Remove this Banner Ad

Recent content by thenighthawk

  1. T

    Opinion Stopping small forwards

    It's a considered trade-off in my mind. So much of the Geelong game plan is based around attacking play out of defence and fast transition, that the risk of a small forward getting off the chain is minimal compared to the necessity for that offensive play out of our backline. And an opposition...
  2. T

    2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

    Watson definitely. Bartel will continue to be used as a utility and wont average higher than 100-110. Lake & Boyd & Hodge vs Clarke & Swan & Murphy/Dal Santo?
  3. T

    Opinion Selection and Geelong's best 22

    Re: Our best 22 this is how i see it mids ottens/simpson selwood corey kelly ling bartel forwards hawkins/mooney podsiadly steve j chapman stokes menzel/varcoe/duncan/christensen (+one on the bench) backs taylor scarlett lonergan mackie enright...
  4. T

    Who is the most valuable young Cat?

    Vardy would be the hardest to replace, as it takes more time for a ruckmen/fwd to develop as opposed to a mid. It would be a lot harder to find/draft a new ruckmen if we suddenly lost vardy, but a midfielder could potentially be drafted and up and going in 1-2 years.
  5. T

    Toast Nathan Vardy Looks The Goods

    I remember Fev being sent to start a match on Fraser Gehrig, he had 5 kicked on him in not much more than a quarter from memory. Fair to say he probably didn't learn much though.
  6. T

    2011 Round 5 Trades, Previews & General Discussion

    Re: Round 5 Trades, Previews & General Discussion planning to trade out coad for either thompson (adel) or hibberd (ess) getting hibberd means that i can use mpp to put heppel on the field in my backs and use a rookie mid on the field. but he's on an extended bench and thompson is named at chb.
  7. T

    Selwood

    with enough money to trade in swan (i opted to start with selwood and pendlebury to avoid losing both in the collingwood bye) is it likely to be a worthwhile trade? it's not only a question of their direct points difference, but also the points i may lose from having a captain other than swan...
  8. T

    Player X vs Player Y Thread

    boomer has had a very good preseason and i saw him play against geelong and he looked as fit as ever. still a hard choice for me. personally i'd be locking in pav, and then it's a matter of whether you want consistent good scores throughout the season or some potentially incredible scores and...
  9. T

    Player X vs Player Y Thread

    I need a defender, two midfielder and a forward. My options are: Ryan Lester, Callan Ward, Tom Liberatore and Charlie Dixon Michael Coad, Jared Polec, Daniel Harris and Dion Prestia (who greatly helps my mpp structure) or Michael Coad, Jared Polec, Shaun Atley and Ryan Gamble Not sure if the...
See more

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top