Recent content by PendlesPremiers

Looks like we... disagree.

Mayne stopped right where the mark was taken then moved laterally as Suckling moved around. Wrong call there.

1. Keath was very composed in his argument- did well to present his thinking calmly despite being frustrated. 2. If he did make contact (and he did), he's forcing the ump into a decision with something that's black and white in the rules (even if we all agree it was soft)

Did you see the alternate angle clearly showing him gouging Neale? Greene's no martyr.

My team may be smashed, but if I've educated a nuffie on an AFL forum I'll count that as a win on such a crappy day.

Are you drunk? It's the very last sentence of the rule you posted yourself! 'field Umpire shall award a Free Kick against that Player if, upon being Correctly Tackled, the Player does not Correctly Dispose or genuinely attempt to Correctly Dispose'

I know the rule very well- if we just disagree on whether or not he tried to kick it, then fine, that's the disagreement.

Incorrect. If he hasn't had prior opportunity he only needs to make a genuine attempt, regardless of whether it's successful or not.

Not true (I've watched the replay on Kayo a few times now), but my team's getting smashed and I should move on.

Right, so you're changing your argument? Grundy should have had a free.

Did you not see his hand on Grundy's number???

Which is wrong if he didn't have prior (which he didn't) and tried to legally dispose of it (which he did).

Sidey tackled immediately, tried to kick it... HTB. Bullshit.

Clear front on contact. Bullshit

Why was that holding the ball against Cotch? He was tackled immediately and made an attempt.