List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[aidansbonor]

Hot take maybe but If true I like this way more than Ryan and Aleer

 

[St Neil]

If we want JSOS we won’t have both Caminiti and Aleer in the backline. One or the other.

Presumably we withdraw from Aleer and save the draft capital.

 

[Yawkey way]

I hope so.

Never been sold on Mackenzie, I know he was in our academy and Hawthorn used pick 7 on him but I just don’t see it.

It always comes back to if you’re good enough you play and he just can’t seem to cement a spot in the hawks midfield.

 

[gringo2011]

Agree 100% with this. Shattered if we lost windy, but absolutely fine letting Rowan go. He’s been a great servant, but if he wanted to go to the Cats, good luck to him. I’m also huge on TDK though - genuinely think he will be a superstar of the competition next year.

TDK can play but we have set him up to be under extraordinary pressure.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Starting to feel like this kind of off season again

View attachment 2408318

I’ve got year 2000 vibes to be honest.

Sitting in an internet cafe in Coogee, waiting for the Olympics to start & reading that we’d signed Hamill…. Then Gehrig…. Then Lawrence & Voss.

With Roo & Kosi a few months away.

 

[stfan]

And who is The Orange Team?

 

[True Believer]

So
TDK
Aleer
JSOS
Ryan
then frdp ( maybe two if we say ta ta to Roh)
Fincher
Get King, Howard, Henry, Pou fit.
2026, the year of hope.
What ever happened to Rucci's exodus from just two weeks ago?

I asked that exact question of the bed-wetting nancy boys earlier in the thread !!

Oddly, I have had no response!

 

[gringo2011]

I’ve got year 2000 vibes to be honest.

Sitting in an internet cafe in Coogee, waiting for the Olympics to start & reading that we’d signed Hamill…. Then Gehrig…. Then Lawrence & Voss.

With Roo & Kosi a few months away.

That's a better model. We have at least built up the youth first this time.

 

[SainterinSydney]

I’ve got year 2000 vibes to be honest.

Sitting in an internet cafe in Coogee, waiting for the Olympics to start & reading that we’d signed Hamill…. Then Gehrig…. Then Lawrence & Voss.

With Roo & Kosi a few months away.

You just unlocked a memory! I remember being at Olympics as well talking to my dad about how we would be a juggernaut.

 

[Hayes4PM]

I would piss myself laughing if we got JSOS. Just to see Carlton fans squeal and go and graffiti their own club again. A bunch of Carlton assistants axed or "exploring their options elsewhere", 2 out of contract free agents giving them the "yeah it's gonna be a no from me dawg" treatment, multiple other players rumoured to be looking elsewhere. I don't wish ill on too many clubs, but Carlton (and particularly their fan base) can go and get absolutely rooted.


Ohhhhhhh it would be delicious to see JSOS come on a contract worth three fifths of **** all and Carlton get a 4th round pick or better yet no compensation...

But at the end of the day, all I want to see is Carlton shit their pants and bottom out, and us continue to build.

 

[stfan]

They are different types of players, but Windy is way better than Cam.

No point trading out Windy to effectively get Cam.

 

[tassiesaint2024]

TDK can play but we have set him up to be under extraordinary pressure.

True, guess we just hope he handles it.

I watched quite a few blues games in the first half of the season and he was a one man band. Just had a huge presence about him - which IMO is something you can’t teach.

 

[Remboy]

we are just taking the piss now its hilarious

It’s a reverse exodus.

 

[gringo2011]

I asked that exact question of the bed-wetting nancy boys earlier in the thread !!

Oddly, I have had no response!

Well if Windy, Marshall and Steele go we are still getting an exodus, we are just getting players back. Also none of us made it up. It was reported and commented on. What are you boorish chest beating oafs wanting?

 

[stfan]

I’ve got year 2000 vibes to be honest.

Sitting in an internet cafe in Coogee, waiting for the Olympics to start & reading that we’d signed Hamill…. Then Gehrig…. Then Lawrence & Voss.

With Roo & Kosi a few months away.

That vibe will shatter somewhat if Cam Mackenzie turns out to be our mystery mid.

 

[hayes]

Butler the odd man out maybe? Surely you can’t carry him, Higgins, Ryan, Collard? Plus Said if he’s still contracted?

Small forwards are like midfielders these days, you can’t have too many good ones.

 

[Remboy]

Might just be easier to name the players we aren't getting at this point.

We would, but there aren’t any

 

[jwikked]

I'd be happy to walk away from the Ryan deal, just doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

Wonder if Liam Henry would want to go back to WA?

 

[Jade Buddha]

Presumably we withdraw from Aleer and save the draft capital.

Don’t think that will happen

 

[stfan]

Again, Wilkie has been awesome for us, but his numbers just don't stack up to the absolute top end this season.

Wilkie has often had to play as a negating defender this season.

Next season with more tall defensive options (Howard fit and JSOS or Aller) Wilkie will be able to play as Wilkie again, and that will make us a better team.

 

[jwikked]

Don’t think that will happen

Just hope we don’t get rid of our first round pick. Take that to the draft, trade the rest for all I care

 

[phantom13]

I asked that exact question of the bed-wetting nancy boys earlier in the thread !!

Oddly, I have had no response!

You want posters to reply to a question you apparently asked about the rucci report? Do you think one of our posters is Rucci?

 

[botts]

Ahahahha we have lost the plot. I do like this though

 

[True Believer]

I would piss myself laughing if we got JSOS. Just to see Carlton fans squeal and go and graffiti their own club again. A bunch of Carlton assistants axed or "exploring their options elsewhere", 2 out of contract free agents giving them the "yeah it's gonna be a no from me dawg" treatment, multiple other players rumoured to be looking elsewhere. I don't wish ill on too many clubs, but Carlton (and particularly their fan base) can go and get absolutely rooted.


Ohhhhhhh it would be delicious to see JSOS come on a contract worth three fifths of **** all and Carlton get a 4th round pick or better yet no compensation...

But at the end of the day, all I want to see is Carlton shit their pants and bottom out, and us continue to build.

This post made my day, absolute pisser!

This sums up seeing the karma bus trundling past on its way to Ikon Park, and standing and applauding.......

Saints fans have long memories you Bloo scum.......

 

[gringo2011]

Life is never boring as a Saints supporter heading into the off season!!!


This one'll be a beauty

This is our time to shine. We never play finals but we always win the off season.