Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - Top 10 Candidates

Which 2 Players Do You Want With Our 2 Round 1 Picks?


  • Total voters
    305
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Let's really roll the dice and trade our pick 4 for Cats pick 17 and F1.

Watch the melts. Death ride Cats lol
They'll finish high due to their cheat ground and the CFL.

In terms of prio, I'd take:

Essendon's pick 9 (from Hawthorn for Merrett) + F1 (very unlikely; maybe if we added 2027 F2 but that won't be useful for matching Bewick with the changes to the F/S + Academy rules)
Gold Coast's pick 6/7 + F1
Dogs pick 11 + F1
 
They'll finish high due to their cheat ground and the CFL.

In terms of prio, I'd take:

Essendon's pick 9 (from Hawthorn for Merrett) + F1 (very unlikely; maybe if we added 2027 F2 but that won't be useful for matching Bewick with the changes to the F/S + Academy rules)
Gold Coast's pick 6/7 + F1
Dogs pick 11 + F1

Bombers will not be trading an f1.

You can virtually rule out the entire bottom 8 bar saints from trading a f1. Next years draft is way too good and the top end talent would be picked before Duursma this year.

Gc/hawks/crows are the picks we might get.
 
Bombers will not be trading an f1.

You can virtually rule out the entire bottom 8 bar saints from trading a f1. Next years draft is way too good and the top end talent would be picked before Duursma this year.

Gc/hawks/crows are the picks we might get.
Sure. The Hawks/GC picks are the most likely/probable. Hence me saying 'very unlikely' to the Essendon one
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Say goodbye to Robey then, if we do split pick 4.

Sad GIF
 
Say goodbye to Robey then, if we do split pick 4.

Splitting is only an option if we clearly come out on top. Hawks may be desperate for Merrett and want Pick 4 to satisfy. Same with Adelaide for Petracca.

Lot to play out. Blair is ahead of the game.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Same

Why the hell would we bend North over only to go back down the order & a future 1st ?

You never want to be down the bottom but when you are make the most of the high picks
If next year is a far superior draft which were hearing from those itk it makes a bit of sense. I think we as supporters hate the idea of trading into the future because we lose a horse to bet on this year but the clubs always gonna do what's best for the club.
 
If next year is a far superior draft which were hearing from those itk it makes a bit of sense. I think we as supporters hate the idea of trading into the future because we lose a horse to bet on this year but the clubs always gonna do what's best for the club.

If we can get a decent return, then all for it, but i just have my doubts that we will get a real decent pick this year if we somehow manage to get a f1. I guess the important thing is we are in a position to do so, so our options are open unlike other clubs.
 
I can't see us taking Robey if we keep picks 3 & 4. The only way we will take him is if we split our picks and take him with a pick in the teens. Hartley is too professional to make a last minute decision on a players value. All of our picks are based off years of scouting and evaluating. Sharp (&/or Cummings) is the most likely choice with three who plays a very similar role and would work well along side Smilie.
 
Splitting is only an option if we clearly come out on top. Hawks may be desperate for Merrett and want Pick 4 to satisfy. Same with Adelaide for Petracca.

Lot to play out. Blair is ahead of the game.
Can't see what Hawks could offer up that would satisfy though? They'll probably be top 4 the next couple of years. 2 x pick ~16 won't cut it, plus at least one of them would likely go to Bombers anyway.

I do like Cam Mackenzie though....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top