List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[stavro#4]

4 years for Windy is about as un-risky as a four year deal can get. Has to be the salary.

He isn’t turning down 200-300k a season for 4 years, is he

 

[Hubnester]

I feel like it would be a huge fumble to let Windy go at this stage. Hopefully just some posturing and negotiating from his management before a deal is done, he's too valuable to lose.

 

[Saints43]

Unfortunately he may get squeezed out. It could come back to bite us.

I think he's already been told and will be heading back to Tassie.

 

[phantom13]

I have seen Dean play and you have just repeated what I went on to say. We will trade that pick out just like every team does if they have a father-son or NGA prospect at the top end of the draft.

Id let it go mate, literally no one cares about your F/S and picks

 

[phantom13]

I hope were not actually into both Aleer and JSOS. Structurally both take already occupied positions in defence (even if were talking about Tauru going forward) and i cant see either being a substantial upgrade in a defensive system on what weve got.

One or the other can help, both feels like a massive reach.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Id let it go mate, literally no one cares about your F/S and picks

We literally give zero Fs about Carlton's draft strategy for 2025...o wait, SOS has just entered the chat

 

[stavro#4]

I hope were not actually into both Aleer and JSOS. Structurally both take already occupied positions in defence (even if were talking about Tauru going forward) and i cant see either being a substantial upgrade in a defensive system on what weve got.

One or the other can help, both feels like a massive reach.

Maybe we are taking “control the air” literally and playing jumbo sized line ups.

TDK ruck. Dodson ruck rover. Marshall rover.

King ff. Owens FP. Sharman HFF. Pou HFF. Heath CHF.

Howard fb. Wilkie BP. Tauru HBF. Aleer CHB. JSOS. BP.

Etc etc.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Maybe we are taking “control the air” literally and playing jumbo sized line ups.

TDK ruck. Dodson ruck rover. Marshall rover.

King ff. Owens FP. Sharman HFF. Pou HFF. Heath CHF.

Howard fb. Wilkie BP. Tauru HBF. Aleer CHB. JSOS. BP.

Etc etc.

"Look closer, Cornesy"

 

[Sully111]

Prove you're right!

He's right about one thing mate. Nobody here has shown any proof that Max's contract has games triggers. It may well have... but asking to see proof isn't over the top.

Things are getting ridiculously cliquey around here. Anyone questions anything by the club or doesn't take for gospel something said by the rose coloured glasses brigade and they get jumped on straight away.

It's getting like a bunch of 12 year old girls.

 

[Saints43]

He's right about one thing mate. Nobody here has shown any proof that Max's contract has games triggers. It may well have... but asking to see proof isn't over the top.

Things are getting ridiculously cliquey around here. Anyone questions anything by the club or doesn't take for gospel something said by the rose coloured glasses brigade and they get jumped on straight away.

It's getting like a bunch of 12 year old girls.

I think Ross said Max signed for "unders". You'd have to be asking questions of Max's management if he signed for unders and had termination clauses inserted as well.

 

[bird_man]

Tom Morris on SEN this morning:

Marcus Windhager (St Kilda)
North Melbourne showing interest

“Windhager wants to stay,” Morris said on SEN Breakfast.

“St Kilda’s offer is not yet four years, but if it gets to four years today he would sign today.

“He just needs that security.”

Kane Cornes said: “He’s a must have, you need these players. Good performer and consistent. An age demographic that suits the Saints but never going to be an A-grader.

“What do you pay him? This is what St Kilda are clearly weighing up. We can’t overpay for a player who has limitations in his game.”

Morris added: “St Kilda and Lyon has a philosophy, you have your stars that you pay, future stars you pay to keep and then you’ve got your soldiers.

“This is about tenure. North has offered five years for Windhager. They want someone in that age bracket – a bit older than Harry Sheezel. North need the older guys, they have the younger guys.

“They need to bring someone in to get better.”

Really strange we don't already have a four year deal in front of him.

 

[stavro#4]

"Look closer, Cornesy"

View attachment 2407571

Carlton: Sos, let’s have sex.

SOS: argh!, No Carlton

SOS: flushes a bid in for Dean on draft night.

 

[chris_h_11]

Geez there is gonna be some tough exit interviews in the next day or two if we have TDK, Jsos, Ryan, Aleer already tapped up, with our 1st round pick and Fincher waiting in the wings.

 

[PJays]

Is it time to make player contracts public?

Agree but maybe only the top 10 at each club- or something like that.

 

[CaptainRisky]

4 years for Windy is about as un-risky as a four year deal can get. Has to be the salary.

Leave me out of this ,

 

[SainterinSydney]

Leave me out of this ,

Any inside scoop, El Capitano?

 

[Remboy]

Surely this JSOS thing is BS.

Where do we apparently fit all these players in the side?

Aren't we losing 25 players in the exodus?

 

[stavro#4]

Aren't we losing 25 players in the exodus?

Oh no, Wilkie is off!

 

[SainterinSydney]

Oh no, Wilkie is off!

Off getting more players to sign up for the Saints.

 

[jwikked]

Prove you're right!

I’m not the one making baseless claims lol.

 

[phantom13]

Maybe we are taking “control the air” literally and playing jumbo sized line ups.

TDK ruck. Dodson ruck rover. Marshall rover.

King ff. Owens FP. Sharman HFF. Pou HFF. Heath CHF.

Howard fb. Wilkie BP. Tauru HBF. Aleer CHB. JSOS. BP.

Etc etc.

Thatll go swimmingly against the good ball use sides.

 

[saintbill]

Just catching up, is there any validity to JSOS?

Would be wrapped if we can snag him, foot skills are awesome.

How do we afford everyone?

 

[Yawkey way]

Unfortunately he may get squeezed out. It could come back to bite us.

That’s crazy and what you get taking on a guy like Aleer.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

Surely this JSOS thing is BS.

Where do we apparently fit all these players in the side?

I think of the few older fellas might be getting a bit more of a run in the reserves.

 

[Remboy]

He isn’t turning down 200-300k a season for 4 years, is he

Depends how he sees North going the next few years. Although to be fair after five years in the bottom two they finally broke into the top 16 this year.