Remove this Banner Ad

Training 2026 Preseason

🄰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Are we really still theorising Banfield in the best 23 in the lords year of 2026?

It’s going to be a long off-season…
He wasn't best 23 in the year of 2025...

Or 2024, or 2023 and so on
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

He wasn't best 23 in the year of 2025...

Or 2024, or 2023 and so on
And yet he still got coaches votes . So doing stuff we don’t see I guess

Counting errors seen others do just as much or more , and those with less errors some are not getting near the ball

I know BF fans are the experts and should pick the team each week , the coach choice should he removed as he has no idea what keeps the fans happy šŸ˜†
 
Last edited:
He wasn't best 23 in the year of 2025...

Or 2024, or 2023 and so on
Played 21 games so he was best 23 in 2025.

I would prefer to use walker in the backline over Banfield. Where that leaves Banfield as best 23 in 2026 is anyone's guess.
 
Played 21 games so he was best 23 in 2025.

I would prefer to use walker in the backline over Banfield. Where that leaves Banfield as best 23 in 2026 is anyone's guess.

Brisbane šŸ† Banfield wouldn't be good enough to make their 23. Freo just managed a finals game and lost. Banfield was good enough to make the team. Let that sink in.

He's terrible
 
My best football was played as an athletic full back that could beat his man to the ball or catch up and spoil it to the boundary line. I was instructed not to do so but my instinct when i won the ball was to keep running and look to distribute the ball to keep the momentum going. Only problem was that I was a shit kick and if my foot met the ball everyone would put their head in their hands and start rocking in the corner. Oh sorry were we talking about Walker?
Anyway Pearce seems to know when to go and when not to go, hopefully Walker can learn it too.
That sounds very similar to Pearce
 
Brisbane šŸ† Banfield wouldn't be good enough to make their 23. Freo just managed a finals game and lost. Banfield was good enough to make the team. Let that sink in.

He's terrible
I honestly dont see a spot for him in the backline anymore. Walker and McVee offer more

Peel is probably the best place for him with a call up here and there when need a fill in.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

No one inside or outside the club would argue Banfield is best 23 based on skill or ability alone. But hes incredibly durable and consistent which means as long Young, Wagner, Worner, Fyfe, Walters, Walker, Sturt kept missing extended periods of games with injury, there was always a spot for him somewhere.
 
Sepultura are pretty shit šŸ˜‰ that's a fact lol
Loop Trump GIF
 

🄰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Getting games because of injury/coaches making the wrong call doesn't make you best 23 :sweatsmile:

Drink more of the kool aid.
Lmao... Best 23 at a given point in time is the players that will field the team on match day. So if there are injuries, or in the case of Banners 2025 he took his chance when moved into defence with limited experience but still managed to contribute to our team defence, especially during that stretch of wins. This made him best 23..COMPRENDO?! Lol

If you want best 23 on paper go stick to ya fantasy footy where the players don't need take the field lol šŸ˜‚
 
I honestly dont see a spot for him in the backline anymore. Walker and McVee offer more

Peel is probably the best place for him with a call up here and there when need a fill in.
5 on the bench now. I can't think of a better utility player from our list in that 5th spot.
 
No one inside or outside the club would argue Banfield is best 23 based on skill or ability alone. But hes incredibly durable and consistent which means as long Young, Wagner, Worner, Fyfe, Walters, Walker, Sturt kept missing extended periods of games with injury, there was always a spot for him somewhere.
This. It's like the haters seem to lack this comprehension. God forbid we do have a shocking run of injuries, having a utility player like banners in the squad , who can step in and perform his role is understated. Not even probably on much coin in comparison to others lol
 
A great listen from Young. Spent a week in Doha, getting ready for preseason. Sounds super committed.



Great listen, thanks for posting.

Easy to gloss over how interrupted his pre season was last year, and how good he was off that prep when he was available. Full program this year sounds good!

Thought his commentary around our (lack off) possession game last year was interesting too. Obviously a focus point.
 
Lmao... Best 23 at a given point in time is the players that will field the team on match day. So if there are injuries, or in the case of Banners 2025 he took his chance when moved into defence with limited experience but still managed to contribute to our team defence, especially during that stretch of wins. This made him best 23..COMPRENDO?! Lol

If you want best 23 on paper go stick to ya fantasy footy where the players don't need take the field lol šŸ˜‚
I'm with you. I just don't get the hate for Banfield.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Training 2026 Preseason

🄰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top