Remove this Banner Ad

Fixture 2026 Fixture

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

It's starting you in the face.

Teams that get an advantage in Round 1 off the back of opening round rather than just playing a team who also did opening round.

Geelong
Carlton
Pies
Hawks
Saints
Suns

That's 5 Vic teams and a Nepo Baby, that doesn't even work in a hollywood movie but the AFL are full steam ahead.
Blues and Pies both requested not to be on Laura Kane Round so I hardly think they'll be jumping in joy about whatever advantage you think we get from it.
 
Let's look at this year and look at their finishing positions:

Sydney (10th) lost to Brisbane (Premiers)
Hawthorn (Prelim) beat Essendon (15th)
GWS (Elim) beat Melbourne (14th)
Collingwood (Prelim) beat Port (13th)

It's almost as if the teams that won were significantly better than their opponents
You're looking at it wrong.

From the year before, Port (Prelim) should have knocked off Pies (9th). The rest went on final positions from the previous year. But Pies got an easy kill and then quickly built momentum.

It's obviously an advantage and stats are starting to line up with that. I've seen it first hand from Freo, we started horribly against the Lions in 2024 but knocked them off once we shook off the rust. No other team did though that year.

It's a compromise that doesn't have to happen even with opening round.

Great to see the geniuses at AFL house not lining byes either for the OR teams. Continuous improvement not their cup of tea.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

You're looking at it wrong.

From the year before, Port (Prelim) should have knocked off Pies (9th). The rest went on final positions from the previous year. But Pies got an easy kill and then quickly built momentum.

It's obviously an advantage and stats are starting to line up with that. I've seen it first hand from Freo, we started horribly against the Lions in 2024 but knocked them off once we shook off the rust. No other team did though that year.

It's a compromise that doesn't have to happen even with opening round.

Great to see the geniuses at AFL house not lining byes either for the opening round teams. Continuous improvement not their cup of tea.
Yes because if there wasn't that pesky cyclone Essendon would have gone on to beat Hawthorn
 
Yes because if there wasn't that pesky cyclone Essendon would have gone on to beat Hawthorn
Nah,
Hawks already played opening round.

If the 4 games went ahead and the same results occurred the record would have been 4-0 for opening round teams against non opening round in 24.

The AFL have decided to have 6 games compromised in round 1 now rather than their standard 4.
 
It was a close game tbf. Essendon challenged in the second half but blew chances.
That Hawks/Essendon game is a poster child for the advantage. Hawks got off to a 6 goal to 1 opening term and it was an arm wrestle for the rest of the game. If you remove the 1st quarter scores, Essendon win by 1 point.
 
Without playing them in Opening round, you'd still be playing the SUNS away during the year.
Which is beside the point.
The argument is that it is better to play interstate OR than have that week off. I am saying I'd rather the week off than Suns away OR
 
If Opening Round is to build interest Northern States, how does St Kilda v Collingwood at the MCG do that?

And if they can play a game in Melbourne, why can’t SA and WA play a game? How does Saints/Coll not take the attention away, but a Port/Fremantle would?
It doesn't
 

Remove this Banner Ad

If Opening Round is to build interest Northern States, how does St Kilda v Collingwood at the MCG do that?

And if they can play a game in Melbourne, why can’t SA and WA play a game? How does Saints/Coll not take the attention away, but a Port/Fremantle would?
Fremantle v Adelaide would’ve been a good one, because they could put it at 8:30pm for the east coast, only 5:30pm in Perth. Both teams played finals last year. Only think is, once you get to seven games, you need to have nine. You can’t give 14 teams an extra bye, whilst the other four have to go through without one. And yes, I get they have an extra week off at the start during OR, but a week off after playing is way different to having one off preseason.
 
Which is beside the point.
The argument is that it is better to play interstate OR than have that week off. I am saying I'd rather the week off than Suns away OR
How about playing Gold Coast away, or getting a second bye a few weeks into the season instead?

Playing Gold Coast away isn’t the punishment. Majority of teams will play them away at some point. So you play them in R0 instead of R15….

The advantage is getting to start your season early and a second bye, and getting to see your tactics in action before taking on an opponent that is still coming out of their preseason.
 
Not sure why people complain about a games crossover.

Leagues far bigger than the AFL globally (EPL, NFL, NBA) all have weekly if not daily crossovers of games. Its not a thing.

Also pies barely leaving Victoria again i see.
Pretty sure most Vic teams including Collingwood leave Vic 5 times not including gather round, Pies, without checking every Vic team are the same as Essendon, Hawthorn and Geelong in leaving Vic.
 
Interesting take.

No SA premiership for 20+ years. GWS and GCS have never won one. Sydney consistently fall over at the last hurdle (maybe its a travel thing??).

Brisbane are an outlier and arguably the best team since themselves 20+ years ago.

You don't think the Adelaide teams only winning 2 of their last 8 finals at their home ground is more of a reason for their failure to win flags than the venue for the GF that they almost never make?

Collingwood have literally never won a premiership while having an unfair home ground advantage at any stage of the finals, by the way.

Didn’t you complain about playing opening round which you’re now not involved in and your first game of the season is against a marvel tenant at your home ground?

My heart BLEEDS for the challenges faced by the magpies.

We are involved in Opening Round. And as usual, we're being used as a cash cow for other teams' benefit, not ours.

The Pies travelling 3 times in the first 16 rounds. I'm glad my mob get their first three travels done by round 5.

Last season we travelled 3 times in our first 6 games. All anyone mentioned about that was that it was an advantage to not have much travel later on in the season. This year it's flipped and everyone will suddenly think that it's an advantage to travel later on.

I predict next year our travels will be evenly spread throughout the fixture, and everyone will change their tune again and decide that even spacing is the real advantage.
 
Wtf is wrong with the afl! Instead of having 8 stand alone games during easter, they decide to play rich vs port and WC vs Syd at the same time.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Im aware of that. Understand all the ramifications around it.

Its just a completely different set of rules they get to play by.
New season, same old posts from uneducated supporters. Or maybe they just don’t read the full fixture, I don’t know.

Collingwood leave Victoria 6 times, just like Essendon, Carlton and St Kilda. Those final two team don’t leave Victoria after early to late June. Collingwood on the other hand leave Victoria 3 times after late June.

But yeah only Collingwood don’t travel.
 
Our travel has been on par with most Victorian clubs who don’t sell games.
Come on now, most people here aren’t smart enough to work that out. Or if they are they just can’t get over their hatred of Collingwood to admit it.
 
Come on now, most people here aren’t smart enough to work that out. Or if they are they just can’t get over their hatred of Collingwood to admit it.

Yep, Collingwood haters aren't the brightest bunch. They are VERY predictable in their stupidity though.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Fixture 2026 Fixture

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top