Recent content by SilKouta

  1. S

    Voting

    Just noticed on the Carlton web site that our memebership numbers are up on the nice to have, which is great and I believe a lot of this has to do with the recruits, however it is fairly dramatic increase in numbers, so it can mean only one thing Smorgan and co are in big trouble. I would like...
  2. S

    Forget Fisher

    I have noticed over the last few months that Brad Fisher is higly rated on this board. However I would just like to say apart from about 3-4 games he has rarely performed. I understand injuries do have an impact, but during all the the bad performances this year i.e Hawthorn, Collingwood and...
  3. S

    The frustration continues...

    i must be watching a different walker to most, his disposal looks fine to me....he seems to cop a lot of unfair criticism IMO, i dont remember him overkicking a lot of targets...i do recall him doing that once, but it is easier to pick out these instances rather than the good ones.....the goal...
  4. S

    Livingston MIA again

    Hi all, whats the deal with Livingston Rnd 1 Good, Rnd 2 OK, RD 3 gone ,Rd 4 Gone. I understand there may be an issue with Team balance, but cannot understand some of the logic with teague the one dimensional fister in the team and Livingston out. I would think long spells in the seniors would...
  5. S

    Pagans Persitence with certain players

    Stokesy- I understand what you are saying, with Chambers I meant he had only been at Carlton for one year and with Sporn the guy has held Hird to limited impact a few times and that says something. I think Pagan needs to make a decision with Wiggins to give him a permanent role if he is too...
  6. S

    Pagans Persitence with certain players

    Hi all I have tried to stay positive in the last few years where we have been in terrible form however I have a few questions to pose: Why does Denis persist with Adrian de Luca? I understand he probably does have a good attitude, trains hard and offers something different, however he has...
  7. S

    Whitnall and Stevens

    Mike Sheahan what an absolute tosser
  8. S

    Training this morning

    McLaren is suddenly a gun. one hell of a very ordinary looking unit young Dylan. hey look at it this way at least he can contest, half the time that is all we need from a ruckmen thats why I rate French because he can contest, unlike De Luca
  9. S

    Training this morning

    Hey guys I am new to all this but have been a reader for a while now, I believe the blues had their first training session this morning and I was wandering whether McLaren was training with us
Top Bottom