Now probably yes
Before drafting no.
This forum was hopelessly divided about TB. You read this yourself.
I always rated JB, but he's improved since coming to us.
If you asked AFL watchers to name 10 A grade players - I doubt either would be on that list.
That's not the point
They were the only A graders on the market.
You want A graders...but only the right kind of A graders...it doesn't work that way as the pool of high end talent is tiny.
If you want an A grade player, you accept them warts and all.
I'm pretty sure Petracca was Hawthorn...
Honestly, posts like this grind my gears.
How many A graders have we got since Sam was boss?
Merrett - oh hang on he stayed
Bailey Smith - nope, Geelong
Petracca - nope GCS
Butters isn't coming. Humphrey - well perhaps, but I'm not convinced GCS will just let him walk.
So who then? The...
I agree mate
It gets lost in here that in the pursuit of 'A-Graders' there are some good players who get ignored.
Hewett absolutely would be a top class addition in the same way Matt Kennedy bolstered the Dogs.
Big bodied accumulator who is rarely injured. And he'd cost next to nothing...
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1508191/gold-star-collingwood-magpies-star-scott-pendlebury-gets-afl-approval-to-wear-special-guernsey-in-record-breaking-game
Good lord - this is sooo tacky.
You're the games record holder - so where a gold lame number. What next cheerleaders with pom-poms who...
That was a very good win in the end. Everyone played their role.
I did spot something and I wondered if anyone else did, or did I imagine it :)
With 9 odd mins to go in Q2 the game changed hard towards the Suns and they got their run on.
I noticed that was when, for some reason, Calsher Dear...
OMG
David King - STFU
"Warner decided to leave it for Charlie".........no you muppet, Warner isn't even in the camera shot. He's 70 meters away.
I'd be happy for someone to drag King out the back and shoot him.
I'm sure it will be Weddle back alongside Scrimshaw
Harry to the wing.
Dalton Fwd / Mid and Finn tagging Petracca
If Finn isn't tagging - why is he in?
At least GCS are easy to read!
Ballard and Jeffrey out - Mac Andrew and Wil Powell back to defence. JUH takes Mac's spot up forward.
Our...
Another brilliant job by the team down at Dingley!
Awesome and respectful Anzac strip - easily the best
Kudos though to St Kilda and WB for their efforts - they look great and have the names of their fallen players on the back.
No idea why Sydney and Brisbane couldn't be bothered to do one...
We have moved on from Finn.
He's out along with Harry, Henry and Max.
It's brutal but it seems to be the way Sam is thinking for the future.
With that mindset the changes:
Dalton for Moore
Scrimshaw for Sicily
McCabe is stiff but you aren't leaving Gunston out.
Next match Moore and Sicily...
No aimed at you mate
Hollands admitted to not sleeping well for a number of days pre-match.
It is now emerging he had a full blown panic attack pre-match and during.
I've had them.
Not a 'feeling unwell' but a full blown panic attack sees your heart rate spike into the 150+ category, you...
I haven't seen Ramsden mentioned at all for this game.
I thought he'd really kicked on last season and would be knocking on the door this year.
I'd have thought this game would be tailor made for Max with Cholly missing.
Seems to have been forgotten and looks set to be the next Jai Serong...