Remove this Banner Ad

Preview 2026 AFL Draft General Discussion

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Haggas, if you had to make a player comparison against kids just recently drafted what would it look like?

At a guess:

Archie Van Dyk - D Sharp
Wil Malady - M.Marsh
Arki Butler - L. Dovaston
Gabriel Patterson - S.Cumming
Kodah Edwards - L.Carmichael
Jack Pickett - A.Ludowyke
Marlon Neocleous - T.Matthews
Cody Templeton - J.Murray
Kale Matthews-Hampton - H.Dean
Noah Williams - O.Taylor
Harry Van Hattum - L.Emmett
Heath Mellody - H.Barker
Granted these aren't recently drafted comparisons but

For me Van Dyk is more Will Day, less of a bull than Sharp, more wirey/lanky slower in congestion and a touch more balanced to the outside with his overhead marking. But not the talent of Will Day. He's special, shame he's got that foot that probably ruins him.

Edwards is very much Robbie Gray in style, he's quick, dangerous a a real weapon when on fire.
 
Last edited:
Haggas, if you had to make a player comparison against kids just recently drafted what would it look like?

At a guess:

Archie Van Dyk - D Sharp
Wil Malady - M.Marsh
Arki Butler - L. Dovaston
Gabriel Patterson - S.Cumming
Kodah Edwards - L.Carmichael
Jack Pickett - A.Ludowyke
Marlon Neocleous - T.Matthews
Cody Templeton - J.Murray
Kale Matthews-Hampton - H.Dean
Noah Williams - O.Taylor
Harry Van Hattum - L.Emmett
Heath Mellody - H.Barker
AFL Comparison for Butler would be early days Petracca for me, incredible in the FWD 50
 

Arki Butler (Vic Metro)
Dougie Cochrane (SA/Port NGA)
Cody Walker (Vic Country/Carl F/S)
Gabriel Patterson (SA)
Harry Van Hattum (Vic Metro)
Caylen Murray (Qld/Bris Academy)
Marlon Neocleous (Vic Country)
Lewis Houndsome (Vic Metro)
Koby LeCras (WA)
Archie Van Dyk (SA)
 

Arki Butler (Vic Metro)
Dougie Cochrane (SA/Port NGA)
Cody Walker (Vic Country/Carl F/S)
Gabriel Patterson (SA)
Harry Van Hattum (Vic Metro)
Caylen Murray (Qld/Bris Academy)
Marlon Neocleous (Vic Country)
Lewis Houndsome (Vic Metro)
Koby LeCras (WA)
Archie Van Dyk (SA)
SA & VC look to be strong again next year looking at some of those names.
 

Arki Butler (Vic Metro)
Dougie Cochrane (SA/Port NGA)
Cody Walker (Vic Country/Carl F/S)
Gabriel Patterson (SA)
Harry Van Hattum (Vic Metro)
Caylen Murray (Qld/Bris Academy)
Marlon Neocleous (Vic Country)
Lewis Houndsome (Vic Metro)
Koby LeCras (WA)
Archie Van Dyk (SA)
off course 2 players there whose dad played for us but not enough games for father son
 

Remove this Banner Ad


Arki Butler (Vic Metro)
Dougie Cochrane (SA/Port NGA)
Cody Walker (Vic Country/Carl F/S)
Gabriel Patterson (SA)
Harry Van Hattum (Vic Metro)
Caylen Murray (Qld/Bris Academy)
Marlon Neocleous (Vic Country)
Lewis Houndsome (Vic Metro)
Koby LeCras (WA)
Archie Van Dyk (SA)
Who are the notable omissions from this list at an early stage? Jack Pickett & Noah Williams?

I also really like the look of WC NGA Garrison Kenh
 

Arki Butler (Vic Metro)
Dougie Cochrane (SA/Port NGA)
Cody Walker (Vic Country/Carl F/S)
Gabriel Patterson (SA)
Harry Van Hattum (Vic Metro)
Caylen Murray (Qld/Bris Academy)
Marlon Neocleous (Vic Country)
Lewis Houndsome (Vic Metro)
Koby LeCras (WA)
Archie Van Dyk (SA)
Based on the last 5 iterations 3 or 4 of these will go after 25+ or not at all lol.
 
For context, this is last year's one.


Picks 1, 2, 4, 6, 13, 27, 49, 50, 56 and rookie draft pick 3.
Yeah it’s the 2nd & 3rd tier boys that everyone should be keeping an eye on.
They’re the ones that fly under the radar and elevate their game in the next 12 months.

However the media will roll with mostly these lads for a while.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Who are the notable omissions from this list at an early stage? Jack Pickett & Noah Williams?

I also really like the look of WC NGA Garrison Kenh
Kyan Perera, the Subiaco speedster and son of former Sri Lanka international cricketer Suresh, is another WCE NGA to watch.

He may choose cricket as his preferred sport but being named in the 2025/26 WAFL 18's summer squad will at least give him some encouragement to pursue footy.

Super quick small forward.
 
Having not watched much of any of these boys outside of Cochrane, Walker and the West Coast boys, is Arki a pure small at AFL-level or more the Zac Bailey mould of being able to run through the guts
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top