Hawks, IMO. As for the specific year? Either 2008 or 2011.
He played deeper/closer to goal in 2008, was more athletic and mobile, and was a better overhead and contested marker. He injured his thumb and shoulder after that and was never quite the same at marking the ball.
He played higher up...
Logan McDonald is so goddamn slow. Such a mediocre athlete. I expect those types to be more skilled natural footballers to compensate but he leaves me unsatisfied.
Was it better than any of Curnow's seasons? How does it rank compared to C. Curnow, T. Cloke, J. Kennedy, L. Franklin, J. Reiwoldt, T. Hawkins, J. Roughead, J. Cameron, T. Walker, and T. Lynch? I think that about covers the best KPFs of the 2010s and onward.
Jesse seemingly combined Travis...
Updated! Another prelim.
2019: Finishes 2nd on the ladder; out in straight sets
2020: Finishes 2nd on the ladder; loses a home prelim
2021: Finishes 4th on the ladder; out in straight sets
2022: Finishes 6th on the ladder; loses an away prelim
2023: Finishes 2nd on the ladder; loses in the...
Why would anyone want to discuss one of the worst teams in the AFL? It's been repeated ad nauseam. I think you're acting paranoid. Stop derailing the thread.
This is a legitimate thread. I noticed several parallels between these two eras, including the final game of the season being a Finals-deciding matchup against Port Adelaide. Not everything has an agenda. Chill.
Seeing Hogan reach his potential must hurt. It just wasn't meant to be. There's an alternate reality where he's doing this for Freo, they make multiple Finals, and Ross is still the coach.
Both began with breakout Finals appearances, followed up with disappointing seasons of missing the eight. If I'm not mistaken, the Chris Connolly era was seen as a talented list underperforming and not meeting expectations. They turned it around in the back half of 2006, finished in the top...