Recent content by Souup

  1. S

    Teams Rate My SC Team 2020 (Pre-season edition)

    Not huge on Doedee, Whitfield or Smith but I get the picks. I see 12 keepers with Smith a potential keeper which would make it 13. Looks solid overall. Running with this at the moment. Some things to note: - I like Docherty but see the 4 premiums in defense I've chosen as ahead of him. If...
  2. S

    Teams Rate My SC Team 2020 (Pre-season edition)

    He played in the practice match a couple of days ago, he's fine.
  3. S

    Teams Rate My SC Team 2020 (Pre-season edition)

    Crisp, Gunston and De Goey are interesting PODs. All 3 have question marks but could definitely pay off. Things I'd strongly suggest changing - If you like Westhoff, pick him in the forward line - Your defensive bench rookies won't play and neither will Ash. Highly recommend Gould and Young if...
  4. S

    Leagues Bigfooty League Sign-Ups 2020 - CLOSING MARCH 7

    Team Name: Chicken Soup Rank: 3,555
  5. S

    Teams Rate My SC Team 2020 (Pre-season edition)

    Well yeah, it's why he's 383K, I cited his inconsistency. If he wasn't inconsistent he wouldn't be priced 383K. Everyone at that price has a reason they're priced that way otherwise they'd be premiums. He's been in the AFL for 3 years and came off a broken leg in his first season and played...
  6. S

    Teams Rate My SC Team 2020 (Pre-season edition)

    I'm not saying he's a lock - just saying those that are dismissing it as a bad pick have no idea who he is or what his role in the side is. He was recently added to the leadership group which further emphasizes the view of him from within. There are certainly some very good reasons to pick him...
  7. S

    Teams Rate My SC Team 2020 (Pre-season edition)

    The Daw pick doesn't make sense - better off going a rookie. Anyone dismissing Simpkin is only doing so because they know nothing of our list and have no idea what's going on at the club. I haven't picked him but hard to argue the pick considering he'll basically play full time midfield and...
  8. S

    Teams Rate My SC Team 2020 (Pre-season edition)

    No chance. Not sure why he's a regular in Supercoach sides at this stage - suppose as a placeholder Sent from my Pixel 4 XL using Tapatalk
  9. S

    Teams Rate My SC Team 2020 (Pre-season edition)

    We share 10/13 premos with differences being You have Lloyd I have Laird You have Houston I have DBJ You have Macrae I have Dunkley You have $100 in the bank I have 77.4K Needless to say it's probably the best team I've seen on here [emoji106] Sent from my Pixel 4 XL using Tapatalk
  10. S

    Position 2020 Forwards

    If Ceglar is the number 1 ruck his floor is 90 IMO - in his 3 games playing sole ruck he averaged 15.6 disposals, 36 hitouts, 3.6 tackles and 3.6 marks which is very encouraging. He's not just a beanpole there to win a tap but manages to find the footy well around the ground. He had games last...
  11. S

    Position 2020 Forwards

    Jonathan Ceglar. Averaged 95 in the last 3 games last season when he was given full time ruck duties with McEvoy playing key defense. How did Hawthorn go in these 3 games? They beat GWS and West Coast away (arguably 2 of the hardest games to win) and Gold Coast at home. Hawthorn traded away...
  12. S

    Review 2019 AFL National Draft

    I'm down on the Comben pick as I'm a big wrap on Thilthorpe next year with a first rounder if he's there. Hard to see us wanting a ruckmen/tall forward with a 1st rounder next year based on the Comben pick. Anyway I'll back Comben and the other lads in - they're Shinboners now. Also got a sick...
  13. S

    Review 2019 AFL National Draft

    He's a known commodity - you know what you're getting with him. Apart from Rowell, Anderson and Green he's the next most likely to make it at the top level based on exposed form. Recruiters love potential which is why guys like Robertson and Gould slide while Kysiah Pickett and Will Day go 10...
  14. S

    Review 2019 AFL National Draft

    Robertson is a legitimate top 5 player in this draft for me. Absolutely shattered that he's fallen so close to our pick with no chance he actually gets there Sent from my Pixel 4 XL using Tapatalk

Top Bottom