We need more from Rowy, he needed to stand up tonight with our two big outs. Tackled his guts out after the poor one he missed early but he needed to get the ball.
I think you can throw Jordan into the same basket. If he isn't tagging is he doing enough?
Hopping into Cleary and Co Warner but...
You can take the boy out of Carlton but you cant take the Carlton out of the boy. Charlie was piss weak after the 1st. Some of the worst umpiring ive seen.
If anyone would like some discounted tickets for opening round please reach out. I have a family pass (2 adults, 2 kids) + additional 1 adult ticket. Reservered seating Victor Trumper concourse Bay 16. Full cost was $140. Any offers considered.
He is a good honest worker. If his pressure is off then something is wrong with him physically, I don't think anyone could question his effort...but we need more from him, he is more or less the same player from debut to now. He has really plateaued since 22 season.
Can any of the more...
I wouldnt mind seeing Roberts get a run as a genuine mid especially if the losses keep stacking up. I like him but would hope he is easily enough replaced I'm the backline.
He has his flaws but he is a tough bugger.
I agree, availability I imagine is playing at least some part when it comes to strategy (Gulden alone totally changes our offence). I for one definitely won't be making a complete judgement on his ability this early especially given the circumstances. I'm feeling quite positive about what he can...
This has probably already been discussed but anyway. I think the main difference between Cox's coaching and Longmires is, Cox seems to be way more focused on the opposition and is constantly changing our methods in an attempt to disrupt our opponents. John of course tried to takeaway oppos...
You could argue he has done to some degree the first 5 points, but doesn't seem to stick the course with any of them.
As for point 7, totally understand wanting to drop underperforming senior guys but there isn't anyone to bring in except Ladhams or underdone Adams, nor sure it would send the...
I apologise for putting words in your mouth. That was just what I was interpreting from your posts, I've got that wrong sorry.
We are getting into the weeds a little and I'm not even sure our opinions are all that different.
I'm happy to accept that Snell and others are currently more viable...
Yes I clearly don't understand how player development works.
I was under the impression that the ranking/rating of players was fluid.
Apparently the development of each player is linear and there is never any change to the supposed order. News to me, thanks for the education.
Yes mate not going to argue any of that. I've included him as potentially best 22 because we haven't seen him yet so potentially could leapfrog some. Equally he could be a flop and delist at contract expiry.
I didn't bother listing Snell, Edwards etc as they have had time to make the 22 but...
Best 22 locks currently out
Mills, Papley, Amartey, Gulden, Melican.
Arguably best 22 fit and in form
Cunningham, Fox, Adams
Potentially best 22
Datoli, Riak,
Not including Logan.
Any list in the comp is going to struggle with depth with that many missing. That's lots of quality and...