Opinion The I Was Wrong thread- Where Tom Atkins posts go to die

[geelong_crazy26]

Having a much improved season but A grade utility is a bit over the top. He is a small defensive half player. Still comfortably behind guthrie, stewart and humphries. But may have surpassed bews, duncan and kolo in those roles. Although i personally would like bews to get more opportunities.

Sure you can argue i am being hyperbolic and carried away but its undeniable he is having a career best season and is playing good football. I would call him a utility as he can play multi positions.

Over the past 5 games he has averaged 20.5 disposals a game, and is providing a bit of dash and carry for us.

He is having an impact on our recent success, which also happens to be 5 wins in a row

 

[cats_09]

Sam Darcy looked pretty good with the ball below his knees on Thursday night - guess that makes him a 208cm small.

Conway has always looked good below the knees when he's been out on the park

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Sam Darcy looked pretty good with the ball below his knees on Thursday night - guess that makes him a 208cm small.

More your medium type i guess

 

[OzeSparky]

Conway has always looked good below the knees when he's been out on the park

Been so long I've forgotten.

 

[cats_09]

 

[dazbroncos]

I expect some posts in here these next few days....

GO Catters

 

[Pure_Ownage]

42 pressure acts in a final. Wow.

 

[Seeds]

I expect some posts in here these next few days....

GO Catters

Going to kick things off then?

 

[CatToTheFuture]

I expect 10 votes for him the Gary Ayres medal this week, no less

 

[CatToTheFuture]

42 pressure acts in a final. Wow.

He needs to have pulled that performance out in a granny, Norm Smith effort

 

[Seeds]

I was wrong about this team being premiership worthy ... wait no i wasnt being saying it since mid this year. Geelong 2025 is better then geelong 2022.

Didnt think stanley could play to the same level as in the past. I was wrong about that.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

I was wrong about this team being premiership worthy ... wait no i wasnt being saying it since mid this year. Geelong 2025 is better then geelong 2022.

Didnt think stanley could play to the same level as in the past. I was wrong about that.

I dont think we are better than 2022 but the comp is weaker than 2022..we are definitely good enough to win it.
Stanley might be playing his last game in the GF but hes been super this year.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

I was wrong about this team being premiership worthy ... wait no i wasnt being saying it since mid this year. Geelong 2025 is better then geelong 2022.

Didnt think stanley could play to the same level as in the past. I was wrong about that.

You in the wing thread there mate, this is the contrition thread not the gloating thread.

I hope to post here soon though because from January to basically now I've not believed we were winning it.

The lid is wobbling

 

[Cataholic]

Going to kick things off then?

Daz has praised Axe over the journey, so he's already on the record.

Given this thread is about Axe, and you're here, what say you??

 

[catempire]

I was wrong about this team being premiership worthy ... wait no i wasnt being saying it since mid this year. Geelong 2025 is better then geelong 2022.

Didnt think stanley could play to the same level as in the past. I was wrong about that.

B L I C A V S

 

[Lana]

I didn't think we'd trade more than a first rounder for Marshall

 

[Seeds]

Daz has praised Axe over the journey, so he's already on the record.

Given this thread is about Axe, and you're here, what say you??

Im pretty much bang on about him. Was a very ordinary player in his first 4 seasons but to his credit has improved to the point he is now an average midfielder. Elite defensively but poor offensively.

 

[Lana]

I thought our rebuild on the run hit the wall after the Brisbane loss in round 3

 

[Seeds]

B L I C A V S

S T E W A R T.

 

[Cataholic]

Im pretty much bang on about him. Was a very ordinary player in his first 4 seasons but has improved to the point he is now an average midfielder. Elite defensively but poor offensively.

The coach and all his team mates are applauding him, but you're raining on him.

Right.

The guy brings the spirit, the determination, the 'never say die' attitude to our team but he's average??

Yeah, nah.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

I didn't think we'd trade more than a first rounder for Marshall

Wrong thread but that will happen.

 

[Lana]

Wrong thread but that will happen.

Just getting in early

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Just getting in early

Its alright the extra pick in the 40s we will give them will go on someone who will get delisted in 3 years.

 

[catters_28]

I said it in the autopsy but I was wrong about Mullin.

Never been happier to eat my words

 

[CatToTheFuture]

I absolutely did not think we had the midfield to overcome a side that bats as deep through there as Brisbane.

I guess there's a lesson here in that, just because it looks different to what you like to see, doesn't mean it's wrong