List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[TradeDraft]

Buller In and Miocheck Out

 

[gouki88]

You’d think the official AFL account would at least get his name right

 

[sr36]

I see him as an inside midfielder, he is a competent forward but he’s no Elliott.

Schultz best footy by a mile last year was in Elliott's role.

 

[Jen2310]

You’d think the official AFL account would at least get his name right

tbf, I used to get brody and Brodie mixed up with checkers and Grundy haha

 

[TradeDraft]

 

[No SPIN]

Schultz best footy by a mile last year was in Elliott's role.

I really have no idea how you came to that conclusion - unless my definition of Elliot's role is different to yours.
My definition - has him as a Unicorn who can play tall with Spectacular marks or outstanding as a small.
I love shooter but he cant play tall like Elliot - I wish he could.

 

[sr36]

I really have no idea how you came to that conclusion - unless my definition of Elliot's role is different to yours.
My definition - has him as a Unicorn who can play tall with Spectacular marks or outstanding as a small.
I love shooter but he cant play tall like Elliot - I wish he could.

There was about a month long patch when our forwards were injured - Schultz played as a deep forward who presented at the footy. It was his best month of footy last year.

 

[TradeDraft]

 

[gouki88]

I really have no idea how you came to that conclusion - unless my definition of Elliot's role is different to yours.
My definition - has him as a Unicorn who can play tall with Spectacular marks or outstanding as a small.
I love shooter but he cant play tall like Elliot - I wish he could.

Probably all those times Fly mentioned Schultz playing as a tall forward

 

[stormskye]

WHy ArE wE OnLY geTtiNG sOMe sPUD FrOm SyD aND BrIs, gEEl and HaWKs arE gETtiNG sTaRS

 

[sr36]

WHy ArE wE OnLY geTtiNG sOMe sPUD FrOm SyD aND BrIs, gEEl and HaWKs arE gETtiNG sTaRS

We could have had Quinlan, FFS.

 

[HFF]

Mihocek is leaving I reckon.
33 next season.
And he is knocking back 2 yr deals effectively.

It is what it is.

We need to eventually transition into some younger players.

We still have McStay but also guys like West will need to get some mins.

 

[WanderingDude]

WHy ArE wE OnLY geTtiNG sOMe sPUD FrOm SyD aND BrIs, gEEl and HaWKs arE gETtiNG sTaRS

Spud goes well with big fish.

 

[Doc1763]

We could have had Quinlan, FFS.

dont get me started!!!!

 

[Couch Coach]

There's no cash here Jy. Here there's no cash, alright? Cash no

 

[cfc19902010]

Not sure Mt Buller is a spud from what I’ve seen

 

[nickyds35]

View attachment 2428673

There's no cash here Jy. Here there's no cash, alright? Cash no

Surely this is a salary dump situation?

Don't watch North much, but in one of the few games I saw, he was absolutely horrendous, missing 3-4 simple handballs/kicks in a short space of time.

 

[BillyElliott]

Surely this is a salary dump situation?

Don't watch North much, but in one of the few games I saw, he was absolutely horrendous, missing 3-4 simple handballs/kicks in a short space of time.

North supporters don't speak about him in glowing terms. Majority seem happy to see the back of him.

That's a red flag.

 

[TradeDraft]

Not sure Mt Buller is a spud from what I’ve seen

Have not seen enough to make a Good Prediction

Though sounds like he a Real Solid 2nd Half of the Season at AFL Level

 

[cfc19902010]

Have not seen enough to make a Good Prediction

Though sounds like he a Real Solid 2nd Half of the Season at AFL Level

He’s a big boy
Had a few nice games
Worth a punt on
Maybe lower 2 nd rounder

 

[Jen2310]

He’s a big boy
Had a few nice games
Worth a punt on
Maybe lower 2 nd rounder

2nd rounder? lol he's played 10 games as a MSD player.
3rd or 4th rounder.

 

[WanderingDude]

On Buller the idea of mobile young talls appeals. The issue will be developing them all and good exposure in the VFL. The situation of Howes being at the club for 2 seconds and heading down back does my head in. Miles to go yet.

 

[Supercoach Bargain]

Doesn't get a lot of the ball, abt 12 kicks a game.

Doesn't tackle much, 3-4 a game

Doesn't hit the scoreboard, averaging less than 1

Apart from that, all good

 

[Johno9911]

North supporters don't speak about him in glowing terms. Majority seem happy to see the back of him.

That's a red flag.

He is a peculiar player Jy Simpkin - always feels like one of those guys that should be better than what he has dished out. Most North people I've spoken too feel like he's always performed better playing a genuine midfield role, doesn't seem to have the speed or class to strive as a HFF type where he's often been shunted out to. I feel like he could be a solid midfield option for us - nice mix of an inside/outside type, the hold up for me is the money and contract - a contract he certainly only got as North had literally no one to pay so guys like him were able to earn much more than another club would have provided

If we could get away with a deal of a "decent" pick (from our perspective) and North paying 25% of his alleged $1m a year a contract, I think he could be a serviceable piece within our aging midfield. Paying an early pick or absorbing the whole of that contract is an absolute no-no though imo

 

[Doc1763]

He is a peculiar player Jy Simpkin - always feels like one of those guys that should be better than what he has dished out. Most North people I've spoken too feel like he's always performed better playing a genuine midfield role, doesn't seem to have the speed or class to strive as a HFF type where he's often been shunted out to. I feel like he could be a solid midfield option for us - nice mix of an inside/outside type, the hold up for me is the money and contract - a contract he certainly only got as North had literally no one to pay so guys like him were able to earn much more than another club would have provided

If we could get away with a deal of a "decent" pick (from our perspective) and North paying 25% of his alleged $1m a year a contract, I think he could be a serviceable piece within our aging midfield. Paying an early pick or absorbing the whole of that contract is an absolute no-no though imo

gives me Bytel vibes