That was my point, not that I think he will get dropped either.
I don't care about stats, rankings etc.
If posters think Parish could be dropped because he wasn't hard enough in the contest for example, that's maybe something the coaches wanted that he has to work on in the VFL for a week or...
You can leave out Hollands and still give me 2/3rds of Carlton's list to prove my point, which is that players aren't dropped because they miss the best 23 cutoff.
And that cutoff sure as shit shouldn't be based on some vague ranking system.
I actually never stated I wanted Parish dropped, I just think your justification to all of the "non educated posters" is stupid.
Do you think George Hewett is Carlton's 24th best player?
Your argument is terribly simplistic and there are many more reasons one might want him dropped.
Also...