List Mgmt. Draft thread - 2025 (remaining picks: 29, 34)

[Keys]

Live draft hand
R1: 1 (Duursma), 4 (CDT), 19 (Lindsay)
R2: 29, 34
RD: 1

Draft picks pre-draft
R1: 1, 2, 13
R2: 34, 41
RD: 1

List spots available
Main list: 2 (includes Duursma, CDT, Lindsay)
Cat A Rookie list: 1 (expecting Robertson, Macrae and Schoenberg to join as SSP signings)
Cat B Rookie list: 1

Draft order

Spoiler

Draft prospect video highlights (thanks to noobermensch)

Rookie Me Central 2025 Draft Guide

2025 AFL Draft Guide

online.fliphtml5.com

Matthew Clarke on Gettable 17/11

Spoiler

Cal Twomey’s Phantom Draft

Spoiler

 

[stallon]

Arguably the most important question about this draft; Which number does Willem Duursma get, 1 or 4?

Going by how they dished out numbers last year, Starcevich and Young will get first choice at numbers.
Starcevichs 37 isnt available so he wont pick his old number.

1, 4, 5, 12, 18 are the top 20 numbers.

Hopefully they leave 2 top 10 numbers for Duursma and CDT

 

[bzparkes]

Arguably the most important question about this draft; Which number does Willem Duursma get, 1 or 4?

Bont's his favourite player, so I expect him to go for #4.

 

[Keys]

Bont's his favourite player, so I expect him to go for #4.

4WD

I like it

 

[Elite Pete]

Clarke at 9.15est

 

[RustyShacklefordFalcon]

4WD

I like it

4 Woodstock's Deep

 

[Astro7]

I've come to terms that we'll select CTD would much rather split or just go early on Sharp

But could we turn him into a KPD? Use his game sense and rebound from defence. Think modern day prime Jakovic (even tho I was just small kid, highlight of Jaco using his pace to rebound looked elite)

Wow, I was an adult, watching the Jako-Carey duels at the Waca and Subi - but let's not do a Little River band and start reminiscing again.
I'm at peace with whoever we select, unless it's a total sh*tshow.

 

[Bleedblueandgold]

4 Western Digital

 

[Eastcoasteagle]

Genuinely the shittest take I've read here all year.

Think he's got the Quinella of shit takes

 

[Tugga27]

Think he's got the Quinella of shit takes

Trifecta.

 

[Wedgetailed Westerner]

Bit of a balls up on Clarke's behalf not getting/making an effort for pick 9 (potentially). Banfield, Evans and William although very talented are only worthy of Rookie spots not seniors spot. Those latter picks should of been bundled up with 13 to move into the top 10. Not to mention the possibility the latter picks may not even be required because of our tight list spots. We've just let rebuilding clubs like Roos and the bombers get a free pass on players we require like dovaston, Farrow or even Sharp sliding. Happy to be labelled a bedwetter than be an apologist for a club that doephus dumb shit time and time again.

heck sake. How do you know we didnt try and get pick 9.

 

[RustyShacklefordFalcon]

Think he's got the Quinella of shit takes

Keys can we get an annual award? Could be a red carpet thing, like the Razzies!

 

[TheBudgies]

heck sake. How do you know we didnt try and get pick 9.

He didnt trade a 4th rounder for pick 9 so he clearly didnt even try.

 

[bzparkes]

4WD

I like it

Duggan sure to get him on the podcast ASAP.

 

[Bender_]

I've been carefully studying the form line of potential draftees by reading the comments on this thread. It seems every player in this draft, is a potential gun, and if we pick them, we should burn down the club because we are ruined, is the vibe I'm getting.

Is that about right?

And that next years draft is better.

I have been reading this pearler since the first year I joined.

 

[wceeaglesfan]

Mock Draft | Thoughts?
Trades

• Car trade pick 9 for ESS 21, 27, 30
• Car trade pick 11 for NM 25 and F2
• WCE trade pick 2 + 34 for ESS 5 and 9
• BRI trade pick 44 for ESS F4

1 WCE - WILLEM DUURSMA

2(MB) GC -ZEKE UWLAND

3 ESS - COOPER DUFF-TYTLER

4 RIC - SULLIVAN ROBEY

5(MB) BRI - DANIEL ANNABLE

6(MB) GC - DYLAN PATTERSON

7 RIC - SAM GRLJ

8 WCE - SAM CUMMING

9(MB) CAR - HARRY DEAN

10 ESS - XAVIER TAYLOR

11 MEL - JACOB FARROW

12 MEL - CAMERON NAIRN

13 WCE - LACHY DOVASTON

14 HAW - DYSON SHARP

15 NM - BLAKE THREDGOLD

16 GWS - OSKAR TAYLOR

17 WCE - HARLEY BARKER

18 WB - NOAH HIBBINS-HARGREAVES

19 ADE - MITCHELL MARSH

20 GEE - JOSH LINDSAY

21 FRE - LATRELLE PICKETT

22 HAW - JEVAN PHILLIPOU

23 NM - AIDAN SCHUBERT

24 CAR - ARCHIE LUDOWYKE

25 CAR - LOUIS EMMETT

26 SYD - LEON KICKETT

27 SYD - MAX KING

Multiple players found. Use birthday to differentiate. eg [PLAYERCARD="23/11/1962"]Joe Smith[/PLAYERCARD]

28(MB) SYD - LACHLAN CARMICHAEL

29 WB - MARCUS KRASNADAMSKIS

30 ESS - OLIVER GREEVES

31 GWS - MATTHEW LERAY

32(MB)ESS - ADAM SWEID

33(MB) GC - BEAU ADDINSALL

34(MB) CAR - JACK ISON

35(MB) WCE - TYLAH WILLIAMS

36 MEL - HUGO MIKUNDA

37 RIC - TALOR BYRNE

38 COL - RILEY ONLEY

39 GEE - HUNTER HOLMES

40 COL - HARRY SCOTT

41 NM - SAM ALLEN

42 FRE - FRED RODRIGUEZ

43 ADE - SAM SWADLING

44 PA - LIAM HETHERTON

45 (MB) COL - ZAC MCCARTHY

46(MB) SYD - HARRY KYLE

47 STK - RORY WRIGHT

48 BRI - MAX KONDOGIANNIS

49 WB - JACK DALTON

50 GC - JAI MURRAY

51 ADE - TOM BLAMIRES

 

[squashface]

And that next years draft is better.

I have been reading this pearler since the first year I joined.

Superdraft = n + 1 (where n = this years draft)

 

[PepperTom32]

People are going too heavy on the "weaknesses" of a 19yo kid. He has areas that he can develop or improve on, but that doesn't necessarily mean they are weaknesses as such.

Even if they were weaknesses, it doesn't mean that his game style can't effectively compensate.

Talking about Barnett yeah?

 

[stavro#4]

Trading 13 for a F1 if possible is definitely the play.

Given the new matching rules we should be able to use the F1 (hopefully saints) and our F2 to get into the top 7 in a stronger draft (if it isn’t already there).

The new matching rules means it’s likely to come in 2+ picks if it starts mid range anyway.

Come in peace.

But Friday Twomey was interviewed by Jake from Saints TV.

He said that Phillipou was likely sliding out to the 20s of the draft and that no club was offering a F1 to trade in this year and the costs would be significantly lower to do so. (Carlton/Essendon/North broke later).

Posting as I’ve seen a number of references here about My club trading into the first round and parting with an F1.

Evidently the player we want is Jevan. But not at a cost of a first round and would go without if that was the case.

 

[PepperTom32]

 

[Peptide Pig]

People are ignoring that we want a first rounder in 2026 as a goal of ours still.

I think pick 13 + F3rd for St Kilda F1st and F4th and us moving St Kilda F2nd to Hawks for pick 22 might be the way to go providing Williams isnt bid on

At 22 its that Rodriguez/Swadling/ like spot I suppose

The F1 play with our third pick is very valid. If we had moved up to pick 9 I reckon we could’ve had some interested parties for a slider like Sharp or Farrow. By pick 13 it looks like the draft will even out and the top talent will be gone. Not sure it would garner much interest unfortunately given next years draft is reportedly stronger. But with other pick shuffles maybe it does.

An extra F1 would be handy in a possible trade for Walter or Warner and would have the added benefit this year of keeping list spots free if bids come for all of Williams, Evans and Banfield. Not to mention we may just not rate this draft and have our eye on some kids next year.

It feels like we will keep the pick and hopefully land a decent mid option like Addinsall or Greeves.

 

[Ilkka Sinisalo]

Are you high? it's well known he doesnt/can't jump. He's a bad shot at goal and drops absolute sodas. The marking is somewhat ignored because he clunks some quite good marks to almost make up for it.

The Rowan Marshall comp isnt terrible except that Marshall is a better mark, and would pants him in ruck contests.

A bad ruckman who is 'fine' as a third tall forward but is mobile for his size. Heck yes another Bailey Williams, dream come true. Only costs pick 2???? Deal

I love the idea that a bunch of multi-million dollar football clubs and professional talent evaluators who have ranked CDT as one of the top 5 prospects in this draft have somehow missed the fact that he can’t jump, can’t kick straight and has stone hands.

 

[Godfather32]

Come in peace.

But Friday Twomey was interviewed by Jake from Saints TV.

He said that Phillipou was likely sliding out to the 20s of the draft and that no club was offering a F1 to trade in this year and the costs would be significantly lower to do so. (Carlton/Essendon/North broke later).

Posting as I’ve seen a number of references here about My club trading into the first round and parting with an F1.

Evidently the player we want is Jevan. But not at a cost of a first round and would go without if that was the case.

There's some deluded people on here who like to post trades that work for us but don't work at all for the team we'd be trading with

 

[Godfather32]

I love the idea that a bunch of multi-million dollar football clubs and professional talent evaluators who have ranked CDT as one of the top 5 prospects in this draft have somehow missed the fact that he can’t jump, can’t kick straight and has stone hands.

To be fair we don't know where a bunch of multi-million dollar football clubs rate CDT until the draft.

 

[WCEswift]

i find it humourous that we have 1 and 2 but we get 2 hybrid utilities instead of pure mids

 

[Wooshaaaa]

Mock Draft | Thoughts?
Trades

• Car trade pick 9 for ESS 21, 27, 30
• Car trade pick 11 for NM 25 and F2
• WCE trade pick 2 + 34 for ESS 5 and 9
• BRI trade pick 44 for ESS F4

1 WCE - WILLEM DUURSMA

2(MB) GC -ZEKE UWLAND

3 ESS - COOPER DUFF-TYTLER

4 RIC - SULLIVAN ROBEY

5(MB) BRI - DANIEL ANNABLE

6(MB) GC - DYLAN PATTERSON

7 RIC - SAM GRLJ

8 WCE - SAM CUMMING

9(MB) CAR - HARRY DEAN

10 ESS - XAVIER TAYLOR

11 MEL - JACOB FARROW

12 MEL - CAMERON NAIRN

13 WCE - LACHY DOVASTON

14 HAW - DYSON SHARP

15 NM - BLAKE THREDGOLD

16 GWS - OSKAR TAYLOR

17 WCE - HARLEY BARKER

18 WB - NOAH HIBBINS-HARGREAVES

19 ADE - MITCHELL MARSH

20 GEE - JOSH LINDSAY

21 FRE - LATRELLE PICKETT

22 HAW - JEVAN PHILLIPOU

23 NM - AIDAN SCHUBERT

24 CAR - ARCHIE LUDOWYKE

25 CAR - LOUIS EMMETT

26 SYD - LEON KICKETT

27 SYD - MAX KING

28(MB) SYD - LACHLAN CARMICHAEL

29 WB - MARCUS KRASNADAMSKIS

30 ESS - OLIVER GREEVES

31 GWS - MATTHEW LERAY

32(MB)ESS - ADAM SWEID

33(MB) GC - BEAU ADDINSALL

34(MB) CAR - JACK ISON

35(MB) WCE - TYLAH WILLIAMS

36 MEL - HUGO MIKUNDA

37 RIC - TALOR BYRNE

38 COL - RILEY ONLEY

39 GEE - HUNTER HOLMES

40 COL - HARRY SCOTT

41 NM - SAM ALLEN

42 FRE - FRED RODRIGUEZ

43 ADE - SAM SWADLING

44 PA - LIAM HETHERTON

45 (MB) COL - ZAC MCCARTHY

46(MB) SYD - HARRY KYLE

47 STK - RORY WRIGHT

48 BRI - MAX KONDOGIANNIS

49 WB - JACK DALTON

50 GC - JAI MURRAY

51 ADE - TOM BLAMIRES

If we ended up with
Duursma.
Cumming
Dov
Barker
Banfield
Evans
Williams.


I'd be over the moon. Although I'd suspect it wouldnt be cumming, but sharp.