rather let him go for a second rounder than just pony up the $800k?

I don't think anyone would rather he go for a 2nd rounder.

The discussion was regarding one of the Doper's top 10 picks (as extremely unlikely as that is).

 

[gringo2011]

Interestingly, a few Essendon posters saying they would part with the Melbourne FRP for Windy.

They are saying that pick would be around p10 in the live draft with everything factored in.

I think we’ll regret it and Lyon doesn’t get let off for trashing the list. He has to perform or go.

 

[St Neil]

Honestly it looks fairly even to me.

Port get the best player in that group, we get the next best (based on potential) so we get a pick. West Coast get the third best so two extra picks.

If anyone gets ripped off its the eagles really (and thats not a massive rip off).

It doesn’t look right.

PA have turned Georgiades into NWM?

 

[Diehard Saint]

A lot of people know, they are just very very good keeping it in house.

Surely the best kept secret since....well, ever!

 

[gringo2011]

Id much rather keep him personally but thats a decent return.

Shit draft. We won’t get anything much back and will be a five year apprenticeship before we get a proper return. We need to go now. We can’t keep pushing improvement out. We’ll be paying more to replace him next year.

 

[owen78]

Information suggests there is a world in which Windhager and NAS go together to SA.
As i mentioned over 10 days ago, NAS's teammates are of the opinion if he goes back home, the crows are his likely destination. Jon Ralph then confirmed this in mainstream media recently.

Port however, desperate to bring Windhager to Alberton, which would help their case to get NAS over the line.

 

[StFly]

That's how we tried to use Max... We just didn't have Rowell, Anderson, Touk, Flanders and Co winning the contest and kicking it forward... he was leading to Seb Ross

Bit harsh.

Seb was in all thirds of the ground helping his mates to be buggered by the end it, better instance was he had Gresh and a 40% chance to be catching dirt instead of a ball.

 

[phantom13]

Both more mobile high half forwards than crumbers.

Who is a half forward crumber? Thats a forward pocket which is Butler/Collard

 

[botts]

A lot of people know, they are just very very good keeping it in house.

Well it’s making people go a little crazy. If you can’t tell

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Information suggests there is a world in which Windhager and NAS go together to SA.
As i mentioned over 10 days ago, NAS's teammates are of the opinion if he goes back home, the crows are his likely destination. Jon Ralph then confirmed this in mainstream media recently.

Port however, desperate to bring Windhager to Alberton, which would help their case to get NAS over the line.

They better pony up Butters and the mad rooter if they want both of them.

 

[gringo2011]

Paying a role player 850k is also a gamble imo

He’s probably worth around $800 with some improvement factored in. It’s paying $1.7 for a long contract to a player we don’t need that is more of an issue.

 

[akaifu]

Information suggests there is a world in which Windhager and NAS go together to SA.
As i mentioned over 10 days ago, NAS's teammates are of the opinion if he goes back home, the crows are his likely destination. Jon Ralph then confirmed this in mainstream media recently.

Port however, desperate to bring Windhager to Alberton, which would help their case to get NAS over the line.

Good luck to them trying to satisfy us in a trade far out

Butters + Bergman might actually have to happen

 

[BrutThough]

Port dont need another mid like Windy.

Hard to find that believable on their end or from Windy's end.

 

[Captain Paddy]

Do people really not want to pay Windy $800k?

Like if thats the line between stay or go youd rather let him go for a second rounder than just pony up the $800k?

It's insane lol

We probably paid Zak Jones that much to come acorss 5 years ago. Hill was on like $900 odd.

Windy's a dawg

 

[beside the seaside]

A lot of people know, they are just very very good keeping it in house.

 

[botts]

Information suggests there is a world in which Windhager and NAS go together to SA.
As i mentioned over 10 days ago, NAS's teammates are of the opinion if he goes back home, the crows are his likely destination. Jon Ralph then confirmed this in mainstream media recently.

Port however, desperate to bring Windhager to Alberton, which would help their case to get NAS over the line.

Where did you hear this

 

[Captain Paddy]

Lyon’s very structured game plan doesn’t allow freedom and creativity. Membrey got back to what he’s always been once he got out. Butler is a front runner and needs to break free. If he’s staying close to his opponent he’s not finding space.

Membrey's been pretty shit tbh

 

[botts]

Information suggests there is a world in which Windhager and NAS go together to SA.
As i mentioned over 10 days ago, NAS's teammates are of the opinion if he goes back home, the crows are his likely destination. Jon Ralph then confirmed this in mainstream media recently.

Port however, desperate to bring Windhager to Alberton, which would help their case to get NAS over the line.

So nas at 2 mill plus and windy at 850. Good luck the the list management team

 

[Captain Paddy]

Information suggests there is a world in which Windhager and NAS go together to SA.
As i mentioned over 10 days ago, NAS's teammates are of the opinion if he goes back home, the crows are his likely destination. Jon Ralph then confirmed this in mainstream media recently.

Port however, desperate to bring Windhager to Alberton, which would help their case to get NAS over the line.

With what picks champ

 

[beside the seaside]

There is so much BS that obviously gets spread by managers. Windy is negotiating a deal, his management have obviously said oh yeah XYZ teams are into him hoping that it pressures us to stump up more cash. Many contracts are worked out after the season, there is no way Windy leaves

 

[dudeintheswamp]

Has anyone ever seen Tony74 and owen78 in a room at the same time?

 

[St Neil]

Surely the best kept secret since....well, ever!

A few people in the media over the past few days are now bobbing up declaring their “gut feel” is that NWM will re-sign at St Kilda.

Out of nowhere.

That it is a sign that the dynamics have recently changed.

If it’s true it has to be announced very soon because the dam wall will burst.

 

[Dr Spaceman]

A lot of people know, they are just very very good keeping it in house.

 

[akaifu]

Do people really not want to pay Windy $800k?

Like if thats the line between stay or go youd rather let him go for a second rounder than just pony up the $800k?

It'd be helpful to compare to Josh Daicos' contract - feel like he is a better and more proven version of Windy

Signed in 2023 to 2030

AA 2023, BF winner, premiership player

If Windy deserves 850k, then Daicos is probably on 1m+ which I'm not sure about