Plowman got owned by the magpies last year, Yes. But the vast majority of the time he gets the toughest match up and beats his opponent.
Hes made Papley and Walters look second rate on multiple occasions.
The nature of Plowmans role is of he is beaten, it is in an area of the ground that...
Draft a KPP in the 20s (one of the WA Lads)
Throw at the stump with pick in the 60s. More likely than ever to find a Gem considering the last 24 months.
Take a Ruck Prospect in the Rookie Draft.
Akuei as a Cat B.
Job done.
Understand your point.
But if we're relying on the 38-43rd best player on our list for depth. I'd rather it be an 18 year old with upside, than Matt who doesn't.
To your point. Brander v Cottrell is a no brainer.
If they are unable to find an 18 year old in WA or SA (states who have played basically full seasons) who doesn't have more ability than Matt Cottrell, I'm sorry but they don't deserve to be employed