List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[True Believer]

You want posters to reply to a question you apparently asked about the rucci report? Do you think one of our posters is Rucci?

No, but the bed-wetting prophets of doom were parroting Rucci like gospel. All squealing about our impending player exodus!

 

[bennymc7]

I'd trade our first for McKenzie... He's 21 (I think), and will be better than what's available at our slot..

 

[True Believer]

Well if Windy, Marshall and Steele go we are still getting an exodus, we are just getting players back. Also none of us made it up. It was reported and commented on. What are you boorish chest beating oafs wanting?

If..........

 

[Joffaboy]

TDK can play but we have set him up to be under extraordinary pressure.

Most of that taken away when NAZ signed. NAZ under more pressure to perform if we are just going on $$$

 

[Diehard Saint]

Just hope we don’t get rid of our first round pick. Take that to the draft, trade the rest for all I care

Very much doubt we’re trading our first this year.
Don’t even like trading future firsts. Look at Blues and Dees this year without one. Blues “lucked out” with a compo for TDK.

 

[Remboy]

Cannot judge King’s output with one of the worst midfield in the AFL. Have said this many times, even if we had prime time Ablett, Lockett and Dunstan, they are not going to kick a lot of goals from long bombs to a crowded defence and slow/safe play.

Dunstan wouldn’t be kicking goals if you hit him on the chest in the goal square.

 

[akaifu]

Surely Cal Twomey drops a bomb on Footy Classified just to top the night off

 

[SainterinSydney]

Port Patriot is back in the TDK general thread!!

 

[Tommy Wigs]

So an established version of collard? Almost the perfect mentor for a young talented indigenous kid from WA.

Yes, I’ve been wondering if it’s bringing in a stable mate. Which one is Sinclair and which one is Billings?

 

[Remboy]

Surely Cal Twomey drops a bomb on Footy Classified just to top the night off

We’re getting Cripps!

 

[akaifu]

Port Patriot is back in the TDK general thread!!

Are we offering him 800k too?

 

[Hayes4PM]

I'd trade our first for McKenzie... He's 21 (I think), and will be better than what's available at our slot..

I'd want some change coming back.

 

[stfan]

Ahahahha we have lost the plot. I do like this though

C'mon, no one would offer Cam a 4 year contract.

 

[moirae42]

I'd trade our first for McKenzie... He's 21 (I think), and will be better than what's available at our slot..

No, split the pick for a couple of seconds. Then trade one of those.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

I'd want some change coming back.

Is he any good? Can’t say I’ve seen him play. I don’t recall any real meltdowns in here though when the hawks took him off us.

 

[Leap of Faith]

Charlie Curnows best Coleman medal season:

4.8 scores per game.

Aged 26.

Not a great deal better than max at 22.

Yes I see that. But that comparison is comparing Curnow to what Max was, not what he is. He's basically done sfa for 3 years and has the makings of being an injury bust. Really hope I'm wrong.

 

[gringo2011]

I'd trade our first for McKenzie... He's 21 (I think), and will be better than what's available at our slot..

It's got potential, he looks a bit vanilla but this is a pretty average draft.

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Surely Cal Twomey drops a bomb on Footy Classified just to top the night off

Jono Marsh is back

 

[stfan]

I'd trade our first for McKenzie... He's 21 (I think), and will be better than what's available at our slot..

Question is more. is he good enough to be starting Best 22?

Personally, I think not.



The Orange Team I will disbelieve, unless I see a more credible source.

 

[11men1cup]

Surely Cal Twomey drops a bomb on Footy Classified just to top the night off

Hearing we are entering the Sam Draper race

 

[Joffaboy]

Well if Windy, Marshall and Steele go we are still getting an exodus, we are just getting players back. Also none of us made it up. It was reported and commented on. What are you boorish chest beating oafs wanting?

Why do you always need to insult when caught out? The exodus was reported by Rucci on Dickwad and the Nuffie SEN show, a couple of tweets using Rucci as the source and you lot went crazy, all henny penny.
Lyon came out and poured complete cold water on it calling them nuffies and no rigour and saying Wilkie had rung him and said the report was bs.
It was then reported the Saints had told the senior players what was happening and had given them bonuses.
All this came out and there was complete radio silence from some who had been most vocal.
In saying that, that was then and this is now.
If all the rumours were true Ryan,Aleer and Mackenzie would all cost capital. With our draft hand some people like Steele or Roh could get traded.

We can't afford to lose Windy, can't pull at the fabric of the young group, especially with a plethora of new recruits.

 

[bennymc7]

I'd want some change coming back.

Potentially a few swaps or something... I reckon he's a gun

 

[stavro#4]

Yes I see that. But that comparison is comparing Curnow to what Max was, not what he is. He's basically done sfa for 3 years and has the makings of being an injury bust. Really hope I'm wrong.

He was very good in his return in 23.

Was close to averaging 2 goals a game in 24 until he tore his PCL. He was 19 goals 10 behinds from 11 games if we don’t count the power game. He was fine.

Yes he has missed sometime. But he has put on considerable size and was dominant during pre season match sim

 

[bennymc7]

Any updates on Windy?

 

[gringo2011]

If..........

Hopefully not but we were on a knife's edge with Nas. Sounds like he was still unsure right up until he signed. It was a proper sliding door moment for the club. So much hinged on his decision and even for attracting our pool of overpriced talent probably needed his signature.

Good for you if you didn't give a shit and weren't nervous. We can't all be tough alpha types like you.