- Jun 15, 2020
- 2,201
- 2,993
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Off the top of my head in Melbourne playing some form of footy from within the QAFL
Triffet, Colenso, Green, McCarthy, Briskey, Franks, Johnson, Bulley, Coleman, Hude - I'm sure there are way more.
Of those, Triffet and Johnson the only ones really playing high quality VFL footy and being top liners. Colenso playing majority VFL, but also played plenty of EDFL including a few GF's. Franks at the Bullants, so who would be able to even judge his form at that rabble. Briskey, McCarthy, Bulley, Coleman, Green, Hude all playing majority local suburban leagues. Probably only Triffet, Colesno, Franks and Hude in that list has genuinely dominated QAFL footy.
Then a host of players in country leagues like Torney, Tome etc. Not sure many FIFO's anymore other than the Maroochy lads? I think Adkins and Licht did it for a while.
Is it a problem? Not sure? Are there just as many Vics and Croweaters replacing these guys in the QAFL making the net position fairly even? Maybe. IS the QAFL improving? some would argue yes, others no - its a pretty good product in my view and don't think there is an emergency situation. Probably the one thats a bit of an outlier is a bloke like Fletcher, one of the best local products there is - going to play in a shit league in Tassie for presumably a huge pay out. Probably not an ideal outcome, and perhaps playing for QLD IN Tasmania 2 of the last 3 years exposed him to someone looking for a big recruit - double edged sword that state game!
Triffet, Colenso, Green, McCarthy, Briskey, Franks, Johnson, Bulley, Coleman, Hude - I'm sure there are way more.
Of those, Triffet and Johnson the only ones really playing high quality VFL footy and being top liners. Colenso playing majority VFL, but also played plenty of EDFL including a few GF's. Franks at the Bullants, so who would be able to even judge his form at that rabble. Briskey, McCarthy, Bulley, Coleman, Green, Hude all playing majority local suburban leagues. Probably only Triffet, Colesno, Franks and Hude in that list has genuinely dominated QAFL footy.
Then a host of players in country leagues like Torney, Tome etc. Not sure many FIFO's anymore other than the Maroochy lads? I think Adkins and Licht did it for a while.
Is it a problem? Not sure? Are there just as many Vics and Croweaters replacing these guys in the QAFL making the net position fairly even? Maybe. IS the QAFL improving? some would argue yes, others no - its a pretty good product in my view and don't think there is an emergency situation. Probably the one thats a bit of an outlier is a bloke like Fletcher, one of the best local products there is - going to play in a shit league in Tassie for presumably a huge pay out. Probably not an ideal outcome, and perhaps playing for QLD IN Tasmania 2 of the last 3 years exposed him to someone looking for a big recruit - double edged sword that state game!




