Matthew Hayden shouldn't be within a bulls roar of the test side. He has proved time and time again that he is a great Shield/County player, but has a serious technical flaw that means he cannot makke the next step to play Test cricket.
Same goes for Darren Lehmann and Stuart Law.
Test
M...
Fair enough...
Talent was the wrong choice of words.
But he's basically playing at 90% what he used to - he never has those games where he tears the opposition apart anymore.
Matt
All deals in footy go both ways...
Obviously, Carlton do not want to reach the demands - possibly due to salary cap restrictions.
The demands may be too high (which I suspect)...
I think you may find that they all end up staying with Carlton anyway...
I would imagine...
Matt
Based on these replies, I think I'll cop it for this...
I would rather a round 12 pick than Rehn.
Analyse the 2
Rd 12 pick - A Ramanauskas was taken then.
Basically, most top 20's will be young (under 20), and likely to play a lot of good footy for the club for the next 10 years.
Rehn is an...
I think it lacks a key big man...
McGregor never came on this year
Robran plays back a lot, and is inconsistent when he is forward...
Crowell and Perrie are not very good yet, and it will take them at least a season or 2 before they are ready.
Welsh and Vardy are very inconsistent.
McLeod...
Brainwashing from an early age did the trick to make me Collingwood.
My extended family 'owns' (i.e. reserves every year) an entire MCG row for Collingwood home games.
Matt
You call lolly-legs lloyd a fair player?
he who throws himself on the ground in every contest and always plays for the free kick?
Next you'll tell me Silvagni is a fair player and doesn't cheat/hold/scrag his opponent in every contest.
And that Libba's tactics of scratching and holding...
A lot of players that age develop early.
I know a guy that played for my club that was killing everyone in the U14's and U16's because he was a huge kick for his age (60+ metres) and a lot bigger than the rest.
But he never really developed beyond that so he ended up playing U18 footy in a...
Congratulations Rowdy and Crossy.
Don - I think your comments on Brown are farily harsh and uncalled for.
Brown was a brilliant player when fully fit in the early 90's.
When on the wing he oftened carved up his opponents.
It is sad that he is often remembered for his later years... but what...
Champion would never have been near the top 50 in the game though.
Expect to add Gavin Crosisca, and maybe Gavin Brown to that list shortly too.
Crosisca not having ever been quite near the top however
Matt
You've summed him up beautifully.
The guy's an even more opinionated, know-all moron in his paper.
He has never come up with 1 decent idea in his life.
There isn't a brain in the w***er's head.
Matt
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.