Recent content by Mudman85

Anyone else out of contract that nuffies can threaten to walk to PSD? McAdam?

I said 37 for Brockman + later pick or a pick swap. It ended up 44 and an extra pick. So very similar on points Settled 5 days before the end of trade period. He wasn’t going to PSD

So he wasn’t walked to the PSD? I’m shocked!

We are also relying on media reports of what was offered/rejected 😂 I will abstain from commenting further until it’s done but stand by my comment that psd is good for nobody in this situation and brokering future trades.

Wasn’t referring to you specifically here but more comments in general. I have no skin in the game here. Don’t want him to come to Freo and trying to see it from a neutral point of view. Just think that walking a guy to psd is worst outcome for all parties when the difference between 37 and 44...

This is what I mean, you are torn between “he is going to be a gun” and “he isn’t worth more than 44”. Can’t have it both ways. If I was him and having committed to joining the club I’d be a bit disappointed they didn’t rate me any higher than my draft year and would happily walk me to the pre...

Why don’t you skip him in the psd and take him in the rookie then and pay him sweet fa

You tell me. You guys want him.

46. You would expect that after two years on an AFL list he is worth more than that, if he isn’t then why would you want to recruit him anyway. Go for it, waste pick 1 in psd on him when you could get a mature age player who could probably walk into the current 22.

Nobody? Probably better players than 37 & 44.

Yeah I get that but he wants you and you want him. Just pay 37 for Brockman and 54. Then pick up best available player at pick 1 in psd who will probably be better than pick 37

Unless you had been treated exceptionally badly by current club which doesn’t seem to be the case

How would you feel as a player being walked to PSD? New club wants you for effectively nothing

This is my point haha, just say I want to play at WC with my mate.

Was more so saying the guys with kids were closer to the end than start, where Freo could be on the verge of a baby boom! It’s obvious he wants to be at the eagles and that’s fine, I just thought it was an odd thing to bring up the club having more fathers as a reason when you don’t have to...