Recent content by marcmurphy3

  1. marcmurphy3

    Autopsy 2022 Rd 21 Last quarter surge masks woeful performance

    True. It shouldn't be though. If it's not deemed a reportable offence it shouldn't matter what the outcome is.
  2. marcmurphy3

    Autopsy 2022 Rd 21 Last quarter surge masks woeful performance

    As dumb as the Cripps piece of play was it is pretty much exactly the same as Willie rioli early this year accept riolis looked even worse and he got off.
  3. marcmurphy3

    Autopsy 2022 Rd 21 Last quarter surge masks woeful performance

    Is anyone else concerned that all Voss mentions in press conferences regarding reasons for our loss last and this week is contest work? Doesn't mention our spectacular skill errors, lack of spread or unwillingness to shut down the opposition. I put that loss and last week down to alot more then...
  4. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. List Management 2022

    I think Dow just eroded what was left of his trade value. Won't even get a 3rd rounder now
  5. marcmurphy3

    Autopsy 2022 Rd 21 Last quarter surge masks woeful performance

    Without Cripps, Kennedy and Hewett? The the thought going up against the dees with a midfield of Walsh, Dow, Cerra and Fisher is horrifying.
  6. marcmurphy3

    Autopsy 2022 Rd 21 Last quarter surge masks woeful performance

    No he's out for 2 weeks with fractured jaw.
  7. marcmurphy3

    Game Day Rnd 21 - Carlton v Brisbane Game Day

    For all the talk of needing to get physical not sure cripps getting himself suspended helps us. We were also certainly going to lose this game anyway. Without Cripps I doubt we can win either of the next 2 either
  8. marcmurphy3

    Speculation Tim Taranto

    Yeah that's my confusion with all the conjecture over Grundy. I can see how it helps Collingwood to move him on but I struggle to see how it helps anyone else. Can't think of a club that needs a ruckman that bad that they would take a 29 year old (who hadnt even been playing well) on a 1...
  9. marcmurphy3

    Nick Daicos vs Andrew Brayshaw

    Depends how many running defenders they pick. I would have Daicos 6th in line after Sinclair, Brayshaw, Saad, Docherty and Dale. If I had to guess though I would lean towards him getting picked. Pies have had a great year without many standout individual players. They will want to recognise a...
  10. marcmurphy3

    Nick Daicos vs Andrew Brayshaw

    I guess it depends on your definition of by a mile. In my view one of them is a high chance of being the brownlow medallist while the other is 50-50 chance of being in the AA squad of 40 (still a great achievement for a first year player). For me that constitutes by a mile.
  11. marcmurphy3

    Nick Daicos vs Andrew Brayshaw

    In my view he is having a better season by a mile You clearly you disagree. Fair enough. Don't think I backtracked at all.
  12. marcmurphy3

    Nick Daicos vs Andrew Brayshaw

    There are 30 players that are averaging between 25 and 30 disposals this year. Just because they have comparable numbers doesn't mean they are having comparable seasons. I think you'd struggle to find many non pies supporters that would disagree with me on that. Not a crack at Daicos by the...
  13. marcmurphy3

    Your current top 5 most exciting players? And how do they stack up against the rest?

    For us I'd go 1. Curnow 2. Saad 3. Cripps 4. McKay 5. DeKoning If looking at the whole comp I'd go 1. Bolton 2. Curnow 3. Martin 4. Petracca 5. Cameron (Charlie)
  14. marcmurphy3

    Nick Daicos vs Andrew Brayshaw

    Brayshaw has had a better season by a mile but for the future I take Daicos.