Remove this Banner Ad

Recent content by MrFoster

  1. M

    Autopsy Round 9 St Kilda vs GC Suns

    Think it would be Out: LOC, Brynes, Wilkie, Philipou, Carrol Ins: Nas, Ryan, Keeler, Boxshall, Hastie Maybe 1 too many changes, but apart from Nas and Ryan back, we really need contested ball ability (Boxshall) and drive from half back (Hastie). Macrae is lucky but given that we couldn't win...
  2. M

    Autopsy Round 9 St Kilda vs GC Suns

    Think the long bombs are also due to the fact that it’s the easiest kick to execute, no skill/time/thinking needed, when you are always under pressure, fumbling or just have poor skills (which we are guilty of), long bomb and hope is the only option.. This wouldn’t improve much even if we had...
  3. M

    Game Day Rnd 9 | Gold Coast Suns v St Kilda TIO Stadium, Darwin | Sat May 9 | 7:10pm AEST

    Again, not enough instructions from coaches to tell him to keep it simple, he is not good enough or experienced enough to dummy and walk through 2-3 players, did the same against Carlton too..
  4. M

    Game Day Rnd 9 | Gold Coast Suns v St Kilda TIO Stadium, Darwin | Sat May 9 | 7:10pm AEST

    Really should have played Boxhall, we don’t need more runners (Byrne), we need to win the ball. Think that’s a selection mistake.
  5. M

    Game Day Rnd 9 | Gold Coast Suns v St Kilda TIO Stadium, Darwin | Sat May 9 | 7:10pm AEST

    We just don’t have enough mids/hybrid mids that can win ball cleanly with composure. Macrae and Hall are probably the only 2 in the midfield and Macrae is slow.
  6. M

    Autopsy Round 8 | St Kilda vs Carlscum

    Steele has not looked happy on the field for the last 2-3 years. That doesn’t bold well being the captain, with young mids needing minutes, think letting Steele leave is the right move. Macrae is more of a ball winner whilst being able to play on the wing/half forward flank if required.
  7. M

    Game Day Rnd 8 | Carlton vSt Kilda Marvel Stadium | Sat May 2 | 7:35pm AEST Fox/Kayo

    Let’s be honest, neither Higgins or Wilson will help us in the midfield. Macrae at least is a midfielder and got 31 possessions in the VFL today, he is playing a second game for the day I think. LOC is more a mystery, should have picked Boxhall or Tarau I think.
  8. M

    Game Day Rnd 8 | Carlton vSt Kilda Marvel Stadium | Sat May 2 | 7:35pm AEST Fox/Kayo

    It’s easy to see, we’re not a contested team, against quality opposition, our mids can’t win a clean ball to save ourselves, and we start to panick with the ball ourselves. having NAS, Hill, Poo and Henry all in one team when you don’t have the ball doesn’t help. Carlton basically adopted the...
  9. M

    Game Day Rnd 8 | Carlton vSt Kilda Marvel Stadium | Sat May 2 | 7:35pm AEST Fox/Kayo

    Windhager and Sinclair really really poor. No care for the ball, need a big bake both of them. Winghager has been a butcher the entire game last week too
  10. M

    Autopsy Rnd 7 | St Kilda vs West Coast

    Agree.. he is actually a goal kicking mid in the juniors. In the backline, he is iffy, lots of fumbling and dodgy kick doesn't bold well.. We need Windhager to re-discover his round 1 2025 form where he dominated from the middle against collingwood.. At half-back, Carrol is a much better...
  11. M

    Autopsy Rnd 7 | St Kilda vs West Coast

    Carroll's left peg is a weapon.. also has a ok contested game actually... so playing half back, he can rebound better than Windghager for example who tends to skies his kicks and is error prone (turned over at least 4 kicks today, he is not the only one today). He just needs more confidence...
  12. M

    Autopsy Rnd 7 | St Kilda vs West Coast

    From a physique perspective yes 185cm is not tall, but Neale, Daicos, Ashcroft, Butters, walsh, Warner, Serong, Brayshaw, Rowell all 185cm and shorter.
  13. M

    Autopsy Rnd 7 | St Kilda vs West Coast

    Yes, apart from a couple of rushed handballs.. Garcia had a really really good game.. if can gathered the ball without fumbling a little better like Neale, he'll be our own elite ball winner..
  14. M

    Autopsy Rnd 6 Adelaide vs StKilda

    I agree we play a bruise free brand of football e.g. relies on gut run and hitting free open players, not taking on tacklers and draw the opposition or kicking to forwards’ advantage for a contested mark, we have been playing like this for 10+ years, which is why we as a team are poor at winning...
  15. M

    Autopsy Rnd 6 Adelaide vs StKilda

    TDK had a back issue late in the first/early 2nd quarter, can barely run. Stupid to keep playing him I think. Got killed in the middle there after, there’s no way you can jump/play ruck with an aching back. Windhager is ineffective as a half back, put Nas back there who can actually set up...

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom